When it comes to understanding user satisfaction, anecdotes count a lot, particularly when those anecdotes re-enforce the thesis of a product by example.
You raise the question of what is the point of Facebook if you hide 90% of your "friends". Just asking this question shows that you don't really get what the author is saying. Putting quotes around "friends" tells me you are missing the point that the author is, in fact, leaving left un-hid people who meet two attributes: are legitimate close friends/relatives and post interesting and meaningful content. What remains is a one-of-a-kind stream of content that provides him/her with the ability to feel they are in tune with the lives of people who they are no longer nearby.
People who come to HN and rail on Facebook about privacy concerns and ethics have a point. People who come on HN and rail on Facebook The Product are missing the point. If Facebook's news feed is not engaging, it means one of two things: you have over-friended and not hidden people who post bad content, or you are not connected to any people who post content on Facebook that you enjoy. There are many, many people that do not fit in either of these categories.
A) I think that care deeply needs to be defined.
B) My opinion is that FB is too superficial to merit any kind of "deep connection." Here is where some evidence would have been nice.
B.1) Even so, considering that (just about) everything on FB is semi-public, I'm not sure how anything posted on FB would be conducive to a personal and deep relationship with anyone. Unless we're only talking about private messages sent via FB messenger or something (but FB as a whole is a different kind of animal).
I wasn't railing on FB the Product, as you call it. But I think that the new generation is looking for something more substantive. (There have been slews of such articles [providing hard evidence, incidentally] lately.) I think I'd also be looking for something more substantive (even though I'm 27). My point is that it doesn't seem possible to maintain a personal and deep connection with just about anyone through FB (given the semi-private nature of the service); saying otherwise is begging the question: how, exactly, do you maintain this relationship merely though the superficiality of FB?
The result of this, of course, will be skeptics conjuring up their own litmus tests for what constitutes a "deep" relationship in a way that the author's examples fall outside of that definition. Or, they will reframe the author's examples in other media or means and explain how those interactions would somehow be more meaningful than if they were happening on Facebook. This objectification of human relationships will, of course, be incredibly shallow and offensive to many people.
When you are dealing with people's personal lives and how they value relationships, it's pretty hard to come up with some objective measure of value beyond the self-evaluation of the people in the relationships themselves. Since otherwise, you are by definition being judgmental.
I'm not asking for the lurid details of a romantic relationship here, just some anecdotes that prove exactly how Facebook (as opposed to the myriad of other communication software: IM, email, Skype, etc.) helped foster a "deep relationship."
Someone argued that the OP and I have different definitions of deep. This could very well be the case. I consider deep relationships to be ones that I have with my family, best friends, romantic interest, and maybe some extended family or family friends here and there. If Facebook would disappear tomorrow, my relationship with the aforementioned groups of people wouldn't suffer one bit. But I could, as always, be mistaken.
Secondly, I don't think anyone has claimed that they maintain a deep relationship using FB only. Like I mention in a nearby reply, having the constant superficial connection through FB strengthens the actual time spent together.
It's also worth noting that hiding has improved dramatically since it was first introduced. Now, you have more control over what gets hidden. For example, you can remove a "friend" from your feed but still get notified when they have a major update or life event (e.g. get married, move away). That way, you can get rid of the noise that person creates but not throw out the signal at the same time.
And I don't think we should expect every opinion piece on the web to be a PhD thesis based on a ten year double-blind cross-over study. It's just a simple opinion piece that says, "Facebook works for me."
No, it is a conclusion drawn from an implied accumulation of anecdote. An actual anecdote would be something like, "when my brother on the other side of the country had a baby, I found out on Facebook, and was thus more connected to him." Ie. it would demonstrate connectedness to someone far away who is cared about deeply.
I think the original author and the poster you replied to probably have very different definitions of "deeply". Facebook doesn't seem very useful for first tier people who get the phone/snail mail/IM/email treatment or third tier people who you don't care to keep up with much, but it has a sweet spot in that second tier. It's usefulness to individual people is probably proportional to how large their second tier is.
"I think my favorite colour is blue."
"I think I prefer brunettes to blondes."
"I think creamy pasta sauces are better than tomato sauces."
"I think Facebook works just fine, at least for me."
I'll give you evidence for things I'm claiming/quoting as _facts_, but ask me for evidence about my _opinions_, and yeah - you're being obtuse.
