Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by polemic on Sunday June 23, 2013 @08:25PM
(#5930205)
Dripping with irony:
Persons wanted on felony charges, such as Mr. Snowden,
should not be allowed to proceed in any further international
travel, other than is necessary to return him to the
United States. Because of the Privacy Act, we cannot
comment on Mr Snowden's passport specifically.
Maybe, after HKSAR's closing jibe[1], they think it's a game?
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by bjornsing on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:17PM
(#5930403)
Speaking of irony, have you seen the ABC News interview[1] with General Keith Alexander, Director of the NSA? He is specifically (and brilliantly) asked if he is confident that the NSA has not broken Hong Kong law (in it's cyber espionage activities). His answer is a mumble about the NSA not violating US law.
Under those circumstances I'd be somewhat careful with the word 'disappointed'... :)
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by ChuckMcM on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:12PM
(#5930380)
That press release is priceless. FWIW that is how you play the game of getting what you want while not getting in trouble. The whole "Well we are still waiting for the correct forms to be filed in the correct way oh and meanwhile he decided to leave."
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by seferphier on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:24PM
(#5930431)
You have to wear clothes to "fit in" with the crowd. It is like camouflaging to your environment: "Sometimes you guys get a bad rap," Alexander said. "From my perspective, what you're doing to figure out vulnerabilities in systems" is great."
It is great because we need to recruit hackers like you to join NSA and find vulnerabilities to gather "intelligence" on everyone!
>The country also needs better sharing between private companies and the government, something that proposed cybersecurity legislation can help fix
Translation: We need to "fix the sharing of data" by forcing private companies, namely, Google, Apple, Facebook, Verizon and Microsoft to hand over all their data on users through legal means.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by fixxer on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:02PM
(#5930340)
When I read these statements (this one, the NSA press statement earlier, etc.), I honestly wonder if anyone on the side of government actually does get the irony.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by jrockway on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:32PM
(#5930460)
I was looking forward to watching the extradition trial snake through the Hong Kong courts, but this is fun too. It really makes the US look like a lot of incompetents trying very hard to not have their incompetence exposed, and we all know how that ends. Snowden: 2, US: 0.
(I'd also like to see a response from all the senators and op-ed columnists that were quick to remind us that Snowden was a "high school dropout" explain why someone so clearly inferior to everyone else can outsmart them so effortlessly.)
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by alexqgb on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:00PM
(#5930332)
Actually, it's not hypocritical at all - which is the problem in a nutshell. We've gotten so used arbitrary enforcement of our own laws (e.g. Clapper) that we're shocked when others take the rule of law seriously. Or at least, more seriously than we do.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by alan_cx on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:06PM
(#5930361)
It is consistent though.... Since we are now sure that non Americans are worth less than Americans to the US government, then it does actually make sense that Hong Kong law could be regarded as secondary and that the demands of US law reigns supreme.
Sadly, I suppose that would be a demonstration of the "arrogance" the US is so often accused of.
Dunno why they dont just leave the bloke to it. Just issue a standard warrant and he's basically never allowed back in the US unless he is prepared to face the charges. Olde days, "exile" was a decent punishment for some one in this position. Why not now? Surely never being allowed home for the rest of his life, to a country so great as the USA must be a terrible punishment for an American, no? What's wrong with a bit of olde skool exile?
