Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by CognitiveLens on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @10:04AM
(#5905560)
There's some good observations here, but I would stop short of the claim that "for viewers, this can only be good." It's not good that some great movie libraries have already been stripped from Netflix because the contract renewal was going to be too expensive. It's not good if Netflix goes all-in on original programming and fails, potentially taking the rest of the company down as well. It's not good if Hollywood feels little pressure to make it easier for consumers to access their content because they're getting great contracts with traditional distributors.
It's also interesting that this article makes no mention of Netflix's 3 other original series that are not as popular as House of Cards and Arrested Development - Netflix is probably making as many flops as hits at the moment, and that adds an important qualification on the risk/reward calculation of its strategic investment in original series - the headliner shows have to not only justify themselves (as the article describes), but carry the duds as they come along as well.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by dasil003 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:11AM
(#5905970)
> There's some good observations here, but I would stop short of the claim that "for viewers, this can only be good." It's not good that some great movie libraries have already been stripped from Netflix because the contract renewal was going to be too expensive.
That's a non-sequitur. That content was going to be stripped regardless of what production Netflix was engaged in. In fact, it doesn't matter if Netflix can magically realize 10x revenue per subscriber overnight, because there is game theory at play here. Big content is happy to make nice marginal payouts from Netflix on the side, but they will do anything to prevent Netflix from consolidating a comprehensive library of A-list content because they already have by far the broadest device reach, and if they get all the content, cable cutting will ramp up overnight and destroy any leverage for rights holders because there will be nowhere else they can go for distribution.
> It's not good if Netflix goes all-in on original programming and fails, potentially taking the rest of the company down as well.
They have no choice. Big content will never let them win. With their own content at least they have a chance to control their own destiny.
> It's not good if Hollywood feels little pressure to make it easier for consumers to access their content because they're getting great contracts with traditional distributors.
As long as customers balk at paying $10/month for Netflix while happily shelling out $150/month for cable, Netflix has no leverage.
On balance I have to agree with the OA's assertion. Netflix putting some of its money directly to production can only benefit viewers overall. Putting that money to more contracts is not going to move the needle in terms of production from the major studios, to them it's just gravy at this point.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by jeffasinger on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:59PM
(#5906711)
I think cable cutting will only continue. I know plenty of people who only care about cable for live sports. Everything else is either on Netflix or pirated. Surely the content producers would rather get a cut from Netflix than nothing from pirated content.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by dasil003 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:28PM
(#5907970)
Sure. Everyone including big content know that streaming is the future. But the thing is, if you look at the numbers (and believe me Big Content scrutinizes these very carefully) cable cutting hasn't made a dent yet, and neither has piracy. Content owners are going to milk the cow as long as they can, they aren't going to hasten the inevitable future because it is not one of more revenue for them. Barriers to both production and distribution are falling on a yearly basis, and this can only mean less money for them in the long run. That is why they drag their feet.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by roc on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @10:56AM
(#5905882)
If the libraries removed from Netflix are licensed to competitors, it is indeed Good for consumers, provided the barriers between services aren't too steep. [1] It incentivizes providers like Netflix to continue increasing their value proposition and ensures profits are flowing back to creators/library owners commensurate with their value.
If Netflix fails, at this point, I don't think it'd be too big a blow. There are plenty of services in the same space and the feeding frenzy for Netflix library contracts would ensure the survivors are offering the same library to the same market.
And I'm not sure why you think Hollywood feels no pressure to get their content in front of viewers. Their proper interest is to maximize the return on their libraries, and they can hardly do that if they enable the creation of an 800 lb gorilla in the streaming market that can dictate terms.
Should Netflix be the undisputed one-true-service for digital delivery, that would almost certainly become bad for viewers. What incentive would they have to work with MS/Google on enabling federated/integrated search/navigation? What incentive would they have to work with new device makers as they have?
Netflix fantastic value proposition is a product of how intensely competitive that space is, due its future up-side. Things that preserve that competition are Good, even if they are bad for Netflix specifically, up until the point they are bad for the entire streaming market.
[1] The current division between Hulu, Netflix, ABC, HBO Go, et al. is about as high a wall as you'd want. Different services, same box, same-ish interface/behavior. If you couldn't get multiple services on the same hardware, it'd be too high. And, of course, if you could get XB1/GoogleTV-style federated search/navigation across services, the status quo would be just fine.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by jonnathanson on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @01:24PM
(#5906855)
The big problem Netflix faces in the long run is its production cost model. It's well known within Hollywood that Netflix basically went to market and announced that it would pay 1.5x (or whatever) the going Hollywood rate for original material. Hence, it's actually absorbing all the cost inefficiencies of Hollywood and magnifying them. It's driving up prices and adding more inefficiency to the system. (FYI, Amazon is currently in town and doing the same).
