News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by digitalsushi on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:49PM (#5908110)
I remember back when I was 16, I did a web page about my home town, claremont nh. I did this site: http://digitalsushi.com/midashi/claremont/ I was working for an ISP in town, and someone with the town called up the ISP to ask whom owned the site. Since I worked there, I was simply transferred the phone call. You can imagine how contextually confusing that would be, to be handed a call that technically had nothing to do with working there, and also, being a dumb 16 year old on tech support.

Well, the guy was asking all sorts of questions. I felt very intimidated. I remember clearly a phrase he left me with: "Well, this is just Big Brother checking in and making sure you're acting in good faith." He decided that I was, that I was not on a mission to sully the good city of claremont, and that was the end of it. But it really stuck with me, probably just out of my young age and the authority of a city official grilling me. 17 years later, the troll I have turned into would have loved the chance to bring out the worst in me, so it's probably good this happened when it did.

This article really brought me back to that time. Also, it's terrifying I have web content I published over 50% of my entire life ago. I know some of you have worse percentages, but that middle mark... yikes.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by johnminton on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:55PM (#5908156)
"ask who owned" not "ask whom owned". "whom" isn't just a word to put in to sound educated - it's used only when the "who" is an object. Here it is not.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by to3m on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:31PM (#5908442)
For all intensive purposes, your right, but is they're really any need to go over things with a fine toothcomb? As me and everybody else seems to feel, the point hear is mute, and I'm sure yourself agrees. Its clear enough what was meaned.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Domenic_S on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:51PM (#5908590)
What are you doing?! I think you just gave me cancer!
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by to3m on Thursday June 20, 2013 @10:05AM (#5912112)
Cancer is unlikely, though some people can come out in a mild rash.

Exposure therapy is the usual treatment.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by antoko on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @06:21PM (#5908805)
very impressive and equally painful, how long did that take you?
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by andrewmcdonough on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:19PM (#5909128)
Excellent comment.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by digitalsushi on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:00PM (#5908187)
You don't have to be a dick about it. I thought 'whom' was right because the subject of the sentence was 'someone'.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Falling3 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:46PM (#5908557)
It might have been a little dickish, but johnminton was right. People definitely have a tendency to overuse whom in a way they wouldn't with other pronouns.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by orik on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @06:20PM (#5908796)
Guys, this is Hacker News, not Reddit.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Falling3 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:10PM (#5909083)
I thought we appreciated pedantry here?
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by meepmorp on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:19PM (#5908337)
Next time, just say that the object case on the pronoun was licensed by an elided preposition. Continuing to call out the dickish behavior of the other poster works, too.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by johnminton on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:23PM (#5908362)
Gramma who under you prepose right would be?
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by rosser on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:02PM (#5908211)
Years ago, someone taught me a very handy trick for determining whether to use the subject or object form: rephrase the sentence somehow so instead of who/whom, you're using he/him (or she/her, if you're so inclined). If "she" sounds right, use "who"; if "him" sounds right, it's "whom".
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by StavrosK on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @06:33PM (#5908881)
Your advice isn't very clear, as you're switching genders. Stick with one, lest someone think "whom" is for men and "who" for women:

If "he" sounds right, use "who"; if "him" sounds right, it's "whom".

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Pitarou on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:35PM (#5909199)
I learnt an even better trick: don't use it.

Or rather, only use it if you intend to go the whole hog and comply with all the pedantic, pseudo-latinate prescriptions of traditional formal English grammar.

"It is I."

"Bad grammar is something up with which I shall not put."

"This is an historic occasion."

And so on....

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by sk5t on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @10:18PM (#5909779)
That's an okay strategy if you're going for "maximin": the best possible worst result. More refined speakers of English will notice and take umbrage at your mistakes, but a wrong "who" is so much less irritating than a wrong "whom."
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by meepmorp on Thursday June 20, 2013 @01:46PM (#5913531)
> Or rather, only use it if you intend to go the whole hog and comply with all the pedantic, pseudo-latinate prescriptions of traditional formal English grammar.

The who/whom I/me distinction isn't a pseudo-Latinate grammatical prescription - it's the last vestages of overt case marking in English. An + words starting with "h" is a phonological side-effect of h-dropping in some dialects.

The preposition stranding thing, though, is pseudo-Latinate prescriptivism. That and the supposed wrongness of split infinitives are my two biggest annoyances with "proper" grammar.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Pitarou on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:39PM (#5915809)
Yes, I know. I'm tarring all these formalisms with the same etymological brush.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by meepmorp on Friday June 21, 2013 @01:44PM (#5919680)
These aren't formalisms.

Some are prescriptivist rules for how grammar ought to be, some are observed facts about how language functions.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by phillc73 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:42AM (#5911669)
> "This is an historic occasion."

What's wrong with this? I cannot think of another way in which to say this?

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Pitarou on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:29PM (#5915781)
"an" or "a"?