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by speeder on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:18PM
(#5930410)
I guess that US knows that it is not great at all, and people will HAPPILY stay exiled (like for example, Bobby Fisher... that after being exiled in this way was very happy to take a Iceland citizenship and dump his US one)
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by malandrew on Monday June 24, 2013 @01:35AM
(#5931212)
I'm sure many in the USG are shocked, and not because they are used to Canada and the UK playing along, but because they think every country would bend to our will because of the fear of any economic sanctions we would impose. The truth is that the more globalism marches on, the less of a consequence a given country would really feel from the US (or any other government for that matter) imposing economic sanctions. Many countries have increasingly diversified their portfolio of trading partners, making economic soft power increasingly irrelevant for smaller sovereign states.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by drrotmos on Monday June 24, 2013 @04:13AM
(#5931633)
HK has nothing to fear with regards to economic sanctions. One can be reasonably sure that even under "One country, two systems", China wouldn't take kindly to economic sanctions against HK, and in the end, the US needs China more than China needs the US.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by mehwoot on Monday June 24, 2013 @02:42AM
(#5931368)
A government will declare whatever it can get away with as legal in order to advance it's agenda (in this case, not getting involved). Remember the Obama administration claims that all the NSA spying is legal anyway. Doesn't mean it is. Doesn't mean there was no legal basis to arrest him.
If Hong Kong even remotely wanted Snowden arrested, he would have been. They wanted nothing to do with the entire matter and so stalled a little bit to let him go.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by mpyne on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:04PM
(#5930569)
Well, remember what Cardinal Richelieu said about being able to convict someone on 6 sentences.
There was a valid criminal complaint, the rest that follows is international politics just like spying or cyberattacks; if Hong Kong had intended to comply with the complaint and arrest Snowden to start extradition proceedings they would have found an excuse to. If Hong Kong did not intend to comply then some reasoning would be found, "mistakenly" or otherwise, within the legal code to technically invalidate or delay the request.
Apparently Hong Kong or China didn't feel like complying. It's just not often we get to see cloak-and-dagger style diplomacy played out so publicly.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by eli on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:48PM
(#5930528)
Honest question: Is there any doubt that Snowden is guilty of the crimes he's charged with (e.g. "unauthorized communication of national defense information")?
"Note that the second and third charges both require the feds to prove that Snowden's release of information to the press was harmful to the United States. This puts our government in the position of attempting to prove that it is harmful to release accurate information about how it is spying on us, and how it is misleading us about spying on us.
Espionage charges usually describe someone with classified information leaking that information to powers hostile to the United States government."
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by eli on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:23PM
(#5930618)
That doesn't seem like it would be nearly as awkward nor as difficult to prove as is implied here.
I would think secret details of spy programs would almost always harm national security (insofar as you believe spying can aide national security). The whole point of spying on communications depends on the targets not knowing they're being listened to.
(Note: I'm not saying the NSA program is good or justified)
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by csense on Monday June 24, 2013 @02:09AM
(#5931294)
"The statute...require[s] the government to prove that the defendant...communicated or made unavailable to an unauthorized person...in any manner prejudicial to the United States or for the benefit of any foreign government to the detriment of the United States...classified information..."
The middle part (labeled (3) by Popehat), as the blog correctly points out, is the reason this is a big controversy and not a straightforward spy case -- it's not at all clear that his disclosures were meant to benefit foreign powers, or that he was attempting to harm the United States.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by eli on Monday June 24, 2013 @07:59AM
(#5932322)
I think you're misreading that. It's whether the action has the effect of prejudicing the United States or benefiting a foreign government regardless of intent.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by fnordfnordfnord on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:33AM
(#5933547)
>It's whether the action has the effect of prejudicing the United States or benefiting a foreign government regardless of intent.
I wonder if there is a precedent supporting successful use of that charge. That's very broad wording. Taken literally, nearly anything you say that isn't puppies and rainbows could qualify.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by kalininalex on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:18PM
(#5930605)
Most definitely. He may well be completely innocent per numerous laws, executive orders and/or the Constitution. An example of the relevant recent piece:
"Executive Order 13526:
Sec. 1.7. Classification Prohibitions and Limitations.
(a) In no case shall information be classified, continue to be maintained as classified, or fail to be declassified in order to:
(1) conceal violations of law, inefficiency, or administrative error.."
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by eli on Sunday June 23, 2013 @10:35PM
(#5930653)
IANAL, but I really don't think that EO (which is not a law) means that you can unilaterally declassify something which you think conceals a violation of law. Also, I'm not aware of anything Snowden disclosed that shows the NSA broke any laws. The FISA court signed off on this stuff, no?
