News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by parfe on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:17AM (#5825686)
How disappointing to see anti-Islam polemic as the top comment. The comment then ties a marriage from 1,300 years ago to his justification for possession of child pornography. Real quality content the community is endorsing.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by speeder on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:24AM (#5825752)
It is not anti-Islam polemic...

The person is very dear to me, and I was only pointing how there is a clear dissonance between values, even in the same person...

The Bible is also full of things that most people dislike, and I am fine with them. Most people think I am evil because of THAT.

I got kinda tired of avoiding commenting about Islam, or Jews, because every time someone talk about Islam people think it is a anti-Islam thing (mostly, because many times it is, unfortunately... I still remember when I told a person that rode the commuting bus every day with me how sad I was about Libya civil war, and he replied that muslims were all stupid evil dirty people and deserved to die, I never talked with that guy again, who knows what other shocking shit he might say), and every time someone say something bad about Jews it turns into anti-semitism (even if the object of the criticism is true).

I guess maybe I should have invented some fictional names for the historical figures mentioned, to still give a example of my point of someone that favours throwing the baby with the bathwater but at the same time respects a historical figure that clashes with their own values.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jbooth on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:27AM (#5825766)
If you find yourself having to constantly restrain yourself from making bad comments about (all/most) Muslims and Jews, maybe the problem isn't just that society is too uptight.

This story has nothing to do with any religion whatsoever, messianic or not, yet your first instinct is to go on about Islam and then call people overly-PC for wondering what the hell you're on about.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by speeder on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:40AM (#5825862)
This also applies to many other things, several of my opinions are controversial, I know...

But where I live at least, you cannot talk about blacks, muslims, jews, gays (both for, or against), and on, and on, and on...

Slandering asians is fine though (I dunno why... but everyone is cool with that here).

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jbooth on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:44AM (#5825883)
Well, then I'll just expand on my previous comment to add racial groups to the cultural/religious groups that you should probably re-examine your views on if everybody finds them offensive.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by drzaiusapelord on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:09AM (#5826096)
Not too long ago, everyone thought inter-racial marriage was offensive. I think basing your morality on "what everyone thinks right now" is foolish at best.
[deleted]
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jiggy2011 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:43AM (#5826310)
That same argument cuts both ways, imagine you live in a place where racist and anti-gay sentiment is the norm.

In such a place you might be concerned about making a comment that could be construed as support for gay marriage or racial equality as you might be ridiculed or shunned in some way by your community.

In such a situation would it be fair to say that the person in question should necessarily adjust their views to conform?

[deleted]
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jiggy2011 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:01PM (#5826450)
Disagree, lots of people hold opinions on things that they haven't really thought much about so those views are likely to be similar simply because by virtue of them consuming similar news sources and echo chambering their views amongst each other.

There aren't really distinct groups of "racist" or "liberal on race" , this is an over simplification. There are in fact many separate and overlapping issues which relate to race and it is possible to have differing opinions on any or all of them.

It is certainly worth re-evaluating your position if you have new information or a good argument to consider, but not simply because category X of people mostly disagree with you.

[deleted]
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jiggy2011 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:23PM (#5826597)
I'm responding mainly to this "Well, then I'll just expand on my previous comment to add racial groups to the cultural/religious groups that you should probably re-examine your views on if everybody finds them offensive."

The guy upthread related an anecdote as an example of where people might engage in doublethink, the example included a guy who was a muslim because that is who he happened to have the conversation with.

He then stated that he is hesitant to use muslims as an example because that tends to bring with it all kinds of personal biases. Then you made the comment quoted above, which is what I am mainly referring too.

You talk about "the liberal coast of america" as if it is some defining oracle of truth and if you disagree with it, then you are wrong.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by CatMtKing on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:36PM (#5826688)
My thoughts exactly, though it doesn't seem like the fellow you're arguing with is grepping it.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by saraid216 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:40PM (#5827239)
Hi. I'm Asian.

Fuck you.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by gizmo686 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:19PM (#5830189)
Sorry but, historically speaking, Asians are by far the most hated people in the US.

Our first laws restricting who can immigrate were designed to prohibit Asians.

In Plessy v. Ferguson (the Supreme court case which upheld racial segragation on trains), the dissent for that case made the arguement: "There is a race so different from our own that we do not permit those belonging to it to become citizens of the United States. Persons belonging to it are, with few exceptions, absolutely excluded from our country. I allude to the Chinese race. But, by the statute in question, a Chinaman can ride in the same passenger coach with white citizens of the United States, while citizens of the black race in Louisiana, many of whom, perhaps, risked their lives for the preservation of the Union, who are entitled, by law, to participate in the political control of the State and nation, who are not excluded, by law or by reason of their race, from public stations of any kind, and who have all the legal rights that belong to white citizens, are yet declared to be criminals, liable to imprisonment, if they ride in a public coach occupied by citizens of the white race."[1]

During WWII, the only people we locked up in concentration camps were the Japanese, despite the fact that many other countries were clearly hostile to us, and the fact that many of the Japanese clearly had no loyalties to Japan (they often didn't even speak Japanese).

