News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by notatoad on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:25PM (#5901409)
A little bit like bicycles themselves. sure, we've got full suspension and electronic shifting and remote lockouts and carbon fibre and all kinds of other fun stuff now, but it's all really just garnish. a bicycle you buy today is not fundamentally different from a bicycle you might have bought 100 years ago. all the core mechanisms are identical.
Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by gamache on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:03PM (#5901678)
A car is still fundamentally a four-wheeled carriage, but it's disingenuous to use that to minimize a century of progress.

Today we have bikes that can ride virtually any terrain, carry hundreds of pounds of cargo, soak 10" bumps at 60mph, ride backwards down vert ramps, accomodate limited-mobility riders, and access enough gears to put you in the right pedal cadence in just about any grade.

Yes, it's two wheels, pedals, and a chain. Yes, it's still the diamond-frame safety bicycle. But it has changed.

Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by revelation on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:37PM (#5901492)
They are all garnish because there is no culture around bicycles as everyday transportation. So it's become an enthusiast market with flashy inventions but little improvement in the core categories like reliability or safety.

It's a market where all you can buy is the kids plastic version of a Porsche or a literal Porsche.

Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by mesofile on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:57PM (#5901624)
Actually, there has long been a strong culture of bikes as transportation for ordinary people in Europe, and to a great extent this has bled over to US cities as more commuters have taken up cycling and created a demand for more utilitarian gear. In the late 90s I had the same complaint you make above, but this is no longer the case. Along with their road and MTB lines all the major marques have introduced a range of 'street' or 'city' models.

The real challenge of improving anything in cycling, from an industrial design perspective, is that a bike is a product whose primary virtue is minimalism. Adding features can be useful for certain niche markets (suspension for downhillers, aero bars for racers) but for the most part a bike is only improved when one can deliver the same (or improved) characteristics of handling, comfort and durability while using less material. Sometimes this is a question of design improvement, but this is rare -- many designs recur over decades (like integrated headset bearings) without ever really becoming essential. More often improvements come from better materials and fabrication techniques.

Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by cgh on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:29PM (#5901854)
You clearly are not Dutch or Danish.
Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by buro9 on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:35PM (#5901899)
I would argue differently.

Take a look at Rohloff hubs.

Take a look at belt drives.

Take a look at disc brakes.

You've already dismissed everything to do with materials, oh well.

Sounds like you just mean: bicycles are two triangles and two hoops... and you would be right.

Strangely that's because the UCI restricted the development of bikes to ensure a level playing field, recumbents were banned in races, as were Moultons with their small wheels and pylon frames, as were the monocoque carbon frames, as were the bikes with farings.

Ultimately, being restricted to two triangles and two hoops means that the manufacturers can only really innovate with everything else.

Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by steelframe on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:18PM (#5901778)
Sure, we've got DMA and flash cells and multiple cores and other fun stuff now, but it's all really just garnish. A computer you buy today is not fundamentally different from a computer you might have bought 30 years ago.
Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by davidw on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @03:58PM (#5901635)
Gearing is a massive difference from a bicycle you could buy 100 years ago. It's what allows you to climb something like this, and race down the other side:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stelvio_Pass

Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by notatoad on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:11PM (#5901727)
The derailleur was invented in the 1890s. the gear ratios have changed, but gearing hasn't.
Re:Bicycle helmets haven't changed since their introduction by davidw on Tuesday June 18, 2013 @04:40PM (#5901926)
There were derailleur type things then, but nothing at all like the wide range of gearing that post WWII bicycles have.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Derailleur_gears