News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by mullingitover on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:24PM (#5841496)
It's exactly the kind of denial you'd expect them to issue if they were legally required to deny any involvement.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Dove on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:14PM (#5841944)
That's moving the goalposts, though. The initial assertion -- that this is a cleverly-worded non-denial -- doesn't hold up with the text. Page is clearly and unambiguously denying that Google supplies any information to the government on a millions-of-users scale.

Saying that denial is a lie . . . is a completely different charge.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by hotpockets on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:07PM (#5842319)
Google could be searching email for certain series of characters, like "xxxx obama" and handing that over. Perhaps NSA supplies google a list of phrases to look for.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by white_devil on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:59PM (#5842258)
> Page is clearly and unambiguously denying that Google supplies any information to the government on a millions-of-users scale.

Kind of like Mariano Rajoy insisted that Spain didn't need a bailout?

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by adventured on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:02PM (#5843345)
And the Federal Reserve said there was no real estate bubble to worry about. And the banks were well capitalized.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by magicalist on Saturday June 08, 2013 @03:03AM (#5844172)
Yes, and murderers always insist that they're innocent. QED. We've got them now!
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Dove on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:26PM (#5842036)
I don't think so. Those usually sound like,

    "We cannot confirm or deny the existence of such a program," 
or

    "It is not our policy to comment on national security topics"
or

    "No comment." 
or even

    "We'll wait for the results of the investigation."
I don't think the government generally asks civilians to lie so enthusiastically, because . . . well, as a rule, they just aren't good at it.

No, I think it's most likely that Page doesn't know of any such program. Now, it's always possible that such a thing is being carried out on the scale everyone fears by a rogue, loyal-to-the-NSA employee, or a group of them. Or it's possible the original Powerpoint slide including Google as an information source is oversimplified or even inaccurate. Such things do happen when presenting overviews of program capabilities.

And many other things in between are possible. It's concerning, but . . . I'll wait for the results of the investigation. ;)

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by mullingitover on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:42PM (#5842146)
It's also possible that Larry is concerned about his share price, and what would happen to it if Google was revealed to be completely in bed with the NSA (My guess is it would fall quite a bit). He has real money at stake in limiting the damage that comes from this revelation.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Avenger42 on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:46PM (#5842170)
The fallout in such a case has to be smaller than it would be if it comes out later that, not only were they in bed with the NSA, they (and the other companies in this situation) blatantly lied about it with their statements today.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by bigiain on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:29PM (#5843026)
I guess keeping an eye out for Larry (et al) cashing out shares over the next few weeks/months might be a good indicator of the likelyhood of exactly that "coming out later".
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by gohrt on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:54AM (#5844010)
For obvious reasons, it is illegal for CEOs to sell stock on short notice.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Matt_Cutts on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:38PM (#5842124)
Really? You don't see any difference between the denial posted by Google's CEO vs. the way that (say) Verizon responded? Here's Verizon's response: http://www.businessinsider.com/verizons-memo-to-workers-abou...
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by ynniv on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:54PM (#5842214)
A better carefully worded response is still a carefully worded response. Google is in a difficult place because we all expected this to be happening, there are now documents suggesting that it has been happening, and no one takes at face value anything that sounds like a lawyer wrote it.

EDIT: I mean: (a) No one cares if they have heard about a program called "PRISM" when the point of that program is to aggregate data from other programs. (b) Anyone who is actually innocent in this needs to stop mentioning "direct access to servers": no one expects this program to be directly accessing servers. (c) We also don't care whether actions were "in accordance with the law", as the constitutionality of the surrounding laws is part of the debate.

I will say that "Any suggestion that Google is disclosing information about our users’ Internet activity on such a scale is completely false." is a good statement to make. It sounds broad in a good way and doesn't appear to have many weasel words, other than specifying "Internet activity" and not email or general activity. Are Google searches even "Internet activity", or is he referring to Google Analytics / Google +1 / 8.8.8.8 DNS?