It's a long story. If you've never had to deal with this quaint piece of British pedantry, count yourself lucky. But you can still sometimes here BBC journalists who say "This is an historic occasion." with both the "n" and the "h" pronounced clearly.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by bane on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:22PM (#5908358)
"Whom" is archaic and generally not used in English anymore anyways. Overzealous and misguided efforts to save the word have scarred generations of youngsters.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by qu4z-2 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @06:40PM (#5908904)
Whom is fine, but so is using "who" in its place. If in doubt, use who.

On that note, it reminds me of a company I did some work for recently. They never used "me", only "myself": "Yes, he gave it to myself on Tuesday."

I doubt anyone would argue that "myself" is archaic, but people using it incorrectly is definitely jarring.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by bane on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:19PM (#5909127)
> Whom is fine, but so is using "who" in its place. If in doubt, use who.

Probably better advice. There's a bit of research literature on the death of "whom". I can't remember when exactly, but I want to say around the beginning of the 20th century it pretty much died out from the language. It's a nice progression, English doesn't use thee, thine, thy or thou anymore either.

re:myself.

That's just plain weird.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by sethrin on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @10:30PM (#5909803)
People do however use "y'all" and "you guys", and others. Just because we don't have the words doesn't mean that they're unnecessary.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by phillc73 on Thursday June 20, 2013 @08:54AM (#5911729)
We must speak with different people, because I hear it commonly used in the correct manner.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by bane on Thursday June 20, 2013 @05:48PM (#5915187)
I can guarantee with near 100% certainty that unless you deal with people who speak in a formal style as their normal vernacular, you do not hear it either commonly nor consistently used in a correct manner.

- the OED remarks "whom is 'no longer current in natural colloquial speech'" and notes multiple cases in Shakespeare, Defoe, Chaucer and the King James Bible where "whom" is used "incorrectly" by modern standards

- Howard Lasnik and Nicholas Sobin describe whom as "It is commonly assumed that the English interrogative/relative pronoun whom is parallel to him and them in manifesting objective pronominal Case...Whom in modern English derives from a set of extra-grammatical rules...[used to generate] products that have a 'prestige' status. Whom differs markedly from intuitions about the use of personal pronouns. http://ling.umd.edu/~lasnik/ and the presentation http://academics.utep.edu/Portals/878/papers/whom_paper_vanc...

- Edward Sapir dedicated significant studies to the obsoletion of whom. In "Language: Intro to Study Speech" he remarks: "It is safe to prophesy that within a couple of hundred years from to-day not even the most learned jurist will be saying "Whom did you see!" By that time the 'whom' will be as delightfully archaic as the Elizabethan 'his' for 'its.' No logical or historical argument will avail to save this hapless 'whom'"

- Thurber provided this example: "A common rule for determining whether 'who' or 'whom' is right is to substitute 'she' for 'who', and 'her' for 'whom', and see which sounds better. Take the sentence, 'He met a woman who they said was an actress'. Now if 'who' is correct then 'she' can be used in its place...'He met a woman she they said was an actress'.

- Chomsky wrote that similar non-grammatical structures that only exist in grammar books are: "...a violation of natural law. In fact, a good deal of what's taught is taught because it's wrong. You don't have to teach people their native language because it grows in their minds, but if you want people to say, "He and I were here" and not "Him and me were here," then you have to teach them because it's probably wrong.

- Mair notes that: "whom is moribund as an element of the core grammar of English, but is very much alive as a style marker whose correct use is acquired in the educational system [, where it is taught]. [The use of whom] is highly restricted, but rather than disappear entirely, the form is likely to remain in use for some time to come because of its over prestige in writing."

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by gruseom on Thursday June 20, 2013 @06:52PM (#5915447)
Holy shit! What a great comment.

I love how serious inquiry into language almost always reveals that the "Rules" are wrong.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by bane on Thursday June 20, 2013 @09:09PM (#5915909)
Thanks, linguistic prescriptivism is a pet peeve of mine. It's astonishing how paper thin and clearly unnatural most of the arguments are.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by samstave on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:02PM (#5908206)
Whomever you are, you sound condescending rather than helpful.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by saraid216 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:44PM (#5908537)
> Whoever you are, you sound condescending rather than helpful.

Fixed that for you.

Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by Angostura on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @06:51PM (#5908973)
Whomsoever, surely
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by lucisferre on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:03PM (#5908221)
Perhaps they asked "to whom the site belonged?".
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by reeses on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @06:24PM (#5908833)
Ask not to whom the site belongs, it belongs to thee.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by dylangs1030 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:12PM (#5909090)
You started the funniest thread on Hacker News I've seen in a long, long time.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by austenallred on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:52PM (#5908129)
For back in the day that's actually a fairly well-designed site.
Re:A Great Response to a Cease and Desist Letter by axb on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:16PM (#5908307)
And a great favicon to boot.