Their ostensible gameplan is to do this in the short run, in order to get a hit or two on their hands -- at which point they can start dictating terms, rather than being dictated to. This is similar to HBO's playbook, from back when it first entered the scripted development market. It's a very big gamble. It paid off for HBO, and in recent years it's been paying off for basic cable channels like AMC. But Netflix has a very different revenue model that is challenged by heavy, loss leading production costs. It's also starting to face a lot of competition for essentially the same service rendered to consumers.
The question of whether this "can only be good" for consumers is a much thornier one. Economics suggests that more players in the distribution ecosystem will lower costs for consumers. And Netflix has already done a pretty great job lowering marginal costs of consumption. But Netflix isn't really disrupting anyone on the content side, at least not yet; that's largely because the studio system is really savvy about protecting itself from disruption.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by nitid_name on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @10:57AM
(#5905886)
We're slowly but surely collapsing back to the channel model of content.
The bundling the cable services were forcing on us to support ESPN (which accounts for something like $15-20 in your TV bill) and then topping with the a la cart channels (HBO, Showtime, etc). Now, we have a few a la cart providers that stand on their own with original content (in addition to licensed content).
My big fear is that the a la cart streaming channels will eventually start running commercials in the manner of Hulu. Throw in ISP bundling of streaming services, and voila, we're back to Cable Television... only since it's on demand, we can't DVR through commercials.
Also, I'm not sure the fallback to channels is a bad thing. I've been spending a lot of time in the YouTube ecosystem and finding good regular series on a topic is a HUGE challenge. If there was a well curated food channel or educational channel on YouTube I'd pay to subscribe — It's a huge time suck searching, especially using the current tools.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:26AM
(#5906057)
The comparison provided in that link doesn't work for me, much for the same reasons someone pointed out in the comments.
The conclusion is that bundling benefits both the consumer and the company. The consumer gets both channels cheaper than separately and the company generates more revenue even with cheaper pricing per channel. This completely ignores the fact that I don't want the sports channel AT ALL. Therefore, instead of paying $11.70 for both channels, I'm paying $9 for the one I truly want.
Now expand that over hundreds of channels, including the dozens of sports channels I don't want, and let's see how it breaks down. From the current lineup of channels that I saw the last time I looked I would expect I would only want at most a dozen channels. Compare that to the amount I currently pay would be of huge benefit to the cable company because currently I pay nothing for cable TV as I'm a cord cutter. I haven't paid for cable TV in three years because of their stupid bundling pricing, how did that benefit the company?
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:57PM
(#5907788)
You are quite correct and I understand the economics of bundling. But that's why I stated the comparison didn't work for me. But one day they will have to optimize for people like me because the group is growing and things suggest it will continue. It may take a while but it's inevitable, as you seem to agree with in your "today" comment.
Let it take a while, I'm quite happy with the current arrangement of me not paying any money for cable TV.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by pbreit on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:37PM
(#5907689)
Your 12 channels cost $100. My 300 channels (which includes your 12) cost $100. Is that really what you want? For a product with zero marginal costs, this is entirely plausible (in fact, required).
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @04:09PM
(#5907858)
No, if that's the cost of my 12 channels then I will continue to say no thanks. Currently I get nothing, save my $100, and I'm quite content with that.
I'm not sure I agree with your last point though. Because it seems the cable TV industry's idea is that the only thing to do is to increase costs for their customers over time regardless of the quality of the product. I stipulate that the quality of cable TV has gotten worse over the years even with the 300 channels they now offer. You're just paying more and more for low-quality noise you never watch.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by pbreit on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @05:00PM
(#5908188)
I can't agree that cable tv quality has gone down recently. Game of Thrones, Mad Men, Breaking Bad? This stuff is not only the highest quality TV we've probably ever seen but higher quality than film as well.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Thursday June 20, 2013 @10:05AM
(#5912122)
In those cases you are quite correct, plus they are on channels that might not exist if not for cable TV. Surely the content of those shows would not exist on broadcast TV.
And that's just two channels out of three hundred. Yes, there are examples of quality but they are severely drowned out by the noise. I guess I should say the average quality of cable TV has gone down over the years.
I suppose if the majority of the channels on cable offered quality entertainment on the level of HBO's or AMC's offerings then my attitude would be different. But since I can access AMC content now with a agreeable arrangement and possibly get HBO's in the future, I don't feel the need to pay for all those channels I'll never watch. Right now I pay for the shows I want to watch.
Plus, Netflix produced House of Cards of which I'd be happy to compare with any of HBO's or AMC's offerings.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by maratd on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:31AM
(#5906096)
> we're back to Cable Television
This will never happen, for the simple reason that you have choice and as a result, competition. You can choose Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, or any of the smaller ones.