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by solnyshok on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:15PM (#5842374)
"direct access to servers" looks suspicios to me as well. However, maybe several dozen lawyers had no clue how to react today, and they just copied one another's text?
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Matt_Cutts on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:05PM (#5842933)
More likely: the first paragraph from the Guardian and the Washington Post both emphasized "direct" access. See the picture here: http://cl.ly/image/2S3i1g2W2R2k

If you're refuting claims of behavior X, it's natural to say "We don't do behavior X."

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by mikeash on Saturday June 08, 2013 @03:01PM (#5845862)
Especially when you're doing X' instead, and don't want to draw attention to it.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by davros on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:22PM (#5842741)
The problem is that Obama himself has acknowledged the program both exists and is very active, the only limitation being 'Internet monitoring is only for those outside United States'- no comfort for Google users like myself outside the US[1].

I don't mind targeted surveillance against genuine suspected terrorists. What frightens me is broader intelligence collection especially commercial intelligence. Over time programs broaden and if we're not really, really careful we'll find gmail being read by intelligence analysts who can brief our US competitors.

If non-Americans can't trust Google with their information that is an existential risk to its future. I think the Google leadership needs to do a lot more than this one short post!

[1] From Obama's comments: Now, with respect to the Internet and emails, this does not apply to U.S. citizens, and it does not apply to people living in the United States. And again, in this instance, not only is Congress fully apprised of it, but what is also true is that the FISA Court has to authorize it.

So in summary, what you’ve got is two programs that were originally authorized by Congress, have been repeatedly authorized by Congress.

That seems pretty clear - there is a congress-approved spying on non-US citizens Internet and email.

EDIT: added Obama quote

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by dTal on Saturday June 08, 2013 @07:37AM (#5844601)
"I don't mind targeted surveillance against genuine suspected terrorists."

This kind of language bothers me - "suspected terrorist" requires no proof at all, while sounding authoritative (65% of Americans support the remote execution by drone of 'suspected terrorists').

I know roughly what you meant, of course, but where that line is drawn is a discussion that needs to be had. I'd say that with the level of surveillance that goes on, we are all suspected terrorists now.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by adventured on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:07PM (#5843358)
I find it fascinating that Matt Cutts didn't bother to address any of this in his defense of Google. Obama and James Clapper have both admitted to what is obviously Prism, a large scale spying program targeting Internet users and their data.

It rather makes it clear that Google is participating in espionage programs for the NSA. Supposedly, maybe, it isn't directed at Americans (har har).

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by unreal37 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:30AM (#5843952)
I don't think they are. I think ISP's allow government equipment on their networks to capture traffic as they see fit. If every ISP participates, then they have Google data, Facebook data, Yahoo data, and on and on.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by declan on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:08PM (#5843360)
Obama has acknowledged that federal law allows FedGov to obtain emails of non-citizens without a search warrant but through a court-overseen process. This is part of a 2008 law that we all know (if you've been paying attention) does this.

The president has not, however, confirmed that the news reports about "PRISM" are accurate. All he's done is summarized the law.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by GoodIntentions on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:04PM (#5842666)
The last couple lines of his blog post seemed to convey, at least to me, that he was posting truth but perhaps not as much as he'd like.

"We post this information on our Transparency Report whenever possible... ...we understand that the U.S. and other governments need to take action to protect their citizens’ safety—including sometimes by using surveillance. But the level of secrecy around the current legal procedures undermines the freedoms we all cherish."

