Re:Google’s Real Secret Spy Program? Secure FTP
by jedbrown on Sunday June 16, 2013 @11:50AM
(#5888790)
Does this imply that a personalized canary similar to [1] asserting that no information had been disclosed effectively makes it possible for a company to notify a user promptly (by discontinuing the daily canary)? Or would the court rule that discontinuing the canary is communication, thus requiring the company to continue updating the personalized canary after disclosing information about that person, despite the canary now being a direct lie?
This is correct.
There is a difference between people lying, compelling silence, and being forced to lie.
The government can force people to be silent, be it upcoming raids, targets of investigations that they don't want tipped off, etc.
I know of zero legal authority that allows the government to force people to actively lie.
If anyone here does, i'd love to see it.
There is in fact, authority that the government cannot compel false or misleading statements. None that i'm aware of in the national security context, but this actually comes up quite a bit in the abortion context.
For example, Casey vs. Planned parenthood and others make it very clear the government cannot compel you to speak misleading information.
Opinions argue about what is false and what is misleading, but that is clearly not an issue here.