Netflix gets commercials? It will literally take a few clicks to switch to Amazon. All 3 get commercials? Watch competition sprout.
That's the beauty of the Internet. Barriers to entry are significantly less than in the real world, which allows for competition to flourish. There is literally nothing stopping you from starting your own streaming service. Most of the technology is proven and widely available. And, of course, anybody can license content. This is universal and required by law.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by Thrymr on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:07PM
(#5906348)
> This will never happen, for the simple reason that you have choice and as a result, competition. You can choose Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, or any of the smaller ones.
You will not have choice with regards to exclusive content. If you want to watch Arrested Development (season 4) you will need to be on Netflix, if you want to watch Zombieland you will need Amazon Prime. Just like the networks where HBO, ESPN, etc. have exclusive rights to their content.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by mbreese on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:16PM
(#5907585)
What are you talking about? Of course it will happen. The only way you can have true competition in the way you suggest is if all providers have the same content.
When we start getting Netflix producing shows A, B, and C, and Amazon Prime producing X, Y, and Z, if you want to watch only A and Z, you are stuck paying for both services.
It might not be as bad as paying for 200 channels when you only watch 3, but it's still the same model - just at a different scale.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by maratd on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:35PM
(#5907681)
> you are stuck paying for both services.
No, I'm stuck using thepiratebay.org and when they get tired of losing revenue, they'll start sharing the content. Piracy is most certainly a force to be considered here and it can actually nudge the players toward a more competitive position where they're not hoarding content.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:10AM
(#5905968)
While true, I'm more hopeful for the market to deal with that as it is much easier for a competitor to show up vying for your entertainment dollars since they don't have to compete on the infrastructure level. With the cable companies you often had no competitor to switch to until the satellite options gained popularity, but they quickly turned into the same as the cable providers because there wasn't much competition on that front. Just like laying cable, it costs money to launch satellites.
On the other hand, a direct competitor to Netflix is much easier to pull off as there's no cable to lay nor satellites to launch. What I would worry over is if a company like Netflix starts pushing for exclusivity in certain markets using local laws much like how the cable companies obtained their stranglehold on their markets. I don't see how such a thing could be done but never underestimate money and lawyers.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by liquidcool on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:18AM
(#5906012)
I share your fear of commercials. Last I checked, Hulu didn't even offer a paid version that's commercial free. I wonder if that's due to contractual obligations, or that without commercials the price would be too high to bother. Considering Netflix is able to do it, I'm assuming it's contractual, which is a shame. I'd definitely pay extra for commercial free (and 1080P).
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:32AM
(#5906103)
That's the thing I've never understood about the complaint of commercials on Hulu. Hulu is not the exact same service as Netflix and never has been. Hulu provides TV shows almost immediately after airtime and I can understand that something may have to be done to offset the increased costs of doing that.
Amazon offers a similar service where you can purchase an episode for many shows the day after airtime. Even though I have an Amazon Prime account I still have to pay extra to see the show immediately even though that very same episode will likely be free in the future because of the Prime account.
Hulu is doing the same thing, instead of you paying extra you watch commercials. And yet, no one seems to complain over Amazon's model even though it is essentially the same thing.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by cdash on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:28PM
(#5906503)
I would assume that people complain about Hulu because the media companies have a large ownership stake in the company if I remember correctly while this is not the case with Amazon.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:58PM
(#5907798)
That may be so, but that seems to be a different complaint than complaining about having to watch commercials despite a monthly subscription fee. Even though that's been the model for cable TV since the beginning.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by talmand on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:46PM
(#5907731)
Yes, I got the season's pass for both Walking Dead and Breaking Bad so that's how we've kept up on them. I'm not sure how many shows they do this with.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by julianozen on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:28PM
(#5906505)
idk. I feel like we're more likely to see the cable companies become more digital than collapse.
What's more likely to happen first? Some Microsoft, Google or Apple is able to offer a bunch of TV over IP channels as an tangential part of their business, or some cable company like Comcast or Time Warner will get the rights to run all its channels, or even individual streaming shows to a roku or iPad.
I think it'll be much easier in this circumstance for Comcast or Time Warner will be able to adopt their business (not their prices) before a tech companies will be able to license the content deals for cheap
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by confluence on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:16AM
(#5906001)
At the end of the day capitalism always comes back to bridges, trolls, control, volume, monopoly and power. NFLX can only continue to exist so long as it stands in between people and the things they desperately want. If the good they sell is non-exclusive however, then they are only one amongst many competing trolls all controlling similar bridges to the same exact island. In such conditions, prices will invariably fall to the lowest cost distributor, and costs will invariably rise to the worst managed ones, squeezing one's margins to shit. It sucks to be one of the 10 different bridges that people can choose between to cross over to get the stuff that they want. It's also why being an airline sucks. Competition sucks. Hard.
