Re:What's Wrong with the iOS 7 Icons?
by czhiddy on Friday June 14, 2013 @06:53PM
(#5883000)
Wow. I'm sure there are examples that might prove your point, but those are some of ugliest icons I've ever seen. The second one looks like it's straight from Windows 3.1.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
What's important is that HE likes them. You don't have to agree :)
Re:What's Wrong with the iOS 7 Icons?
by Alphasite_ on Saturday June 15, 2013 @05:39AM
(#5884602)
Yes, but it runs counter to his own implication that more freedom -> higher quality, which is what he was pointing out.
I did not mean to imply that. But even if I did, quality is a subjective measure.
This is what the app (a game) looks like: https://lh3.ggpht.com/YYpdtrkXsIPU-I_CW3_vbYHXk1av1Qug4EYsrP...
The icon is a perfect representation of the game. I don't have to guess what it might be.
I chose icons I consider good looking. If you think they are ugly, that is a subjective matter. Also keep in mind that they are displayed much smaller on the screen.
The point I was trying to imply is that icons can much better represent their app if they are not forced to abide to a standard of shape or style.