If Google ran its ship the same way with regard to hammering UI guidelines down everyone's throat, this would likely happen there as well. I don't know which is better or worse, but the two are certainly different, and it's either created a divide or pointed out a difference between people who strongly prefer one over the other.
What I find funny is that the people who are writing these articles are advanced users and not some grandmother who needs protection. Ie - if you are either a designer who deeply cares about how your icons look - don't be a sheep and customize your pocket computer the way you want.
Random examples:
https://lh5.ggpht.com/mKx3_D9fhszXZ3A-03zI5qsKi4yiecWo8i1jm_...
https://lh5.ggpht.com/nENqr4mCerIwGYtbn6lAhaWSE7P1itMRp_A5yL...
https://lh6.ggpht.com/T7nxYYhpmGDzg5Ckwu3L7Jb4HTHyKdGoz0n2u1...
https://lh6.ggpht.com/os72icmFlDtbxpYbZCP-v6kOereSLGDmlKsBl1...
https://lh6.ggpht.com/H_b-56TTd9bE-TOx13irsriNiqHCHijeaEcSaf...
The icon is a perfect representation of the game. I don't have to guess what it might be.
I chose icons I consider good looking. If you think they are ugly, that is a subjective matter. Also keep in mind that they are displayed much smaller on the screen.
The point I was trying to imply is that icons can much better represent their app if they are not forced to abide to a standard of shape or style.
1. Allow new users to guess at the functionality of apps before tapping them. This is important for first impressions (like trying out the phone at the store before buying it).
2. Allow current users to quickly and reliably navigate to the app they intend to use.
It seems to me that instead of arguing about skeuomorphism, there should just be some good old A/B testing for these two use cases. And whatever wins is best. Maybe Apple has done this, maybe not.
I've been using a shell for many years (doesn't matter which - can't even recall name now) which comes with its own icons. So to me this sounds as childish (ie Apple treating its customers as children who can't be trusted with picking their own icons) - as if my laptop had a set of preconfigured directory names and I could not rename them myself.
It's rather telling that all these people take the concept that icons on their pocket computer are G-d given and immutable, like a law of nature and that the most they can do is whine if they don't like them.