It also makes you a bitch to both your clients ("I'm switching right now unless you give me a better phone deal!") and to your suppliers ("So you need my content yesterday? Pay me X billion right now or you can go get fucked.")
To make money long term you need to either be the lowest cost producer for non-exclusive goods, or the sole controller of exclusive goods. You can make money both ways, but the former is much, much, much harder. NFLX, and every other company in existence, is either going for volume or for monopoly. That is why they are producing original content. It's because volume sucks.
It's also why startup success is largely luck based. Imagine a million different trolls, building a million different bridges, to a million different islands. Now imagine that upon one island a scarce metal is accidentally discovered and some random dipshit idiotic troll has just somehow, through sheer chance, managed to acquire exclusive control of the resource. Now, if you want to get that metal, you are going to have to pay that troll, and the more people want it, and the more desperately they need it, the fatter the troll will get.
Stand between people and the things they desperately want and you'll never go hungry. But you might get some indigestion.
Fuck competition. Become one with your inner troll; charge people through the nose for what they want, and then charge them again, and again, and again. And then when they can't take it any more, kill the product, and make another one.
Rinse and repeat.
In AAPL we trust; all others bring shitty margins.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by maratd on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:44AM
(#5906177)
> Fuck competition. Become one with your inner troll
What a morbid way of looking at things... and it's not terribly accurate, either.
You can make a very good buck on volume, even with fierce competition and extremely tight margins.
So you can't charge a whole lot for the toll because there are a dozen other bridges? Boo hoo! Have you thought of selling coffee to your clients as they pass?
You can easily make up margin on the up-sell or cross-sell. Something that anybody who worked in consumer electronics retail already knows. And that type of retail is extremely low-margin and competitive. The guy across the street and on the internet has the same exact widget as you.
This is something that Netflix isn't doing. Yet. And there's quite a bit of margin there.
Oh and here's a little bit of insight, once you have a "bridge" you can point it at any "island". It's super easy, almost like copy and paste. How many countries have access to Netflix?
There's plenty of opportunity in volume and you serve the greater good. Not every company has to be a hipster love fest like APPL, where you pay through the nose for substandard hardware. That's just as crass as children refusing to wear anything but brand name clothing.
Volume capitalism is beautiful because it mercilessly lowers the price of goods, allowing access to all. And you can make quite a profit too!
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by d23 on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:05PM
(#5906343)
> So you can't charge a whole lot for the toll because there are a dozen other bridges? Boo hoo! Have you thought of selling coffee to your clients as they pass?
If nothing else, I've gotten some fantastic imagery out of this conversation.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by mbreese on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:07PM
(#5907537)
You had me right up until calling Apple a hipster love fest with substandard hardware. This adds nothing to your argument and just makes you sound grumpy (as in get-off-my-lawn type of grumpy). The crass children comment just reinforces this picture. I personally find their hardware to be high quality, and most of their margins come from the supply side. But that's beside the point.
True - you can make money on volume, but when you are in a race to the bottom in terms of price, something invariably suffers... it's usually quality. So, if you want to make money selling cheap crap, go right ahead - profit is profit. Just don't assume everyone wants to be in that business.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by maratd on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:29PM
(#5907660)
> You had me right up until calling Apple a hipster love fest with substandard hardware.
Alright, alright. The hardware itself is, of course, not substandard. You're paying for the brand, so it's just overpriced. Yes, build quality is wonderful on the Air, but my Samsung Series 9 has similarly wonderful build quality.
You're definitely paying for the brand. That's why everything they sell has a prominent Apple logo stamped on it. If it wasn't for that logo, people wouldn't fork over the kind of money they do. Yes, they built up their brand on good service and quality, but then, every luxury brand does that as well.
Now, somebody has to be the luxury brand and somebody has to make "cheap crap" as you say. That's fine and there's nothing wrong with that.
But please don't pretend that Apple is for the masses. It makes about as much sense as saying everybody should drive a Ferrari.
My point was that not every business needs to be run like a luxury brand to make money. Look at Samsung and many others as an example. You can make plenty of money on volume, up-selling, and cross-selling, as well as expanding internationally.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by fusiongyro on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:47PM
(#5907740)
> But please don't pretend that Apple is for the masses.
Not every Apple product is for everyone, but they have done a very good job of creating a product line diverse enough that anyone can afford something. Minimum wage laborers are certainly seen sporting iPods. iPads are still the most popular kind of tablet. If you can afford X for a product you want, if you put in the effort/take out a loan, you can afford 1.5X for a product in the same class. We're not talking about cars, where the luxury brands can easily exceed the expense of commodity brands by factors of ten or a hundred.
> If it wasn't for that logo, people wouldn't fork over the kind of money they do. Yes, they built up their brand on good service and quality, but then, every luxury brand does that as well.
