News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by betterunix on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @06:51PM (#5865243)
Ah, well, glad that is cleared up. "We never give the government direct access to our systems, nor do we have a server set up for them to obtain copies. Instead, we just use scp to send the data directly to the government's systems! Trust us, we respect your privacy while we do this -- it's even encrypted!"
Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by cromwellian on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @06:57PM (#5865275)
Google never said it doesn't send data on user accounts when proper legal warrants are served, it publishes these facts in the yearly Transparency Report.

What people were worried about, a "dragnet" that allows arbitrary access and intercept of any user data by the NSA turns out to be false.

Unless you think you can use SFTP to upload, in real time, all traffic on Google services.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by cracell on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @07:40PM (#5865483)
Google continuing to deny that their is a dragnet is not evidence that their is no dragnet. If there was a dragnet it is very likely that they legally are not allowed to admit it as per terms of the court order.

There's nothing Google could say or do to clear their name on this. The NSA, Congress or the Executive branch need to detail the level of access and the form of access that the NSA has to Google's information in order to clear Google's name. Even that unfortunately has to be taken with a large grain of salt.

There's simply too much information pointing towards mass surveillance with assistance from US companies to believe what the companies themselves say. This is a shitty position for Google to be in but consumers didn't put them in it, the US government did by admitting to the PRISM slides being correct without detailing how the companies mentioned on them are involved.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by jmillikin on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @08:11PM (#5865616)

  > If there was a dragnet it is very likely that they
  > legally are not allowed to admit it as per terms of
  > the court order.
In the US, gag orders may compel silence but to my knowledge may not compel private citizens to claim they are not under a gag.

  > The NSA, Congress or the Executive branch need to
  > detail the level of access and the form of access
  > that the NSA has to Google's information in order
  > to clear Google's name.
Just to be clear: you believe that Google's press release is untrustworthy, but you would trust an NSA press release about the extent of NSA surveillance?
Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by DannyBee on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @11:36PM (#5866389)
"In the US, gag orders may compel silence but to my knowledge may not compel private citizens to claim they are not under a gag."

This is correct.

There is a difference between people lying, compelling silence, and being forced to lie.

The government can force people to be silent, be it upcoming raids, targets of investigations that they don't want tipped off, etc.

I know of zero legal authority that allows the government to force people to actively lie.

If anyone here does, i'd love to see it.

There is in fact, authority that the government cannot compel false or misleading statements. None that i'm aware of in the national security context, but this actually comes up quite a bit in the abortion context.

For example, Casey vs. Planned parenthood and others make it very clear the government cannot compel you to speak misleading information.

Opinions argue about what is false and what is misleading, but that is clearly not an issue here.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by jedbrown on Sunday June 16, 2013 @11:50AM (#5888790)
Does this imply that a personalized canary similar to [1] asserting that no information had been disclosed effectively makes it possible for a company to notify a user promptly (by discontinuing the daily canary)? Or would the court rule that discontinuing the canary is communication, thus requiring the company to continue updating the personalized canary after disclosing information about that person, despite the canary now being a direct lie?

[1] http://www.rsync.net/resources/notices/canary.txt

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by cracell on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @08:39PM (#5865720)
An NSA release that is confirmed by another party such as Senator Wyden, Rand Paul, ACLU or EFF.

Realistically I'm not sure what the NSA would share with anyone that could be conclusive. But a logical explanation of how the NSA gets into data without corporate cooperation and that explanation matching up with the timeline presented on the one slide would be a great start.

For instance, you could argue that the PRISM timeline is simply showing once the NSA had filters in place to identify and capture general internet traffic headed to and from those specific companies. But this has a large hole in that why would Google, a company who's search queries would be highly valued, come so far after Microsoft on the timeline. So an explanation that addresses the large questions like that.

As opposed to the current situation which is a credible leak that makes Google look very bad, an executive branch that is defending the information in the leak as being legal and Google flat out denying any involvement.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by aniket_ray on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @08:48PM (#5865749)
I think you're conflating two different issues. The government was defending intercepting emails and getting phone records. The government too never claimed that they can access data from web companies.
Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by mpyne on Wednesday June 12, 2013 @12:31PM (#5868960)
Of course the company would have to cooperate to make PRISM work, but I think you're missing what PRISM is meant to do on the company end.

It takes what the company was doing manually before PRISM (complying with NSLs and FISA warrants)...

and automates part of that process.

What it doesn't do is insert NSA as a wiretap into all their systems's traffic, as that's not what FISA compliance needed in the first place.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by StavrosK on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @08:20PM (#5865653)
> Google continuing to deny that their is a dragnet is not evidence that their is no dragnet.

Of course it is. It's not proof, but it's evidence. It shifts the probability towards "there is no dragnet" by some amount. Maybe it's not significant, but it's there.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by felisGoodman on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @07:26PM (#5865412)
If the NSA can request data on 'suspects' at will from Google, how is that functionally different from a dragnet? Arbitrary data could be collected via phone records, then email/user data could be requested from Google/Facebook based on 'suspicious activity'.

I bet that the bombshell disclosure will be that these 'proper legal warrants' are actually just arbitrary requests justified via the Patriot Act or similar.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by cromwellian on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @10:48PM (#5866216)
I don't know what the official definition of dragnet is, but when PRISM first came out, the hyperbolic, dramatic media interpretation was that of a firehose -- NSA gets a feed of everyone's data and can search it at will.

Now the scenario is: They must obtain NSL/FISA orders, Google reviews them, then the data on their target is released.

Is that a dragnet? What if when Google wins the right to publish statistics on NSL/FISA requests, it turns out to be just a few hundred per year, or less than regular search warrants, like when a guy is suspected of killing his wife.

Would that change your opinion? It seems that the pitchforks came out on the original WashPo/Guardian scenario, and if that turns out to be wrong, people will keep moving the goal posts and not put the pitchforks away.

Some people just want to believe that the tech companies are greedy, unscrupulous, entities.

Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by eightyone on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @08:12PM (#5865622)
I wonder why Greenwald and the Guardian haven't released more information yet. Maybe they are waiting for all the tech news to die down? Are there any other major things happening this week?
Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by rasterizer on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @06:58PM (#5865280)
How else would one comply with data requests?
Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP by mpyne on Tuesday June 11, 2013 @11:11PM (#5866312)
Print out a bunch of QR codes and FedEx it, I guess.