I stated my opinion elsewhere on this thread: Use what works for you.
That said, I do wonder how you'd like to back up your claims here? I mean - if you'd just say "Bah! Gnome 3 is a step in the wrong direction and the Gnome developers are clueless. I'm moving on" that'd be fine and cool - I guess everyone could understand reasons to do that, without neccessarily agreeing.
But you
- state that a 'majority' hates Gnome 3.
What? Really? A 'majority' of .. which representative group?
- state that Gnome developers consider their users as dumb (I .. hope I didn't misrepresent you here) That's impossible to back, insulting and quite frankly it's hard to assign a
single motive to the 'Gnome developers'
- argue that they lost market share for some reason Ignoring whether you're right or not (I .. tend to disagree): Why would that be
important? Why do you consider 'rule the DE market' / 'be a leader in the DE
market' (what market??) a worthwhile goal of the Gnome project? In my
opinion they should provide one of a number of consistent desktop
environments..This reminds me when some version of Nautilus (around 2003?) adopted that ridiculous open each folder in new window thing without an option to disable it.
Instead of listening to outcry of very much every single user out there, the person in charge insisted that his vision was the "correct" way of using desktop metaphor, and suggested everyone to get over it.
But good for them, it's easier to be "brilliant" and "forward thinking" with zero users to support.