News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by DanielBMarkham on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:09AM (#5813343)
Facebook is performance art. It's a phonebook of people I lost contact with many years ago. It's also a quasi-broken emailing list program. It might be a decent advertising platform for small businesses. Don't know.

It's not a news feed. It's not stories relevant to me. It's not a way to actually have friends. It's not a place where people create things and share (mostly). People might think it's those things. Hell, Facebook itself will tell you that it's those things, but it's not.

I agree with the article. Facebook's biggest problem is that, because you're always talking to everybody, you really can't say much. Conversation is, and has always been, context-dependent. You don't say things at a funeral home that you would at a keg party. You don't share the same stories with your peers that you would with your grandma.

I've always thought Facebook was from the devil. Anybody that would use my own friends against me to suck me into a network of participating whether I wanted to or not? Not somebody with my best interests in mind.

I only use Facebook with the FB Purify plugin that gets rid of a lot of the spam. Even then, if I could abstract myself completely away from it, and do all of my social networking activity on my O/S without a browser or a layer of commercial crap stuck on top, I would in a heartbeat.

ADD: It might also be a decent shared photo album. Jury is still out on that one.

What really bothers me is not that these services like FB, Twitter, G+, or various cloud storage systems are not useful -- they are. It's that, instead of being internet standards, they're branded properties. And they're all doing the same thing. It's like if email was a completely different thing depending on which ISP you used. These things should be completely abstracted away from any corporate logo. If I want to store things in the cloud, for instance, I could care less who actually keeps the bytes. If I want to reach my high school chums, why the heck do I need some other party to help me do that? I control gigabytes of storage and god knows how many computational cycles on my personal possessions, and I need Google+ to tell me whose birthday it is today? Really?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by austenallred on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:26AM (#5813443)
Google+ really was on to something with its circles: My friends are easily divisible into groups, and, apart from life events like getting engaged, what I want to share is only really relevant to a specific subset. I know Facebook has groups you can share specific things with, but it's not a feature Facebook has focused on, so even I don't really use it. I could use google +, but no one else does, and there's not much of a point to shouting into an empty room.

I have found, however, that my Facebook experience has greatly improved once I started hiding posts from people i don't care about as much from my news feed. There are people I still want to be able to check up on now and then, but I don't want to see 99% of the things they have to say. It's like unsubscribibg to junk mail; it makes everything feel wanted and relevant.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by roc on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:04PM (#5814386)
> "Google+ really was on to something with its circles:... I could use google +, but no one else does"

I wonder how much of Google+'s 'use' problem relates to this feature working extremely well.

You section off people you like to keep in contact with, just not on a daily basis. You then don't send most of your day-to-day posts their way. They look at Google+ and see a wasteland.

And whenever they mention Google+, you can't just say "I love it and use it daily; I just put you in the 'Siberia' circle". The only answer is "I don't use it much." Which re-affirms their view of the service as being basically empty.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by tracker1 on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:21PM (#5816456)
I find that for tech follows, it works better than twitter and fb... but there's much less signal overall, which is nice... for random musings, I'll glance at a twitter feed now and then... it's more of a highest noise platform to me. FB is mainly to keep up with friends/family, some of whom I'd otherwise never talk/communicate with.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by kinleyd on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:12PM (#5817497)
Exactly my experience with tech follows which I enjoy most of all. I've found it entertaining, informative and inspiring. I've never used twitter and stopped using Facebook. Also, so far no issues with spam on G+.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by untog on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:24PM (#5814522)
Agreed that Circles are a great idea- and they're just as great on Facebook. I am lucky that I have a relatively small number of friends- categorising them did not take long at all. Now I can post updates to different groups, and it works great.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by mhaymo on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @06:39AM (#5818610)
Even those who can't be bothered to categorise their contacts can use the automatically-generated ones, based on family, location and college/workplace. It's very freeing to be able to ask only close friends in my city if they want to see a movie, or link only those that I have put in the "Techie" group to a great article I found on Hacker News.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by nahname on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:00PM (#5815547)
The problem with Google+ is that they are so terrified of the user seeing no content, it comes pre-loaded with... well crap. Friends list is empty? Let's import everyone you know, but create 5 separate contacts each. Then spam those people to join because they are not actually on G+. Send them a message? They are not actually there. You cannot hide that your social network is a ghost town by putting fake people in it.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by moron4hire on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:39PM (#5814217)
>> but no one else does

You and I apparently have drastically different pictures of G+.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by wambotron on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:26PM (#5814531)
Seriously. I use G+ all the time, although not in the same way people use FB.