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by unreal37 on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:27AM (#5843948)
In the transparency report, Google can only report wide ranges of numbers, not actual numbers (i.e. 1000-4999). They have always said they wished they could provide the actual numbers of requests as well as copies of the requests themselves, so this is consistent with that.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by tomkarlo on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:31PM (#5843036)
It's well-known that there are restrictions on how much companies can legally disclose about some of these government requests.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by teawithcarl on Friday June 07, 2013 @07:19PM (#5842725)
Matt - Many of us believe that many of the people at Google are doing their best, however in this instance you're not doing the right thing.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Matt_Cutts on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:24PM (#5843008)
Hey teawithcarl, I appreciate that. I'd be interested in hearing what you think the right thing is. I suspect that we're actually in agreement on most points. If there's something you think we should be doing differently (and I agree with you :), I'm more than happy to lobby for that within Google.

I do think Google is working hard to protect our users from unwarranted government requests. Just speaking for me personally, I really dislike provisions in the PATRIOT Act and FISA that compel secrecy. One thing I did like in Google's blog post was that we spoke out against the "level of secrecy around the current legal procedures." I was encouraged that Facebook later said something similar. In my opinion, a lot of the frustration about the current situation would be best applied to changing some laws in the United States.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by bigiain on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:50PM (#5843091)
Hey Matt.

While I honestly think _you_ believe Google is doing "the right thing" - there's a nagging suspicion that there's some NSL-style legal (or possibly extra-legal) compulsion being used at the very top levels. Even if I believe that Larry is 100% "on my side" against the government - I'm also under no doubt that Larry and Google are effectively powerless against the pressure the various US government agencies could apply if they so chose.

While explanations of the similarity between Larry's and Mark Z's posts based on direct rebuttal of the WaPo article are plausible, when combined with Apple's, AOL's, and Yahoo's suspiciously similar structure and wording - cynical-me can't help but wonder if all 5 CEO's are being compelled to disseminate the same government supplied message (and are possibly intentionally using almost word-for-word similar language as a plausibly deniable way of telling people that).

I'm not sure if there's much Google can say or do - given the depth and seriousness of the seeds of suspicion that've already been sown… (Having said that, I was pleased to read Yonatan's G+ post earlier today…)

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by declan on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:18PM (#5843393)
When AT&T was asked politely by the NSA to open its networks under the warrantless surveillance program, the company refused to confirm or deny. They actually offered arguments like this one from an AT&T attorney:

http://news.cnet.com/Legal-loophole-emerges-in-NSA-spy-progr... Federal law may "authorize and in some cases require telecommunications companies to furnish information" to the executive branch, said Bradford Berenson, who was associate White House counsel when President Bush authorized the NSA surveillance program in late 2001 and is now a partner at the Sidley Austin law firm in Washington, D.C. Far from being complicit in an illegal spying scheme, Berenson said, "AT&T is essentially an innocent bystander."

And a sealed AT&T document I obtained tried to offer benign reasons why there would be a secret room at its downtown San Francisco switching center that would be designed to monitor Internet and telephone traffic: http://news.cnet.com/2100-1028_3-6077353.html

What Google and Facebook are doing today is precisely the opposite of what AT&T did.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by teawithcarl on Saturday June 08, 2013 @12:30AM (#5843808)
Hi Matt - Thanks for answering. I genuinely appreciate your earnest communication. To answer your question, I sincerely believe Larry should do the right thing irregardless of the law, which means telling the American public the truth.

What Sergey (and Google) bravely did in China gave Google years of priceless respectability. This is one of those situations where civil disobedience is best. I realize you can't just "pull out of the United States", yet Google is looking like liars, and that just doesn't work.

For what it's worth, if Larry summoned the courage to speak his conscience completely, he will not go to jail. Far from it ... Google will be the true statesman, showing courage and leadership.

Indeed, I believe it may help Google the most, by catalyzing people's courage to do what's right. It's simply wrong to associate yourself with this.