So sorry, but Asians do have a special place in this country for being discriminated against.

[1] http://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/163/537/case.html

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:31PM (#5829095)
Jesus this thread is vitriolic. I didn't see him slander an Asian person, nor say that he supported it.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by darkarmani on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:21AM (#5826185)
> This story has nothing to do with any religion whatsoever, messianic or not, yet your first instinct is to go on about Islam

A few sentences out of many is not "going on about Islam." Why is mentioning Islam offensive?

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jlgreco on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:02PM (#5826462)
Many people think that religion is a topic that deserves or requires exceptional treatment.

I don't pretend to understand why.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by ealloc on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @02:58PM (#5827785)
This type of racism carried out by people who are too lazy to realize they are hurting other people by their social blindness. It has to do with being oblivious to social context, due to one's priviledge.

The subject of Mohammed's child bride is frequently used to justify hate against muslims, and has a social context of islamophobia. If there weren't that social context it would be fine to bring it up randomly, but since there is, bringing it up is offensive. It's part of the discriminatory pattern muslims experience.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by darkarmani on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @08:06PM (#5829534)
> The subject of Mohammed's child bride is frequently used to justify hate against muslims, and has a social context of islamophobia. If there weren't that social context it would be fine to bring it up randomly, but since there is, bringing it up is offensive. It's part of the discriminatory pattern muslims experience.

Is there any criticism of Islam that can be made that wouldn't be offensive? Or is it offensive to even hypothesize that someone might criticize Islam?

Let alone the fact that he wasn't even criticizing Islam, but using it to talk about a friend that was inconsistent in his beliefs. He never once said that Mohammed having sex with a minor was wrong. In fact he said exactly the opposite a few different times:

> never understood why all the paranoia with pedo...

> my grandmother married when she was 14...I have a hard time believing that a 14 year old girl is so dumb to the point of needing heavy-handed state protection in deciding her relationships.

So, how exactly is he criticizing Islam when he agrees with the example of Islam he used?

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by ealloc on Friday June 07, 2013 @02:27PM (#5840703)
I never said you couldn't criticise islam. In fact, I think Islam is terrible and deserves criticism and mockery.

However, it is also true that many Muslim people are unjustly persecuted, and randomly bringing up that "their prophet had a 9 year old wife" fits into the pattern of discrimination. People who bring that up are either bigots who enjoy namecalling at Muslims, or people who are unaware of that social context of their words, which is a form of racism/privilege itself.

So, feel free criticise Islam (including for the 9 year old bride), but don't randomly bring it up if it's only vaguely related to the topic of discussion.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jbooth on Thursday June 06, 2013 @12:48PM (#5833533)
The guy could have said "all religions' holy books take place in a time when child marriage was common and even endorsed".

But he didn't say that. He went on about muslims specifically. Makes me, and hey I'm just an observer, but it makes me think his point was more about muslims than it was about child pornography.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by darkarmani on Friday June 07, 2013 @12:52AM (#5837304)
> The guy could have said "all religions' holy books take place in a time when child marriage was common and even endorsed".

Did you even read the OP? He was relating a conversation he had with a Muslim friend that had conflicted views. Why would he try to convince his Muslim friend using "all religions" instead of islam?

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by guard-of-terra on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:43AM (#5825881)
If I find myself having to constantly restrain myself from making bad comments about something, it may be also because that something is of inferior quality.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jbooth on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:55AM (#5825962)
Inferior to what, exactly? Christianity?

If the beef is with religion in general, it begs the question of why focus on muslims?

I have friends who are practicing muslims, jews, christians, hindi and buddhist. They're good people.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by guard-of-terra on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:15AM (#5826146)
Sorry for bringing Hitler card so early on the table, but there were quite a few people in SS/CheKa who you would consider "good".

People doing X and being good do not count toward X not being bad.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jbooth on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:29AM (#5826241)
I'd just like to note for the record that none of my friends are operating death camps or starting a world war.

Yesterday, at least one American did at least one bad thing, somewhere. Are you culpable for that? Are you inferior?

So far in this conversation, the post I responded to identified muslims, jews, blacks and gays as morally inferior. I objected, and you're tripling down on the assertion. Am I misunderstanding you?

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by guard-of-terra on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:37AM (#5826282)
But they would if they were allowed to. They want to criminalize abortion? That's women lives on the line. "Pro life" is actually "pro death of poor under-age mothers from bleeding from illegal abortion", always call them that.

They want to make porn illegal? They just made everyone a felon, and they can pull anyone over and land him in a camp. Even fascist didn't have such a good tool. CheKa grade.

They want to tinker with age of consent? They'll make a 16 year old girl and her 17 year old boyfriend both felons. Is that nice?

They agree to predatory, murderous, bloody ideas all the time and they are still "good people". As a group they do that. That's so nice of them.

I try to find one thing religious people are getting right over agnostics/atheists and I seriously can't think of one.

UPD: I'm not saying people are inferior, just that their beliefs are and they would be better off without those.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jbooth on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:43AM (#5826313)
I agree with your policy recommendations.