The fact that other luxury brands do something similar vis-a-vis service and quality doesn't mean you get to slyly deduct it from reasons to buy Apple. Buying Apple gets you a pretty thoroughly integrated positive experience. The logo certainly has value, but it's a lot more than just the logo.
Expect to see Apple remaining in their market position for as long as it takes their competitors to develop an appreciation for the advantages these non-technical and semi-technical efforts bring.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by mapgrep on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @02:14PM
(#5907205)
So it's come to this: A company spends tens of milions of dollars financing great shows that wouldn't exist otherwise, including one that was cancelled and left for dead, then makes it incredibly easy and cheap to get at this content, disrupting greedy inefficient incumbents -- only to be derided within the hacker community as a "troll... charging people through the nose for what they want."
You don't have any entitlement to the things you want simply because you want them. When someone spends loads of money creating that thing you want, they can charge what they please. You are free to call them dumb of criticize their terms, but when you're reduced to calling an innovative and very low cost, low margin company like Netflix a "fat troll" you become the sort of caricature the worst, dumbest old line content companies love: A free rider who will never pay, no matter how good the terms, who has no respect for the efforts or rights of others.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by mbreese on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @03:10PM
(#5907554)
In this context, I didn't consider the "troll" comments to have a negative connotation. In fact, I found it pretty descriptive. They could have just as easily have used "gatekeeper" or "toll-collector". Trolls under bridges though is a lot more fun to picture in my head.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by jebblue on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @07:39PM
(#5909214)
Pawn Stars, American Pickers, Ice Road Truckers and American Restoration are the top ones for me, precedence order. I like more of their shows though, http://www.history.com/shows
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by amalag on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @10:14AM
(#5905622)
They should tie up with a good content provider. AMC has excellent shows all available on streaming, Breaking Bad, Mad Men, The Walking Dead are of course famous. Other good shows are The Killing, Hell on Wheels. I think if they make partnership they will get a better deal out of it, rather than them creating such content on their own.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by roc on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @11:13AM
(#5905981)
But what would the partner get out of it?
Anyone with a track record at this point has far more to gain by letting the streaming providers compete for a license every few years.
Netflix might offer slightly better terms than competition would produce in the short-run, but they'd want a longer license term to make up for it. And that, given the growth and promise of the space, would be silly.
Consider the 700% licensing fee increases. Would Netflix offer a 700% premium over a 3-year license in exchange for a 6-year partnership -- with who-knows-what restrictions on future licensing of content produced under the partnership?
They'd need to find a producer with a track-record for quality, but that was also cash-strapped and needed someone to share future production costs to stay in business or to make some wild expansion gamble. Which would only raise the question of why a producer with a track-record would have trouble finding another partner.
Plus the nature of Hollywood is that it doesn't make too much sense to partner with AMC to get new content, based on their success in hiring successful creatives, when you can just hire successful creatives directly.
What, after all, has AMC brought to The Walking Dead, beyond hiring a successful creative and providing a time-slot? Their input into the situation has seemed to be the 'tweaking for profitability' consideration that requires little industry acumen (AMC was remarkably ham-handed in this case) and that Netflix might not even see the same need for in the first place.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by buren on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:35PM
(#5906550)
The main issue is, in my point of view, fragmentation.
If you'd like to watch both HBO and Netflix series, then you'd have to subscribe to two services.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by notatoad on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @01:52PM
(#5907045)
I don't think it's really a big deal. $8 for the new season of Arrested Development or Game of Thrones is a perfectly reasonable price to pay. It only seems like a tough price to swallow because netflix advertises themselves as a place to find all the content you want to watch.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by cookiecaper on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @12:41PM
(#5906598)
The real reason Netflix is producing original content is short and simple: current copyright law make Netflix completely beholden to the big six media companies, and if these people, for whatever reason, feel they don't need/want/like Netflix anymore, Netflix will be over. It can only operate as an appendage of the major media corps. We caught a brief glimpse of this with the Qwikster debacle, where licensing costs imposed for streaming forced Netflix into a new model that was very poorly received, and ultimately had to be rolled back due to public panic.
Netflix are beginning to chip away at that bondage by producing original content, and giving people a reason to use Netflix that can't be taken away arbitrarily by external forces.
Netflix could be a great champion of copyright reform ... if that wouldn't cause all their content providers to immediately drop NF in retribution, that is.
Re:Why Netflix is producing original content
by shmerl on Wednesday June 19, 2013 @01:22PM
(#5906846)
Does Netflix release that original content DRM free? They claimed that their interest in DRM is driven by media companies. So let them prove it by releasing their own content DRM free.
It's also interesting that this article makes no mention of Netflix's 3 other original series that are not as popular as House of Cards and Arrested Development - Netflix is probably making as many flops as hits at the moment, and that adds an important qualification on the risk/reward calculation of its strategic investment in original series - the headliner shows have to not only justify themselves (as the article describes), but carry the duds as they come along as well.
