Re:Climate change: A cooling consensus
by _delirium on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:29PM
(#5921969)
If you take a very narrow view of falsification, then evolution is unfalsifiable too, and therefore not science (this is actually a common argument made by anti-evolution people).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
That is untrue since evolution has indeed been studied in falsifiable experiments.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Experimental_evolution
On the other hand studying how exactly the current specieses evolved is more like history.
There are certainly specific experiments that have been carried out w.r.t. mechanisms (also true with climate science, fwiw). It's more the overall "big" conclusions that are a bit difficult to replicate in a laboratory, e.g. "the earth is warming as a result of human-caused greenhouse-gas emissions" and "humans descended from other animals through a process of evolution driven by natural selection".
Any examples of such experiments for climate science? Other than actually predicting climate change and then waiting 30 years I have trouble imagining falsifiable experiments. For evolution you can isolate a couple of populations with short generations in the lab and study them.
Re:Climate change: A cooling consensus
by neutronicus on Friday June 21, 2013 @08:51PM
(#5922039)
I agree with that argument.
It's history. If not for the whole religion dust-up we'd probably call it natural history.