It must come from Google first, Google is the strongest. Please consider the honor in doing this. Done genuinely, the public will rally behind Google, just like SOPA/PIPA. And don't forget, you have the world's largest bully pulpit.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Matt_Cutts on Saturday June 08, 2013 @08:53PM (#5846996)
Thanks for posting this. Here's something I wrote to someone recently: "I view talking about FISA (see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillan... ) like handling radioactive waste or juggling chainsaws: it has to be done carefully." The reason is that FISA orders come with a gag order: see https://ssd.eff.org/foreign/fisa . So I understand why official company blog posts, even from Larry, have been carefully worded so far, even if that comes across as legalistic or weaselly-worded to some.

For what it's worth, I'd recommend reading this post: https://plus.sandbox.google.com/+YonatanZunger/posts/huwQsph... To me, Yonatan's post read as the sort of personal, even blunt statement that you're asking for.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by teawithcarl on Saturday June 08, 2013 @10:06PM (#5847193)
Will do, thanks. Genuinely appreciate you.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by gohrt on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:47AM (#5843988)
It is literally impossible for you to know for certain if Larry Page is telling the truth or lying about PRISM. So, now what?

Are you asking Larry to violate the law on National Security Letters, by publicly posting their content?

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by onecommentonly on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:56PM (#5842227)
Verizon said what they could: we have to comply with the orders when we get them. Nothing weaselly, maybe because we read the judge's order.

Why should we trust the safety of any information on our searches, emails, location data, chats etc stored by Google? Stop storing it

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by ashleyblackmore on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:20PM (#5843398)
Thought twice about posting this, but am I the only one who feels really queasy about someone like Matt Cutts jumping directly into conversations about their own company on HN (especially when it could be connoted as being part of damage control)? He's hardly rank-and-file. I think it is plain old creepy, YMMV.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by tptacek on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:39PM (#5843648)
Yes, you might be the only person here to suggest Matt Cutts is ever unwelcome on any HN thread.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by ashleyblackmore on Saturday June 08, 2013 @12:15AM (#5843766)
Heh, did you get out of the wrong side of bed today? I don't spend all day reading HN comments - sorry if my knowledge of responses to Matt Cutts' posts isn't as comprehensive and magnificent as your own. When I posted this, nobody else had said anything.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by declan on Friday June 07, 2013 @11:27PM (#5843611)
As a reporter, I think it's great. I wish we'd see senior folks from Microsoft, Yahoo, Facebook, AOL, and Apple doing the same right now.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by Matt_Cutts on Saturday June 08, 2013 @09:16PM (#5847067)
ashleyblackmore, the initial news stories seemed to imply voluntary, wide-scale, direct access to Google's (and other's) data by the NSA. I genuinely thought that sounded wrong and against the bent of Google--both its execs and the rank and file employees. In the last few days, more recent stories have indicated that it's more like compelled, limited FISA requests, which all US companies are legally required to respond to. See Yahoo's recent post at http://yahoo.tumblr.com/post/52491403007/setting-the-record-... which also points in this direction.

Compelled and limited is a very different story than voluntary, wide-scale, and direct. Do I like FISA? No, I think it sucks. FISA orders come with a gag order, and laws that compel secrecy like that should be struck down, in my opinion. But in recent days, you've heard the CEO of Google say that they haven't gotten the sort of broad requests that (say) Verizon got, and that Google can and does push back on requests that they consider too broad.

I think the proper response to this issue should be frustration with bad laws, and calling your Senator or Representative in Congress to tell them that.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by gohrt on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:48AM (#5843991)
You demand answers from Google leaders. A Google leader gives you answers. This upsets you?
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by davidmr on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:56PM (#5841807)
I've never heard it said that anyone was required to deny involvement. Did you mean that exactly as you wrote?

I think there's a world of difference between a gag order where you are not allowed to confirm, and an order to explicitly deny involvement. I'm not saying the former is "good", but there's a difference.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by bigiain on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:58PM (#5843128)
OK, I'll say it.

I think there's a non-zero probability that there are US government agencies who can and have compelled people to explicitly deny something that they know is true.