That's a non-sequitur. That content was going to be stripped regardless of what production Netflix was engaged in. In fact, it doesn't matter if Netflix can magically realize 10x revenue per subscriber overnight, because there is game theory at play here. Big content is happy to make nice marginal payouts from Netflix on the side, but they will do anything to prevent Netflix from consolidating a comprehensive library of A-list content because they already have by far the broadest device reach, and if they get all the content, cable cutting will ramp up overnight and destroy any leverage for rights holders because there will be nowhere else they can go for distribution.
> It's not good if Netflix goes all-in on original programming and fails, potentially taking the rest of the company down as well.
They have no choice. Big content will never let them win. With their own content at least they have a chance to control their own destiny.
> It's not good if Hollywood feels little pressure to make it easier for consumers to access their content because they're getting great contracts with traditional distributors.
As long as customers balk at paying $10/month for Netflix while happily shelling out $150/month for cable, Netflix has no leverage.
On balance I have to agree with the OA's assertion. Netflix putting some of its money directly to production can only benefit viewers overall. Putting that money to more contracts is not going to move the needle in terms of production from the major studios, to them it's just gravy at this point.
If Netflix fails, at this point, I don't think it'd be too big a blow. There are plenty of services in the same space and the feeding frenzy for Netflix library contracts would ensure the survivors are offering the same library to the same market.
And I'm not sure why you think Hollywood feels no pressure to get their content in front of viewers. Their proper interest is to maximize the return on their libraries, and they can hardly do that if they enable the creation of an 800 lb gorilla in the streaming market that can dictate terms.
Should Netflix be the undisputed one-true-service for digital delivery, that would almost certainly become bad for viewers. What incentive would they have to work with MS/Google on enabling federated/integrated search/navigation? What incentive would they have to work with new device makers as they have?
Netflix fantastic value proposition is a product of how intensely competitive that space is, due its future up-side. Things that preserve that competition are Good, even if they are bad for Netflix specifically, up until the point they are bad for the entire streaming market.
[1] The current division between Hulu, Netflix, ABC, HBO Go, et al. is about as high a wall as you'd want. Different services, same box, same-ish interface/behavior. If you couldn't get multiple services on the same hardware, it'd be too high. And, of course, if you could get XB1/GoogleTV-style federated search/navigation across services, the status quo would be just fine.
Their ostensible gameplan is to do this in the short run, in order to get a hit or two on their hands -- at which point they can start dictating terms, rather than being dictated to. This is similar to HBO's playbook, from back when it first entered the scripted development market. It's a very big gamble. It paid off for HBO, and in recent years it's been paying off for basic cable channels like AMC. But Netflix has a very different revenue model that is challenged by heavy, loss leading production costs. It's also starting to face a lot of competition for essentially the same service rendered to consumers.
The question of whether this "can only be good" for consumers is a much thornier one. Economics suggests that more players in the distribution ecosystem will lower costs for consumers. And Netflix has already done a pretty great job lowering marginal costs of consumption. But Netflix isn't really disrupting anyone on the content side, at least not yet; that's largely because the studio system is really savvy about protecting itself from disruption.
The bundling the cable services were forcing on us to support ESPN (which accounts for something like $15-20 in your TV bill) and then topping with the a la cart channels (HBO, Showtime, etc). Now, we have a few a la cart providers that stand on their own with original content (in addition to licensed content).
My big fear is that the a la cart streaming channels will eventually start running commercials in the manner of Hulu. Throw in ISP bundling of streaming services, and voila, we're back to Cable Television... only since it's on demand, we can't DVR through commercials.
Also, I'm not sure the fallback to channels is a bad thing. I've been spending a lot of time in the YouTube ecosystem and finding good regular series on a topic is a HUGE challenge. If there was a well curated food channel or educational channel on YouTube I'd pay to subscribe — It's a huge time suck searching, especially using the current tools.
The conclusion is that bundling benefits both the consumer and the company. The consumer gets both channels cheaper than separately and the company generates more revenue even with cheaper pricing per channel. This completely ignores the fact that I don't want the sports channel AT ALL. Therefore, instead of paying $11.70 for both channels, I'm paying $9 for the one I truly want.
Now expand that over hundreds of channels, including the dozens of sports channels I don't want, and let's see how it breaks down. From the current lineup of channels that I saw the last time I looked I would expect I would only want at most a dozen channels. Compare that to the amount I currently pay would be of huge benefit to the cable company because currently I pay nothing for cable TV as I'm a cord cutter. I haven't paid for cable TV in three years because of their stupid bundling pricing, how did that benefit the company?
You're also an exception, and if the cable company tried to optimise for you (today) they would lose much much more than they would gain.
