News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by ig1 on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:07PM (#5842680)
Facebook: "We do not provide any government organization with direct access to Facebook servers."

Yahoo: "We do not provide the government with direct access to our servers"

AOL: "nor do we provide any government agency with access to our servers."

Paltalk: "Paltalk does not provide any government agency with direct access to its servers"

Apple: "We do not provide any government agency with direct access to our servers"

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by lawdawg on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:59PM (#5842910)
And if they didn't say that, everyone on HN would be whining about why they didn't deny "direct access" when that was the headline accusation.

Can't win with you guys.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by ig1 on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:14PM (#5842965)
It's not the phrase "direct access" (which they could reasonably use given it was used in the original leak story), but rather the construction of the whole sentence.

There are millions of ways you could phrase the response (Dropbox and Microsoft used completely different language), the chance that these five came up with the phrasing used independently seems fairly low. Especially as the statements weren't all given to a single reporter (who could have phrased the question in a particular way) but rather to a variety of different news sources.

It could still be completely innocent, they could all have cribbed off whoever did the first denial or they could have discussed it beforehand and co-ordinated messages without there having been any government involvement.

It is however something that needs explaining.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by DannyBee on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:24PM (#5843222)
There are millions of ways to deny things.

This is the most clear and direct way

I accused you of doing X

You could say "you know, my brother and I, we once, 30 years ago blah blah blah blah blah blah but X, X never happened".

Most people, however, will just say "No, i don't do X".

They were accused, point blank, of providing direct access to their servers. They said "we do not provide direct access to their servers".

But please, see a conspiracy here because people are trying to be as direct and clear.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by eatitraw on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:37PM (#5843449)
I accused you of doing X on mondays. You could say "You know, in fact, I do X, but on tuesdays". Most hypocrites however will take your question as literally as possible and will just say: "No, I don't do X on mondays".

You see, people don't want to know if government has direct access(ok, they want, but it is not their primary concern), they want to know what happened.

It simply doesn't matter if google uploads data to government servers or government gets data from google servers by "directly accessing" them. I would even guess that the latter is simpler to implement and maintain.

I don't mean that google is happy to hand user data to government - they probably aren't - I want to know how many data governments gets.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by DannyBee on Saturday June 08, 2013 @10:57PM (#5847331)
"You see, people don't want to know if government has direct access(ok, they want, but it is not their primary concern), they want to know what happened. "

The companies are saying they have no idea. They literally said "we've never heard of this program". What more do you want?

The claim the newspapers made, in line 1, was, "the government has direct access". The denial made was "the government does not have direct access".

If they want to publish a different claim, i'm sure a different denial will be written.

If you want to know what happened, why are you asking GOogle? Go ask the NSA

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by ig1 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @03:37AM (#5844252)
No it isn't. You can run it through plagiarism software which is specifically designed to take into account scenarios like your suggest and it'll be flagged.

For example why do they all use the word "provide" there are hundreds of synonyms that work just as well ("given", "enabled", "allowed", "have", etc.). They weren't accused of "providing" the access, it's a word they've chosen to use.

The specific accusation was about the NSA, why are the denials using "government agencies" or synonyms rather than NSA. There might be perfectly valid reasons, but the chance that they'd all make the same decision to use it independently ?

Why are they all in current tense rather than "we have never x" ?

If there were on or two similarities it might be coincidence, but we're talking about dozens of grammatically and phrasing choices.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by arrrg on Saturday June 08, 2013 @05:03AM (#5844382)
Because it is plagiarism. Do you honestly believe the PR people who wrote this didn't also read what others wrote? I don't think they released their statements all the same second.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by twelvechairs on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:27PM (#5843020)
It is the phrase 'direct access'. It basically makes the whole sentence meaningless (i.e. whatever the truth is, the statement is defensible).
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by espeed on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:03AM (#5843884)
Here's an example of how a government agency could get indirect access to phone data...

Amdocs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amdocs) provides billing services and customer support for most of the major phone companies so it has access to all of the transactional data on your billing statement. If a government agency had access to the Amdocs data, it would have access to the phone data through an indirect channel.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by leoc on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:24PM (#5843011)
> they could have discussed it beforehand and co-ordinated messages without there having been any government involvement

These are after all companies several (all?) of whom have co-ordinated illegal no-hire compacts in the past: it's not far-fetched to think they'd work together on a PR response to this. Which isn't necessarily to rule out a more sinister explanation of course.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by kahirsch on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:40PM (#5843459)
Who says they did it independently? I'm sure the people who wrote each statement read the others that had been previously released.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by ryguytilidie on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:43PM (#5843292)
Commits massive domestic spying operation, people complain.

"Can't win with you guys."

I mean, not much more you can do than just laugh at shit like this. Yeah man, everyone here is so unreasonable with their standard of "I don't like when companies blatantly lie" how hypocritical of them?

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by mikeash on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:16PM (#5842971)
Are you complaining that they can't win when it comes to the right PR spin on a massive spying program?
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by chc on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:23PM (#5842999)
I think lawdawg is saying there's no reasonable way they can deny participating in a massive spying program without somebody saying it sounds dodgy.

And it is kind of true: "We do not provide any government agency with direct access to our servers" is the clearest construction I can imagine for denying involvement, but they get called out for it anyway.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by mikeash on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:41PM (#5843065)
That's only because the facts suggest that they are involved. It is very hard to state an obvious lie without sounding dodgy. That's hardly our fault.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by elchief on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:29PM (#5842778)
"we do however give them a data dump every minute"
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by ccera on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:49PM (#5843088)
Those statements are probably true. The NSA has probably subcontracted the operation out to a private corporation. So Facebook, Google, et al, don't deal directly with the government, they deal with the private company.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by Sven7 on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:14PM (#5843379)
Or the govt believes the program exists when it really doesn't ;)

and don't tell me that hasn't happened before.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by papaf on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:23AM (#5843941)
In at least two cases, at Google and Facebook, one of the plans discussed was to build separate, secure portals, like a digital version of the secure physical rooms that have long existed for classified information, in some instances on company servers. Through these online rooms, the government would request data, companies would deposit it and the government would retrieve it, people briefed on the discussions said.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/08/technology/tech-companies-...

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by est on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:39PM (#5843454)
The Chinese security bureau didn't have "direct acces to servers" as well, instead, they install black boxs in every IDC which mirror router traffic to an unknown destination.

There's also shit ton of papers on Chines academia on how to reconstruct and rapid classify packets from raw IP dumps

Edit: THIS -> https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5843442 Beam splitters, or 分光 as called in Chinese.

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by Lost_BiomedE on Saturday June 08, 2013 @12:23AM (#5843789)
At least this would be a good explanation on why we ended up with the obviously sub-optimal duopoly in internet access/providers.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by pyvpx on Sunday June 09, 2013 @11:20AM (#5849188)
do you have any good tips/links/search terms to find this tonnage of papers? I'm curious.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by stfu on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:19PM (#5842983)
Love it how they got played. I hope they appreciate the way the administration let them look and lie their customers in the face.

Wish I had been a fly on the wall when they where instructed on what to say and how to phrase it. It is certainly no accident that they came out on the same day, with the same phrasing, etc

Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by wavefunction on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:25PM (#5843012)
You're supposed to love it and feel clever. Meanwhile the machine marches on.
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by leoc on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:55PM (#5843111)
But Clapper's statement predates the tech companies' response, no?
Re:White House admits it has 'access' to Facebook, Google by runn1ng on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:46PM (#5843300)
That is very creepy and suspicious indeed.