Realistically, it would boggle my mind to discover they'd done that to all the founders/CEOs/legal departments of all the companies involved here (at least Google/Facebook/Apple/Yahoo/AOL), but given the stakes in this game - I have no doubt that it _could_ be done.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by cheald on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:26PM (#5841517)
I agree, but what could Page say to convince us otherwise?

Either the government is coercing them, and they have to issue lies as denials, or they are participating voluntarily and are voluntarily lying, or they are not participating. The second option seems unlikely to me.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by mpyne on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:36PM (#5841624)
Well, you can't prove a negative so I'm not sure there's anything Page can say.

But at the same time they can't all be right. NSA says it's getting data in some form from Google, Page says no direct access.

The truth is probably somewhere in the middle then... but where?

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by dragonwriter on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:55PM (#5841801)
I don't know why we'd expect the truth to be in the middle. If the NSA document is genuine, the information the NSA is collecting from Google is part of a Top Secret program as described in the leaked internal document.

If that is true, why would we expect that Google officials would be able to make any public confirmation of the Top Secret program? And, given that, why, in that case, would we expect the truth to be "in the middle"?

Conversely, if the leaked document is not genuine, then I still don't see any basis for expecting the truth to be in the "middle" between the false document and the Google denial.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by dwild on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:15PM (#5841946)
Did I miss some information? I only saw two slides. One that show the potential data accessible and one that show when the companies were added. It doesn't say exactly that they had access to everything. As far as we know PRISM can simply be there to centralize the information that the NSA got in legals ways. We do know that the government ask about 100 users account information each day to Google, we can guess that they do the same to every company on that list and they were all added to PRISM at the date you can find on the slides. I mean that slide contains one of the most important information that we currently have to guess the magnitude of PRISM, the budget. They only need 20 millions $ every years. True data mining is much more expensive than that.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by cheald on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:42PM (#5841688)
I'm 100% with you. I don't know what Page could say, and I agree that it's extremely likely that the truth is somewhere in the middle, but damned if any of us have any ability to actually suss out what that is. It's very frustrating.

I just think it's important to not be entirely cynical here, and to keep in mind what such a statement might look like if it were being truthful. I don't know how much different it might be, which generally makes the statement only as good as Larry Page's word, and only then if he doesn't have a gun to his head.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by anon808 on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:44PM (#5841703)
The truth comes from the source that wasn't intended to be public.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by darkarmani on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:38PM (#5842123)
> NSA says it's getting data in some form from Google, Page says no direct access.

Page says no direct access and not even legal access at that scale (verizon). He doesn't say they don't have any access -- in fact he says they comply within the bounds of law, but it's not at the Verizon scale.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by bilbo0s on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:14PM (#5841945)
I don't know how many of us served as officers in the military, but the requisite action in this situation is pretty clear. If one is interested in day to day security, speaking from a strictly tactical perspective:

You assume Google is giving the NSA information and act accordingly.

Doubts are like bothersome flies...

until they are crushed...

you will never be comfortable at your current position.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by sjs382 on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:46PM (#5841719)
We obviously stil have a lot to learn about PRISM... But with that said, I have some conflicting instincts & feelings about all of this and the company responses.

On one hand, I would think a very-visible CEO of a major corp would keep their name off of a press release, if the press release was a lie that they were compelled to tell by the government.

On the other hand, I feel like each company's response and their use of the exact same terminology ("direct access", etc) feels like a wink and a nod.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by cheald on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:48PM (#5841756)
I completely agree, and I don't know how to reconcile the two.

If I was going to go completely conspiracy-nutter, I'd say that Page has been kept out of the loop intentionally for plausible deniability, and the actual incursion happens at a much lower level, where the people involved are coerced into keeping their mouths shut. That way, the bigwigs get to tell what they think is the truth, the NSA gets their data, and nobody is the wiser.

Granted, I think that belongs more in the plot of a thriller novel than in this actual world we're living in, but given the revelations of the past couple of days, fiction doesn't seem that implausible.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by sinnerswing on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:57PM (#5841818)
This may not be PRISM, but wtf is this???