I talk to my good friends offline and use G+ for the communities. It's almost like reddit with 90% less trolling.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by frostmatthew on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:39PM (#5816548)
"90% less trolling" - where's the fun in that!
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by Goladus on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:39PM (#5814598)
I have found, however, that my Facebook experience has greatly improved once I started hiding posts from people i don't care about as much from my news feed.

Oddly, I've found the opposite to be true. Apart from clearing out app-request spam, streamlining my facebook feed to only the "friends I care about" tends to result in the most predictable updates. It seems to me the outer-circle friends have the most potential to be interesting.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by cantos on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:28PM (#5814893)
I agree. I email my friends, or see them in person so I know what's going on in their lives. Too often people only want to analyze facebook as an organizational tool. But there is a great entertainment component built in as well.

You get to learn the kind of personal information about your past acquaintances that otherwise you could only get by going to a reunion. You can find out if anyone you thought would be successful has ended up struggling, if anyone you thought was a slacker has done something interesting, if that person who is attractive, and successful is somehow also a nice person, etc.

Spending a few minutes looking at this kind of trivia can be a lot more fun than yet another youtube cat and the game only gets more interesting the more friends you have on facebook.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by ryguytilidie on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:09PM (#5815191)
I've been thinking about this a lot lately. I almost want to just do a reset of the feeds I'm blocking. I did such specific blocking that now I really only see posts from the same group of people and most of those peoples most interesting/original thoughts are very certainly not going on Facebook. I've essentially created a large social network only to cut off most of it.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by brianpan on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:37PM (#5814584)
I thought so as well, but I'm not really that interested in "organizing" my friend list. Ideally, yes, I would. But there's too many corner cases and overlapping circles that it's never exactly what I want and it quickly gets out of date.

For me, Facebook did work the way I wanted long ago- people tagged you in photos and it was fun to look at photos of you and your friends. The problem is that in order for Facebook to grow, your feed needs to get broader and broader (status updates, youtube videos) and it gets filled up with things that are not as relevant.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by qu4z-2 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:36AM (#5818023)
Well, I just set up a few circles when I joined (maybe 7ish), and now whenever I add someone, I quickly tick one or two of the boxes. It's not really high-maintenance.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by nevster on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:25PM (#5817537)
Totally agree.

80% of the crap is from 20% of the people.

Just hide them from your timeline. In your browser, hover over the person's photo, then hover over the Friends button and deselect "Show in News Feed".

Problem (mostly) solved.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by scholia on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:13PM (#5814068)
> there's not much of a point to shouting into an empty room

Spot on....

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by russell on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:42PM (#5815427)
Primal Scream Therapy: it's quite prevalent in the Internet.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by saraid216 on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:34PM (#5814192)
> I could use google +, but no one else does, and there's not much of a point to shouting into an empty room.

There hasn't been a generation growing up with Google+ yet.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by ryanbrunner on Monday June 03, 2013 @10:34PM (#5817347)
There really wasn't with Facebook when it got a bit more public, and yet there was orders of magnitude more excitement and buzz when it expanded to certain cities. Google+ may have more users, but Facebook was one of those things that you had conversations about nearly daily, with people not even vaguely involved in the tech scene.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by xtracto on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:32AM (#5813836)
Facebook works very well for me:

During my lifetime I've lived on 6 cities in 3 different countries. I've got friends (some of them, became very good friends) and people I know from all these places.

Facebook allows me to stay in contact with them, and if I want, to peek at where are they know (and what are they doing). For me, it works as an "information push" platform, where sometimes I'll see an update from an old time friend who I forgot about, and I would use that moment to say hello and congratulate him or give kudos for whatever he is doing (or just say 'haha' at whatever funny picture he shared).

Before that, I had to remember to send an email to every person I knew... and ask them specifically what where they doing.

Sure, some people might find no sense in maintaining those kind of relations (staying in touch with people who you do not actively talk to). But I think we never know when we might be able to get together again, and having this point of contact is good.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by ctdonath on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:17PM (#5815659)
Put another way: Facebook is for friends outside arm's reach, people you don't want to forget but who are not part of your current "inner circle". Real current friends are not maintained via Facebook precisely because you do connect with them in other ways. It's for those you don't want to lose, but don't want to put much effort into either.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by ripperdoc on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:18PM (#5817144)
I have a similar situation with multiple countries and friends and family back home. Facebook is a good tool for that. Sure, the toolset itself is only ok (crashy app, opaque list-management, messy UI). But more than half of the value of Facebook is NOT the tools it provide, but the fact that almost everyone is ON it. A stellar social tool startup would be of no use to me considering it would take years before the people I need to talk to are memers, if ever.