Even with my closest friends that I see every week, I don't run down the week's minutiae when we see each other, even though we might see/share it on FB. Tough commute to the office? Find an interesting article worth sharing? Bragging about the cocktail you're about to drink down? None of this stuff comes up every week, but I'm happy to Like or comment on them when I see them, and, yes, it does help keep me connected. And they're in the same city. I don't think any of this should be surprising.
Also, I contend that "semi-creeping" on friends of friends is not what "most" people use Facebook for. That may be what you and your friends use it for, but I think this all goes to the underlying crux of the OP's argument -- Facebook is a personalized experience that is very different for each person, depending on who they are, how they use it, and who their connections are, and he's happy with it.
[1] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/07/28/nearly-90-percent-o...
[2] http://psychcentral.com/news/2010/04/26/how-people-use-faceb...
I guess if your point was that most people use facebook to look at details of other people...well, I guess that's true, but it feels like saying the sky is blue, so I'm assuming you are trying to make a more specific argument?
All I'm saying is that the claim that FB fosters deep relationships is unfounded.
If you're looking for serious evidence for this effect, I find support for this theory from the field of remote work and the invisible water cooler effect (http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/jobcenter/workplace/bru...) as well as some papers I've read about increased connection through lightweight sharing methods (http://research.microsoft.com/apps/pubs/default.aspx?id=6931...).
Absolutely. This is a particularly acute pain point for us nerds, but it afflicts just about everyone to some extent. Our social circles are unfortunately limited in a way that technology could certainly address.
I envision a service that would include everything from dating to finding Dungeons & Dragons groups to just finding people to chat with who are currently nearby and share an interest. Google Glass would make this kind of thing even more interesting.
This technology exists and it's called approaching people you don't know and sparking up a conversation.
Social skills need to be developed just like nun-chuck skills and computer hacking skills.
Essentially I upvoted the article because it's nice to know that HN isn't completely a sound-proof echo chamber =)
I now speak to relatives far away on a weekly basis because of Facebook.
And do I even have to mention that I talk a lot more with my girlfriend due to Facebook?
Face-to-face is better, my relationships suffer when I communicate via phone.
Phone calls are better, my relationships suffer when I communicate via email.
Email is better, my relationships suffer if I communicate via FB.
Maybe the problem is you, not the communication method.
Do I care deeply about those people? Maybe not enough to text or call each and every one of them (cellphone network failure notwithstanding) but enough to see if they had posted, "I'm OK. Thanks for checking."
That's more than I can say about any other social network.
> Facebook keeps me connected to folks I care deeply about who aren’t nearby.
As soon as I saw it, I said to myself: "boy oh boy, he better give some hard evidence." The article goes on even without providing anecdotal evidence, let alone anything to the extent I was expecting or hoping. In fact, the entire discussion seems to be about the hiding feature. Yeah, everyone knows about it (and more and more people are using it), but I'm not sure how using a destructive feature of a service makes the service more necessary (I would argue for the opposite). If I hide 90% of my "friends" from my feed, for example, what's the point of Facebook? Apart from the ego-boosting friend-count (which I might also hide).
Now, going back to the initial (bolded!) argument: Facebook keeps me connected to folks I care deeply about who aren’t nearby. I think that this is just simply not true. Of course, a definition of "care deeply" would be needed, but my assumption here is that we're talking about moms, dads, sisters, brothers, aunts, BFFs, and the like -- NOT ex-girlfriends/boyfriends or classmates from high school that helped us out that one time on that one biology project in freshman year. If I only contacted my mom or dad through Facebook, my parents would first of all be quite mad -- and second of all, our relationship would suffer. People that I care deeply about get emails, phone calls, Skype calls, text messages, sometimes even snail-mail from me! I'm not sure how the OP expects us to connect Facebook to "caring deeply." Again, some evidence (or an actual argument) would've been nice.
I don't hate Facebook, but more often than not, I find myself just using it when I'm bored and semi-creeping around seeing what X or Y is up to and randomly clicking on that "cute girl that's a friend of a friend of a friend" (incidentally, this is what most people use it for). "Creeping on Facebook," has in fact, become a relatively common colloquialism; I wouldn't even attribute a negative quality to the idea, but I would argue it's a fundamental failure of FB (and something that should capitalize on). I posted about this before, but I really believe that the next "big social thing" will be a start-up that will somehow make it easy to approach people you don't know and spark up a conversation. There are so many people on FB, and yet most of us hide 90% of the people we're friends with and we don't add the ones we might find interesting but don't know. That doesn't seem "just fine" to me.
Oh yeah, go ahead and add me on Facebook.