Your problem isn't with muslims, it's with social conservatives and specifically social conservatives who want to legislate their morality on the rest of us (a population that, in the US at least, is 99% non-muslim and in fact most of them hate muslims). I'd suggest that focusing on muslims distracts from the issue, unless your actual problem is really with muslims specifically and you're being disingenuous with your policy concerns.

And no, my friends would not be operating death camps if they were allowed to. They're nice people, good work ethic, live and let live types.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by guard-of-terra on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:52AM (#5826384)
Mad social conservatives (or I would call them social sociopats) are using religion as a medium of legislating their morality on the rest of us, AND people who are religious do not visibly protest against that, AND social sociopats use the sheer numbers of people who "believe in something" as if they were all agreeing with sociopats on the basis of believing.

If only people stopped being "a bit religious" social sociopats will lose a lot of turf and become a lot less scary. And currently they are very scary.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by jiggy2011 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:42AM (#5825868)
I think in this case Islam is simply used as an example.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by rmc on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:49AM (#5826360)
A religious person acting like a hypocrite about their religion. This is common in all religions, and doesn't really add anything.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by lawnchair_larry on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:45AM (#5826329)
What's wrong with anti-islam comments? We don't tolerate things like power balance bracelets or homeopathic medicine. I don't see why it's somehow "bad" to be intolerant of religious fairy tales as well.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by flog on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:52AM (#5826383)
I think "tolerate" is the interesting word. Tolerance != respect.

Surely, it's better to "respect" religion, and how can I do that if I cannot challenge it? And then, should a non-defendable religion be tolerated?

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by PavlovsCat on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @04:44PM (#5828478)
To respect Islam is to disrespect all those it gleefully claims roast in hell, and thought itself.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:32PM (#5829103)
""To respect [insert basically any {generally monotheistic} religion you want] is to disrespect all those it gleefully claims roast in hell, and thought itself.""

Fixed that one for you, if we're just going all in on senseless religion hate at this point.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by PavlovsCat on Thursday June 06, 2013 @04:14AM (#5831141)
If I say apples are fruit, you don't "fix" that by mentioning that other things are fruit, too, as if I had claimed otherwise. You're just being a needy doofus.

Also, pffff. Senseless religion hate? I came to my conclusions as a believer, and I read the Quran with anticipation and hope, actually. Those were sorely disappointed, to put it mildly. My stance now is "if that's from God, God sucks and we're all fucked. If it's not, I can't wait until it goes the way of the dinosaurs." That's not hate, that's just paying attention. Not being American I don't particularly care about Christian fundamentalists. In Europe, there is ONE active religion and ONE that matters, and that's Islam.

Make yourself familiar with intellectual honesty and OT, NT and Quran, and then tell me they're not documents of fascism. Whatever any person does, if God says it's evil, it's evil; whatever thing God does, no matter how much more selfish and brutal in nature, is good.

It's very fucking easy to be "tolerant" about things you hardly know, or don't take seriously at all. I don't senselessly hate, I have reasons for my dislike. Are you, however, senselessly sucking up?

I love thought and logic; those religions hate them. Put differently, I didn't start this; I'm just not rolling over. If you don't want beef with me, don't put a pistol to my head, and don't call me wrecking that pistol an attack. For me that's real basic, but if you only deal in feel-good slogans, it's obviously going to confuse you. Well, good riddance.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by drivebyacct2 on Thursday June 06, 2013 @02:15PM (#5834154)
I'm sorry but I just laughed at your entire post. I'm an ardent atheist so that little diatribe was cute.

There are plenty of reasons to not like religion, you didn't really bother having that discussion and instead resorted to a cheapshot driveby comment. That was what I was mocking.

And yeah, there's plenty of "fascist" behavior in American Christians too. To sit there and tell me I don't know what I'm talking about... in the same breath that you say you don't know or care about US Christians is a special kind of braggard ignorance.

Good riddance? I guess? I don't even know what your point against me was at this point.

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by darkarmani on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @11:23AM (#5826199)
> How disappointing to see anti-Islam polemic as the top comment.

How disappointing to see unsubstantiated claims. What is the part that is an anti-Islam polemic?

Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by tome on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:24AM (#5825749)
What's anti-Islam about that comment?
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by scottymac on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @10:32AM (#5825806)
Absolutely--I agree we shouldn't adhere to customs, values, and laws created and held by men 1300 years ago.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by CatMtKing on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @12:33PM (#5826674)
Either you've completely misread his comment or I have. He was pointing out that modern standards have changed quite significantly and quickly, and that the modern standard is ill defined.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by DanBC on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:41PM (#5829146)
Not just as top comment of this thread, but one of the top voted comments in recent HN.
Re:Exhibit A – the “child pornographer” by drivebyacct2 on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @06:29PM (#5829091)
I'm not even going to address your shit attitude and comments and just focus on the libel you're committing. If you're going to throw a fit because you're incapable of having a discussion elevated beyond "Kill everyone who ever looks at a child", at least try not to make false accusations of CP possession against others.

What a stupid, rude thing to do.