With that said, Facebook is slowly reducing the Signal-to-Noise ratio, and it's an ominous sign for the platform as a whole.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by Gormo on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:19PM (#5814486)
> I agree with the article. Facebook's biggest problem is that, because you're always talking to everybody, you really can't say much. Conversation is, and has always been, context-dependent.

Nothing has yet approached traditional web forums, IRC, and even old-school Usenet in this capacity. These forms of online community are clearly-defined social spaces, in which everyone has a direct view to who is and isn't participating. There may be many separate contexts going at any given time, with lots of overlap among participants, but each one is still an independent venue with legible boundaries. Modern "social media" lacks this sense of defined space, which, I think, is necessary for anything to be legitimately called a "community".

Forums and IRC are like a few dozen friends sitting around a table, with everyone engaged in a single coherent conversation at any given time. Twitter and Facebook are like two hundred acquaintances having 40,000 conversations by shouting at each other across the floor of a gymnasium.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by ryguytilidie on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:12PM (#5815213)
Yeah it just turns into "oh my golf friends would love this, but everyone else would think its uninteresting" or "oh, my friends who are passionate about politics might be able to start an interesting discussion here, but having older relatives also comment will turn this into a clusterfuck" or "My poker buddies would love this, but I don't want most of my friends knowing I gamble." Groups seems like the main answer, and I suppose this is the main reason that I mostly use Groups when I'm actually using fb at this point.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by unclebucknasty on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:01PM (#5817448)
Good points. And, after a while it seems like there's not much ROI on using a piece of software like FB to try to "manage" with whom you communicate and how.

In fact, it seems an artificially wedged in middleman at some point. And it becomes more efficient to get it out of the way and go back to simple email, phone calls or, as you say, IRC and forums.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by daigoba66 on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:22AM (#5813781)
In the beginning (circa 2003-2005 when I was in college) it was a tool for only your peers. Granted at the time it was little more than a directory and event management tool. But it served a useful purpose back then. In my opinion the jumping-the-shark moment was either when it was opened to the world or when "Apps" were introduced.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by pseut on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:23PM (#5814121)
IMO it started to degrade pretty quickly once the 2003-2005 cohort started to have babies. That pushed extended family, etc. to join to see baby pictures, etc. But I agree somewhat about the apps too, especially the way the games were introduced (when I think about how much I know about some of my friends' mafia wars habits vs. how much I care...)

This all happened at about the same time, though, and it all fits under the umbrella of the (sensible, from FB's standpoint) strategy of "grow as large as possible."

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by smspence on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:59PM (#5814342)
That doesn't sound accurate to me...

You're not always talking to everybody. On Facebook you can create friend lists, and then post things that are only visible to the people in the chosen list, in the same way that you can share things with only certain "Circles" on Google+. For example, I have different lists for "Close Friends", "Family", "Work Friends", "Random Acquaintances", etc. If I choose, I can share a post with only my "close friends" list, and none of my family or work friends will see it.

This problem has been solved already. On Google+ the concept is called "Circles". On Facebook, they call them "Friends Lists". Why does everyone on HN praise Google+ Circles, but ignore or hate the Facebook Friends Lists feature?

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by neilk on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:53PM (#5814687)
I am a fairly savvy computer user, and I use Facebook lists. I always have trouble figuring out who is in what list and which list I'm talking to, and how to add and remove people from that list.

Facebook has proved over and over that their priorities are about public sharing, and even to make more things public that previously were private. In part this might be Zuckerberg's vision that sharing almost everything is the future. But as a business they are also incentivized to make sharing effortless, to encourage people to put data on Facebook without thought.

Any thought to privacy is always a little bit of friction. So it's always de-emphasized, if not actually buried.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by dirkgently on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:56AM (#5817945)
Can you limit your feed to default to only certain lists?

Can you remove all the promoted content (aka crap)?

Is it easy to see who you are really sharing with even after creating list?

Can you prevent one list from knowing what you liked or commented on other lists?

You most likely haven't used G+ to really know the difference. FB lists are anything but G+ Circles.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by robomartin on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:59PM (#5814344)
The only way a services can be non-intrusive is if you, the user, pay for it. If you paid for the full cost of developing and supporting a solution that did not require such things as advertising and social graph mining in order to build, grow and support a company you'd get a much better product. You'd probably get a product that is far more sensitive to the needs and wants of it's paying client user-base.

That's one of the problems with this culture of everything being free on the 'net. Free isn't really free. Businesses don't run on air. They run on money. The user always pays. If it isn't in real currency it will be in ways the company can convert into currency. That's just the way it is.