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by mpyne on Sunday June 23, 2013 @11:48PM
(#5930879)
Right. The determinant as to whether information is classified is its effect on national security if widely known.
You don't classify innocuous material just because it might be embarrassing.
But on the other hand you can classify material that risks national security even if it also happens to be embarrassing.
In any event PRISM itself is 0.01% or so in actuality as it was claimed to be, I'm not even sure I'd call PRISM itself embarrassing (it's just a damn web service). The laws under which PRISM operate might be different, but that's not something we can pin on NSA, and it's not something that was secret anyways.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by fnordfnordfnord on Monday June 24, 2013 @09:52AM
(#5932829)
>You don't classify innocuous material just because it might be embarrassing.
You're wrong. That's a well-known, ongoing, and acknowledged problem in the US which even has its own act of Congress as an attempt to deal with the problem.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by fnordfnordfnord on Monday June 24, 2013 @11:48AM
(#5933662)
>The FISA court signed off on this stuff, no?
Who knows? The "court" meets in secret. Its rulings are secret. I'm not even certain that NSA is bound in any meaningful to abide by their decision/advice.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by krapp on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:56PM
(#5930548)
I don't see how there could be.
Although there does seem to be some debate about whether or not what he did should be considered a crime, and whether he's guilty of everything he's charged with.
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by csense on Monday June 24, 2013 @02:03AM
(#5931278)
If he's given a trial by jury, and the jury believes the circumstances justified his actions, they have the option of acquitting him, regardless of how strong the evidence is that he broke the law.
"The courts cannot search the minds of the jurors to find the basis upon which they judge." [2]
In the United States, judges cannot direct a jury to deliver a specific verdict, getting a verdict you didn't like is not an acceptable reason for an appeal, and jurors cannot be punished for the way they decide a case [2].
Re:US 'disappointed' with Hong Kong, asks Latin American cou...
by chii on Sunday June 23, 2013 @09:59PM
(#5930556)
its almost certain that he broke some law, and the US gov't is trying to nail him as an example for other to-be-whistleblowers.
Whether the laws he broke is justified for the sort of revelation his information revealed, i m certain that is the case, but i highly doubt the courts in the US will agree.
1. http://www.info.gov.hk/gia/general/201306/23/P201306230476.h...
Under those circumstances I'd be somewhat careful with the word 'disappointed'... :)
[1] http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politics/2013/06/nsa-chief-keith...
»I am sure we did not break Chinese law.«
As for if they broke Chinese law "when they hacked computer systems IN CHINA", that's another question.
I thought we're technical people here.
yes, a t-shirt with EFF slogan: https://twitter.com/EFF/status/346011010819305472
[1]: http://news.cnet.com/8301-1009_3-57481689-83/nsa-director-fi...
It is great because we need to recruit hackers like you to join NSA and find vulnerabilities to gather "intelligence" on everyone!
>The country also needs better sharing between private companies and the government, something that proposed cybersecurity legislation can help fix
Translation: We need to "fix the sharing of data" by forcing private companies, namely, Google, Apple, Facebook, Verizon and Microsoft to hand over all their data on users through legal means.
Spooky...
see related: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milgram_experiment
(I'd also like to see a response from all the senators and op-ed columnists that were quick to remind us that Snowden was a "high school dropout" explain why someone so clearly inferior to everyone else can outsmart them so effortlessly.)
What exactly does the US think that Hong Kong should have done? Break the law?
What a bunch of hypocrites.
Sadly, I suppose that would be a demonstration of the "arrogance" the US is so often accused of.
Dunno why they dont just leave the bloke to it. Just issue a standard warrant and he's basically never allowed back in the US unless he is prepared to face the charges. Olde days, "exile" was a decent punishment for some one in this position. Why not now? Surely never being allowed home for the rest of his life, to a country so great as the USA must be a terrible punishment for an American, no? What's wrong with a bit of olde skool exile?
