I don't have a strong opinion, but from what I've seen I think tau makes the most sense. These things are fun to think about, because it requires that you think about how pi is used in mathematics and contemplate how we organize and use the concepts related to pi. It's a good brain exercise.
But it's hardly worth getting into a fight over.
Edit: OK, e^(itau)=1, which is quite nice. :-/
e^(iτ) = 1
And, as rotating something by one whole turn is the same as rotating it by any number of whole turns, you can get a nice intuitive series of equivalences that are not as pretty if you where to use pi: 1 = e^0 = e^(iτ) = e^(i2τ) = ...I have a position on Tau simply because it's fun to think and talk about, and I really don't care if stodgy mathematicians disapprove. :)
But I agree that it's a distraction, and I don't think the radial relationship is that important. I got over my annoyance of typing 2 * pi by thinking about it as the ratio of the diameter to the circumference.
Where else in math do you talk about the diameter?
I'm sorry that my personal idiosyncrasy bothers you so much.