"A US government-mandated backdoor allowed China to hack into Gmail"

"In order to comply with government search warrants on user data, Google created a backdoor access system into Gmail accounts. This feature is what the Chinese hackers exploited to gain access."

http://www.cnn.com/2010/OPINION/01/23/schneier.google.hackin...

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by gohrt on Saturday June 08, 2013 @01:57AM (#5844015)
Schneier is a smart guy, but he provides no evidence, links, or conjecture of what this backdoor may be.

Maybe those hackers just used the regular tech support "back door", as in "SELECT * FROM gmail where email = '[email protected]'

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by ket on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:46PM (#5841720)
> or they are participating voluntarily and are voluntarily lying, ... seems unlikely to me.

Their business is based on user's data. If you do not feel comfortable giving them your data, it might hurt their business. Hence, IMHO, they do have some incentive to deny PRISM, regardless of the facts.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by declan on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:36PM (#5842105)
Or the news organizations summarizing the leaked slides got it wrong.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by declan on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:34PM (#5842083)
This is a false assumption. AT&T did not deny opening its networks to the NSA during the EFF litigation. It simply declined to comment, and offered suggestions (which I wrote about at the time) about how the law allowed it to comply with such a secret court order.

It's the opposite of what Larry Page is doing.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by sullivandanny on Friday June 07, 2013 @08:06PM (#5842941)
No, it's not. What little we've had about super-secret legal requests isn't that companies have to lie about them. It's that they can't acknowledge them at all.

So the answer they give when asked, and they do get asked, is "no comment."

If they were voluntarily part of PRISM, and legally required to keep that quiet, I'd expect them to say "no comment."

Doing the opposite make so little sense. It means they're having to flat-out lie to their users, something very hard to recover from.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by RWeaver on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:42PM (#5843284)
The thing is "no comment" would basically confirm that 'something' is happening that's secret. Everyone would go conspiracy wild and pull everything they have away from Google.

They probably want to confirm it, but in a completely open and transparent way that assures people there's nothing they should fear here, which they can't do because it's all cloaked in secrecy.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by danso on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:13PM (#5841937)
No, it's not. Gag orders can also be satisfied by saying "no comment" or just not saying anything at all, which is differently then actively denying something.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by colin_jack on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:46PM (#5841728)
One thing we know for sure is the truth of what they have been doing will leak out.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by rasterizer on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:27PM (#5841520)
That's not true, in Verizon's case they just said that they are under a gag-order: http://publicpolicy.verizon.com/blog/entry/from-the-desk-of-...
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by ttrreeww on Friday June 07, 2013 @04:36PM (#5841631)
There are cases in which you can't even confirm the existence of a gag order. I can not believe it's constitutional... but they do it.
Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by SilasX on Friday June 07, 2013 @05:01PM (#5841854)
What about the strategy you hear about of getting around this? Where they say "we're not under a gag order" (or whatever) each day until they are, until they go under a gag order, at which point it reveals they are.

Now, I'm not so naive to think that if someone tried this, the government and courts would just say "Herp, derp, you sure outfoxed us there!" But has that strategy ever been tested in court?

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by bigiain on Friday June 07, 2013 @09:06PM (#5843154)
Rsync.net does this:

http://www.rsync.net/resources/notices/canary.txt

And they note:

This scheme is not infallible. Although signing the declaration makes it impossible for a third party to produce arbitrary declarations, it does not prevent them from using force to coerce rsync.net to produce false declarations. The news clip in the signed message serves to demonstrate that that update could not have been created prior to that date. It shows that a series of these updates were not created in advance and posted on this page.

Re:Larry Page addresses PRISM by ttrreeww on Friday June 07, 2013 @06:14PM (#5842366)
I'd imaging it'd get you a free one way ticket to Cuba, not charged.