Let it take a while, I'm quite happy with the current arrangement of me not paying any money for cable TV.
I'm not sure I agree with your last point though. Because it seems the cable TV industry's idea is that the only thing to do is to increase costs for their customers over time regardless of the quality of the product. I stipulate that the quality of cable TV has gotten worse over the years even with the 300 channels they now offer. You're just paying more and more for low-quality noise you never watch.
And that's just two channels out of three hundred. Yes, there are examples of quality but they are severely drowned out by the noise. I guess I should say the average quality of cable TV has gone down over the years.
I suppose if the majority of the channels on cable offered quality entertainment on the level of HBO's or AMC's offerings then my attitude would be different. But since I can access AMC content now with a agreeable arrangement and possibly get HBO's in the future, I don't feel the need to pay for all those channels I'll never watch. Right now I pay for the shows I want to watch.
Plus, Netflix produced House of Cards of which I'd be happy to compare with any of HBO's or AMC's offerings.
This will never happen, for the simple reason that you have choice and as a result, competition. You can choose Netflix, Hulu, Amazon Prime, or any of the smaller ones.
Netflix gets commercials? It will literally take a few clicks to switch to Amazon. All 3 get commercials? Watch competition sprout.
That's the beauty of the Internet. Barriers to entry are significantly less than in the real world, which allows for competition to flourish. There is literally nothing stopping you from starting your own streaming service. Most of the technology is proven and widely available. And, of course, anybody can license content. This is universal and required by law.
You will not have choice with regards to exclusive content. If you want to watch Arrested Development (season 4) you will need to be on Netflix, if you want to watch Zombieland you will need Amazon Prime. Just like the networks where HBO, ESPN, etc. have exclusive rights to their content.
When we start getting Netflix producing shows A, B, and C, and Amazon Prime producing X, Y, and Z, if you want to watch only A and Z, you are stuck paying for both services.
It might not be as bad as paying for 200 channels when you only watch 3, but it's still the same model - just at a different scale.
No, I'm stuck using thepiratebay.org and when they get tired of losing revenue, they'll start sharing the content. Piracy is most certainly a force to be considered here and it can actually nudge the players toward a more competitive position where they're not hoarding content.
On the other hand, a direct competitor to Netflix is much easier to pull off as there's no cable to lay nor satellites to launch. What I would worry over is if a company like Netflix starts pushing for exclusivity in certain markets using local laws much like how the cable companies obtained their stranglehold on their markets. I don't see how such a thing could be done but never underestimate money and lawyers.
Netflix is the equivalent of watching last seasons DVD release.
I can't see netflix having even 1/5th the cost per episode hulu does.
Amazon offers a similar service where you can purchase an episode for many shows the day after airtime. Even though I have an Amazon Prime account I still have to pay extra to see the show immediately even though that very same episode will likely be free in the future because of the Prime account.
Hulu is doing the same thing, instead of you paying extra you watch commercials. And yet, no one seems to complain over Amazon's model even though it is essentially the same thing.
What's more likely to happen first? Some Microsoft, Google or Apple is able to offer a bunch of TV over IP channels as an tangential part of their business, or some cable company like Comcast or Time Warner will get the rights to run all its channels, or even individual streaming shows to a roku or iPad.
I think it'll be much easier in this circumstance for Comcast or Time Warner will be able to adopt their business (not their prices) before a tech companies will be able to license the content deals for cheap
It also makes you a bitch to both your clients ("I'm switching right now unless you give me a better phone deal!") and to your suppliers ("So you need my content yesterday? Pay me X billion right now or you can go get fucked.")
To make money long term you need to either be the lowest cost producer for non-exclusive goods, or the sole controller of exclusive goods. You can make money both ways, but the former is much, much, much harder. NFLX, and every other company in existence, is either going for volume or for monopoly. That is why they are producing original content. It's because volume sucks.
It's also why startup success is largely luck based. Imagine a million different trolls, building a million different bridges, to a million different islands. Now imagine that upon one island a scarce metal is accidentally discovered and some random dipshit idiotic troll has just somehow, through sheer chance, managed to acquire exclusive control of the resource. Now, if you want to get that metal, you are going to have to pay that troll, and the more people want it, and the more desperately they need it, the fatter the troll will get.
Stand between people and the things they desperately want and you'll never go hungry. But you might get some indigestion.
Fuck competition. Become one with your inner troll; charge people through the nose for what they want, and then charge them again, and again, and again. And then when they can't take it any more, kill the product, and make another one.
Rinse and repeat.
In AAPL we trust; all others bring shitty margins.
Previous comments on competition and monopoly here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5253747
What a morbid way of looking at things... and it's not terribly accurate, either.
You can make a very good buck on volume, even with fierce competition and extremely tight margins.