Yes, imagine have to flee Nebraska or South Carolina for a place like Amsterdam or Paris or Singapore, etc...
Accused my ass.. more like "IS".
I think the UK and Canada have spoiled the USA to the point where a foreign entity acting as tho they had sovereignty offends and confuses.
If Hong Kong even remotely wanted Snowden arrested, he would have been. They wanted nothing to do with the entire matter and so stalled a little bit to let him go.
There was a valid criminal complaint, the rest that follows is international politics just like spying or cyberattacks; if Hong Kong had intended to comply with the complaint and arrest Snowden to start extradition proceedings they would have found an excuse to. If Hong Kong did not intend to comply then some reasoning would be found, "mistakenly" or otherwise, within the legal code to technically invalidate or delay the request.
Apparently Hong Kong or China didn't feel like complying. It's just not often we get to see cloak-and-dagger style diplomacy played out so publicly.
http://www.popehat.com/2013/06/23/a-look-at-the-charges-agai...
"Note that the second and third charges both require the feds to prove that Snowden's release of information to the press was harmful to the United States. This puts our government in the position of attempting to prove that it is harmful to release accurate information about how it is spying on us, and how it is misleading us about spying on us.
Espionage charges usually describe someone with classified information leaking that information to powers hostile to the United States government."
I would think secret details of spy programs would almost always harm national security (insofar as you believe spying can aide national security). The whole point of spying on communications depends on the targets not knowing they're being listened to.
(Note: I'm not saying the NSA program is good or justified)
That goes double if they can declare him an "enemy combatant" and try in in a secret military tribunal, as opposed to normal kangaroo court.
>I would think secret details of spy programs would almost always harm national security (insofar as you believe spying can aide national security).
How could it be any other way?
>The whole point of spying on communications depends on the targets not knowing they're being listened to.
In that case, I think there is little doubt as to whether the foreign targets were previously aware of our activities.
The middle part (labeled (3) by Popehat), as the blog correctly points out, is the reason this is a big controversy and not a straightforward spy case -- it's not at all clear that his disclosures were meant to benefit foreign powers, or that he was attempting to harm the United States.
I wonder if there is a precedent supporting successful use of that charge. That's very broad wording. Taken literally, nearly anything you say that isn't puppies and rainbows could qualify.
"Executive Order 13526:
Sec. 1.7. Classification Prohibitions and Limitations. (a) In no case shall information be classified, continue to be maintained as classified, or fail to be declassified in order to: (1) conceal violations of law, inefficiency, or administrative error.."
You don't classify innocuous material just because it might be embarrassing.
But on the other hand you can classify material that risks national security even if it also happens to be embarrassing.
In any event PRISM itself is 0.01% or so in actuality as it was claimed to be, I'm not even sure I'd call PRISM itself embarrassing (it's just a damn web service). The laws under which PRISM operate might be different, but that's not something we can pin on NSA, and it's not something that was secret anyways.
You're wrong. That's a well-known, ongoing, and acknowledged problem in the US which even has its own act of Congress as an attempt to deal with the problem.
http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/111/hr553
Here, if you like a good Catch-22: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20121126/01371621143/defen...
Who knows? The "court" meets in secret. Its rulings are secret. I'm not even certain that NSA is bound in any meaningful to abide by their decision/advice.
Although there does seem to be some debate about whether or not what he did should be considered a crime, and whether he's guilty of everything he's charged with.
"The courts cannot search the minds of the jurors to find the basis upon which they judge." [2]
In the United States, judges cannot direct a jury to deliver a specific verdict, getting a verdict you didn't like is not an acceptable reason for an appeal, and jurors cannot be punished for the way they decide a case [2].
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jury_nullification_in_the_Unite...
Whether the laws he broke is justified for the sort of revelation his information revealed, i m certain that is the case, but i highly doubt the courts in the US will agree.