News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by chii on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @03:51AM (#5976384)
> a restaurant that had over priced wine and cheap ingredients would fail miserably in short order, regardless of how many Google ad auctions they won.

unless if there's so many restraurants, and the quality of wine is so subjective that most customers cannot really differentiate it. Then exposure is really the only thing a (time poor) customer can rely on, and thus, by massively spending on advertising, and not on ingredients, they can convert more paying customers than the small, but quality restaurant who nobody knows exists.

I want some way to have word of mouth recommendations work over the net, without it being game-able. perhaps a system where you must pay (a very small token amount) to review?

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by lmm on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @08:29AM (#5977325)
>I want some way to have word of mouth recommendations work over the net, without it being game-able. perhaps a system where you must pay (a very small token amount) to review?

That would make it even more of a money arms race. Ultimately you want something like personal recommendations where people attach their own reputations to their recommendations; google is trying to push something on these lines with google+.

Re:How Google is Killing Organic Search by chii on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @10:33PM (#5982089)
but a person's reputation on the net is inherently non-existant, unless they're forced to use their real name, and is somewhat known/famous.

Being able to create fake reviews and fake recommendations is the same problem as spam in email (cept spam is easier to filter out). If sending email costs the sender some token amount (say, 1cent per 1000 email), it would probably stop majority of spam, because it just became cost-ineffective. That was why i was suggesting paying token amount for writing reviews - tho i have no doubts there are flaws with that idea….