So you can't charge a whole lot for the toll because there are a dozen other bridges? Boo hoo! Have you thought of selling coffee to your clients as they pass?
You can easily make up margin on the up-sell or cross-sell. Something that anybody who worked in consumer electronics retail already knows. And that type of retail is extremely low-margin and competitive. The guy across the street and on the internet has the same exact widget as you.
This is something that Netflix isn't doing. Yet. And there's quite a bit of margin there.
Oh and here's a little bit of insight, once you have a "bridge" you can point it at any "island". It's super easy, almost like copy and paste. How many countries have access to Netflix?
There's plenty of opportunity in volume and you serve the greater good. Not every company has to be a hipster love fest like APPL, where you pay through the nose for substandard hardware. That's just as crass as children refusing to wear anything but brand name clothing.
Volume capitalism is beautiful because it mercilessly lowers the price of goods, allowing access to all. And you can make quite a profit too!
If nothing else, I've gotten some fantastic imagery out of this conversation.
True - you can make money on volume, but when you are in a race to the bottom in terms of price, something invariably suffers... it's usually quality. So, if you want to make money selling cheap crap, go right ahead - profit is profit. Just don't assume everyone wants to be in that business.
Alright, alright. The hardware itself is, of course, not substandard. You're paying for the brand, so it's just overpriced. Yes, build quality is wonderful on the Air, but my Samsung Series 9 has similarly wonderful build quality.
You're definitely paying for the brand. That's why everything they sell has a prominent Apple logo stamped on it. If it wasn't for that logo, people wouldn't fork over the kind of money they do. Yes, they built up their brand on good service and quality, but then, every luxury brand does that as well.
Now, somebody has to be the luxury brand and somebody has to make "cheap crap" as you say. That's fine and there's nothing wrong with that.
But please don't pretend that Apple is for the masses. It makes about as much sense as saying everybody should drive a Ferrari.
My point was that not every business needs to be run like a luxury brand to make money. Look at Samsung and many others as an example. You can make plenty of money on volume, up-selling, and cross-selling, as well as expanding internationally.
Not every Apple product is for everyone, but they have done a very good job of creating a product line diverse enough that anyone can afford something. Minimum wage laborers are certainly seen sporting iPods. iPads are still the most popular kind of tablet. If you can afford X for a product you want, if you put in the effort/take out a loan, you can afford 1.5X for a product in the same class. We're not talking about cars, where the luxury brands can easily exceed the expense of commodity brands by factors of ten or a hundred.
> If it wasn't for that logo, people wouldn't fork over the kind of money they do. Yes, they built up their brand on good service and quality, but then, every luxury brand does that as well.
The fact that other luxury brands do something similar vis-a-vis service and quality doesn't mean you get to slyly deduct it from reasons to buy Apple. Buying Apple gets you a pretty thoroughly integrated positive experience. The logo certainly has value, but it's a lot more than just the logo.
Expect to see Apple remaining in their market position for as long as it takes their competitors to develop an appreciation for the advantages these non-technical and semi-technical efforts bring.
You don't have any entitlement to the things you want simply because you want them. When someone spends loads of money creating that thing you want, they can charge what they please. You are free to call them dumb of criticize their terms, but when you're reduced to calling an innovative and very low cost, low margin company like Netflix a "fat troll" you become the sort of caricature the worst, dumbest old line content companies love: A free rider who will never pay, no matter how good the terms, who has no respect for the efforts or rights of others.
Anyone with a track record at this point has far more to gain by letting the streaming providers compete for a license every few years.
Netflix might offer slightly better terms than competition would produce in the short-run, but they'd want a longer license term to make up for it. And that, given the growth and promise of the space, would be silly.
Consider the 700% licensing fee increases. Would Netflix offer a 700% premium over a 3-year license in exchange for a 6-year partnership -- with who-knows-what restrictions on future licensing of content produced under the partnership?
They'd need to find a producer with a track-record for quality, but that was also cash-strapped and needed someone to share future production costs to stay in business or to make some wild expansion gamble. Which would only raise the question of why a producer with a track-record would have trouble finding another partner.
Plus the nature of Hollywood is that it doesn't make too much sense to partner with AMC to get new content, based on their success in hiring successful creatives, when you can just hire successful creatives directly.
What, after all, has AMC brought to The Walking Dead, beyond hiring a successful creative and providing a time-slot? Their input into the situation has seemed to be the 'tweaking for profitability' consideration that requires little industry acumen (AMC was remarkably ham-handed in this case) and that Netflix might not even see the same need for in the first place.
Netflix are beginning to chip away at that bondage by producing original content, and giving people a reason to use Netflix that can't be taken away arbitrarily by external forces.
Netflix could be a great champion of copyright reform ... if that wouldn't cause all their content providers to immediately drop NF in retribution, that is.