Aspects of your post bother me to some extent because you are complaining about services you are not paying for. I think that is a very important distinction. Don't get me wrong, I have lots of problems with some of the services you mention in your post. I simply choose not to use them.

I also happen to think that people who use ad blockers are just short of thieves. It's hypocritical to navigate to a site and make use of its free services and, at the same time, go out of your way to deny them revenue. It's like someone figuring out a way to make you work and legally not pay you for it.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by boomlinde on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:20PM (#5815680)
Not to leave a perfectly valid point to argue to a joke, here's my stance on ad blocking: You don't get to decide what content recipients will fetch. Content is commonly split into multiple separate requests for data which some users and clients won't even have the means to turn into useful information. The interactivity and selectivity in receiving said content is inherent to the protocol, and by all means what makes it different from other mass media. You can't deny users the ability to "receive" whatever part of the content you want unless you are willing to deliver it in another, more intrusive way. What you are really saying is that people are "just short of thieves" for not requesting content that an HTML document merely presents to them as an available resource.

What's your stance on turning down the volume and preparing a sandwich during a TV commercial break? Would you be just short of a thief, or would you simply be doing what's reasonable when having the ability to opt out of information you are not interested in? Don't try and turn a flawed business model built on an infrastructure not meant to support it into a question of ethics.

Also, as some pointed out, to the user, free can really be free. Ever maintained a personal website? How did (or would) your visitors pay for it? Everyone with an internet connection has the option to deliver free services and content at no additional cost.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by unclebucknasty on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:17PM (#5817519)
>You are complaining about products that you are not paying for

Facebook's revenue model is built upon your participation (labor) and your information. Sure you're paying for it.

>It's hypocritical to navigate to a site and make use of its free services and, at the same time, go out of your way to deny them revenue.

But it's OK for FB to welcome you to their site, encourage you to supply information using your own "labor", then sell that information to third parties (even if in aggregate form)? And, it is OK for them to constantly look for ways to further track and glean data about you for its own profit? How is people using ad blockers any different from Facebook burying their monetization schemes in fine print?

Perhaps FB should simply ban ad blockers or make users prove they've viewed x ads per page view. Ah, but that would open too much dialogue about how much FB utilizes information that it harvests from users and how it monetizes it. Wouldn't want those items foremost on members' minds.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by hnha on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:04PM (#5814380)
i use free xmpp servers to talk with people who I "met" on free websites. Many people provide services for free because they believe in a shared good. It's not all money money.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by robomartin on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:49PM (#5815916)
OK, sure. You go and try to run a real web-based business with employees, offices and the required infrastructure without "money money".

The point stands: If you as a user don't explicitly pay for it with cash, using an ad blocker means you have chosen to deny the service some revenue.

OK, don't call it theft. That's fine.

Here's a simple mental exercise: Assume that 100% of the entire world-wide Internet audience used ad blockers. How much of the internet would cease to exist as free services? The answer: A huge chunk.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by bittercynic on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @01:26AM (#5817881)
That might not be so good for Silicon Valley, but I believe mankind would be richer overall if a huge chunk of the internet ceased to exist.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by qu4z-2 on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @02:41AM (#5818031)
I agree. That does actually sound like quite an appealing internet, to be honest.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by robomartin on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @11:56AM (#5820199)
Sadly enough, it is hard to argue with that.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by moheeb on Monday June 03, 2013 @01:16PM (#5814466)
So what would folks using an ad blocker be then, if they're "just short of thieves"?

I was hoping you had a website in your profile so I could surf all over it.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by robomartin on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:55PM (#5815963)
Thankfully I don't do anything on the web that relies on advertising for revenue.

Here's a website you can surf: mcmaster.com

Have fun.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by boomlinde on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:41PM (#5815420)
The real thieves are the people not visiting your website.
Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by gasull on Friday June 07, 2013 @10:56AM (#5839246)
Nutshellmail lets you use Facebook and Twitter receiving a daily update by email (or more or less frequently if you prefer). You don't need to log into Facebook or Twitter at all.

Also, for a distributed social network, we have Bitmessage:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t_dTotavJZ8

https://bitmessage.org/

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by gavinpc on Wednesday June 05, 2013 @01:52AM (#5823948)
> I've always thought Facebook was from the devil.

But you can't stop using it. Why?

I quit Facebook about two years ago, when I stopped liking it. Too many political arguments and misunderstandings. Guess what? Life goes on.

Re:The Facebook experiment has failed by thinkloop on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @12:32AM (#5817733)
> You don't share the same stories with your peers that you would with your grandma.

Turns out there's quite a lot that we do.