But good for them, it's easier to be "brilliant" and "forward thinking" with zero users to support.
That said, I do wonder how you'd like to back up your claims here? I mean - if you'd just say "Bah! Gnome 3 is a step in the wrong direction and the Gnome developers are clueless. I'm moving on" that'd be fine and cool - I guess everyone could understand reasons to do that, without neccessarily agreeing.
But you
- state that a 'majority' hates Gnome 3.
What? Really? A 'majority' of .. which representative group?
- state that Gnome developers consider their users as dumb (I .. hope I didn't misrepresent you here) That's impossible to back, insulting and quite frankly it's hard to assign a
single motive to the 'Gnome developers'
- argue that they lost market share for some reason Ignoring whether you're right or not (I .. tend to disagree): Why would that be
important? Why do you consider 'rule the DE market' / 'be a leader in the DE
market' (what market??) a worthwhile goal of the Gnome project? In my
opinion they should provide one of a number of consistent desktop
environments..Instead of listening to outcry of very much every single user out there, the person in charge insisted that his vision was the "correct" way of using desktop metaphor, and suggested everyone to get over it.
Right?
The problem extends further than just GNOME's stupidity. When you have forks, you get a lot of fragmentation. Now, nobody can figure out whether to develop for GTK2, GTK3, Qt, or goddamned xaw because there is just so much fragmentation in the desktop environments. If GNOME had just been sane, there would be no MATE, there would be no Cinnamon, there would be no Unity, and we wouldn't be having this discussion right now.
Here's an example: I use Evolution as my email client. An important email comes in that I'd like to store in a project folder. In Gnome 2 you just drag and drop directly to the target folder; in Gnome 3 you have to right-click; choose "Move To"; then browse to the target folder (that is right before your f-ing eyes), and hope that it works.
It's the same for every application. Open 2 Nautilus windows, try to shift-select a bunch of files and drag to the other window -- does.not.work
For me lack of drag and drop is the single biggest strike against Gnome 3.
I use a tiling WM (i3) with Fedora 18; when I switch to Fedora 19 it will very likely be a Gnome-less stack.
I, on the other end of the spectrum, have yet to find someone who loves it.
I switched to XFCE because I found GNOME 3 to be a terrible experience, despite having loved GNOME 2.
Could you provide some details and corrections? "It's wrong" is not saying much really...
"The extension system is brilliant; I have used it to tweak every aspect to my liking."
The author raises a good point about backwards compatibility, what's your experience with it? How do you keep / plan to keep your customisation up to date after upgrades?
You get upgrade hell with Firefox extensions too, btw. I see that as a necessary tradeoff; I don't want core development bogged down by BC, and I want my extensions to be maintained and improved.
Not even close to what happens in GNOME 3. Firefox has an extension API, GNOME shell doesn't; that has consequences.
I'm not, that happened two years ago, and the only one that lost something there is the GNOME project.
There's no point in answering the rest of your comments, because apparently your mind is not capable of understanding that people are different, and why a project should not piss its current users.
Attempting to continue some war on it is useless, there are many people who are quite pleased with GNOME 3, just because you aren't doesn't mean you need to keep deriding it, just move on and stop caring. As made obvious the past several times you've written incredibly similar pieces, the greater GNOME community doesn't care. There's no purpose to what you're doing.
GNOME 3 is by far the best desktop environment I have ever used. The extension system is brilliant; I have used it to tweak every aspect to my liking. Every person I've shown it to, developer and otherwise, has loved it. It is incredibly polished and stable, especially in the latest version 3.8.
I'm tired of all the bullshit being spread about GNOME 3. If you're going to cling to the past, you're free to use a shitty--I'm sorry--traditional desktop environment.