News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by achille on Thursday June 13, 2013 @02:36AM (#5872626)
21 Comments so far and none commenting the State's Secret Privilege that allows such requests to be thrown out immediately. None of these lawsuits will go anywhere.

See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/State_secrets_privilege

People erroneously tortured by the govt had their cases thrown out. Cases as low as bank robbery have zero chance.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by Tuna-Fish on Thursday June 13, 2013 @03:34AM (#5872750)
The difference is that the tortured guy was suing the government, while this bank robber is being sued by the government. As it's a criminal case, the standard of proof is on his side. So, it's not necessary for there to be proof that he's innocent, all he needs to do is to create a little bit of doubt.

He's probably hoping that the government doesn't release records, as this could possibly be enough to free him.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by TomAnthony on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:27AM (#5872857)
Indeed, in the United States vs Reynolds Supreme Court case that seems to be considered the seminal [1] to establish the State's Secret Privilege:

  The district court rejected the formal claim and ordered the documents
  be produced; but, the government refused and the court entered final
  judgment for plaintiffs on the grounds that the refusal to produce the
  documents established the Air Force’s negligence.
It seems the same logic could potentially apply here?

[1] http://law.lclark.edu/live/files/9577-lcb111lyonspdf

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by ignostic on Thursday June 13, 2013 @11:51AM (#5874687)
Sadly I don't think so. I believe in that case it was certain that documents did exist and one party was just refusing to produce them. In this case, the NSA is neither prosecution nor defense, and therefore doesn't have the same disclosure requirements. Further, there's no proof the NSA has such records. But, like most people in this thread, I am not a lawyer.
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by icambron on Thursday June 13, 2013 @02:43AM (#5872636)
I'm not so sure. In what way are this guy's phone records a state secret?
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by fletchowns on Thursday June 13, 2013 @02:48AM (#5872645)
I'd say it's because they are part of a top secret government program
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by roboneal on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:09PM (#5876258)
A top secret program that the President of the United States has made extensive public remarks about:

http://blogs.wsj.com/washwire/2013/06/07/transcript-what-oba...

De facto de-classification.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by michaelfeathers on Thursday June 13, 2013 @02:53AM (#5872659)
Not any more.
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by Mordor on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:44AM (#5872917)
Actually, there are a lot of secret programs and there's going to be a PRISM II, which, coincidentally keeps an exact copy of the data from PRISM after it has been switched off.

The only way to get around this is to open up the NSA to an independent team of international cyber experts from the UN. It would set a great precedent of 21st century democracy and challenge totalitarian regimes around the world.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by ISL on Thursday June 13, 2013 @12:02PM (#5874753)
An impartial and independent team of observers is a good idea. It's hard to find impartial and independent observers. Another good choice is a large consortium of advocates for stakeholders.

If only we had a body of hundreds of people, chosen by citizens across the country charged with representing their interests and empowered to set the rules and budget for any such program. We could supplement that body with oversight from learned scholars; we can give them lifetime tenure in hopes that they'll remain impartial and give them the ability to find rules and actions inconsistent with fundamental principles.

We get the government for which we vote.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by uptown on Thursday June 13, 2013 @10:34AM (#5874224)
"The only way to get around this is to open up the NSA to an independent team of international cyber experts from the UN."

The UN is a powerless organization. Nations will always act in their own self-interests, and the power-players of the UN will ignore any efforts to intrude upon that authority if they can argue that it weakens national security.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by eru on Thursday June 13, 2013 @05:20AM (#5873041)
Why from the UN?
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by alan_cx on Thursday June 13, 2013 @06:36AM (#5873280)
Because its not the US and not a specific foreign state.

I know Americans hate the UN, to socialist and dares to criticise the US, but for non Americans it's the closest thing to an authority that they can at least try to believe in as independent. We all trust the UN weapons inspectors, yes? Well, not GW Bush on a war path, true, but the rest of us?

So how about UN Data Inspectors?

Do Americans really believe the rest of the planet even slightly trusts the US government? No. So the UN would be the best bet. Unless the US is prepared to be audited by, say, the French.

B5 fans will understand that the US is nicely represented to many by Mr Morden. Nice hair, nice suit, winning smile, all the right words.... surrounded by shadows.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by will_brown on Thursday June 13, 2013 @01:03PM (#5875160)
Americans hate the UN? The US subsidizes roughly 75% of the cost of the UN. That should emphasize the US commitment to the UN and international community.

It may be fair to say Americans are skeptical about relinquishing State Sovereignty, such as the US refusal to sign the Rome Statute and come under the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court, but most Americans would agree the UN is of great importance to the World.

>Do Americans really believe the rest of the planet even slightly trusts the US government? No

I think if you took a poll at any given time a majority of Americans would not trust their own government. American history teaches us to have a healthy skepticism for government. That skepticism would certainly extend to the UN, whereas at least the US is a democracy, in all its imperfection, which includes terms limits and elections, it only makes sense to be skeptical of relinquishing sovereignty to a UN that includes States represented by authoritarian and repressive regimes.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by icambron on Saturday June 15, 2013 @05:38PM (#5886364)
Do you have a source for that 75% number? He's one for 22%: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations#Funding
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by pilsetnieks on Thursday June 13, 2013 @08:44AM (#5873700)
Let's say the inspectors would come from the countries represented in the Security Council. Would you really believe that Russians or Chinese would appoint truly impartial inspectors with no agenda?

Frankly, as bad as this whole situation sounds, I trust the US government far more than Russia or China.

Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by lifeisstillgood on Thursday June 13, 2013 @12:48PM (#5875045)
Mr Borden? Lizzie Borden's father? I dont get the reference
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by chinpokomon on Thursday June 13, 2013 @06:24AM (#5873234)
My thoughts too.
Re:Bank robbery suspect wants NSA phone records for his defense by Confusion on Thursday June 13, 2013 @04:56AM (#5872951)
Because officially these phone records don't exist and acknowledging their existence is a confession that everything Snowden alledges is actually true.