News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by enraged_camel on Sunday June 02, 2013 @02:16PM (#5809506)
Wow.

I am speechless.

As someone who was born and raised in Turkey, and visited Singapore for long periods of time, let me say very clearly: you have absolutely no idea what you're talking about.

Turkey and Singapore are two completely different worlds, with different histories, cultures, and geopolitical situations, and are not related in any shape or form. There may be a few surface-level parallels, but that's where the similarities end.

I am stunned however that a person who very likely has never even visited either place (much less lived in them) has the gall to call what Turkey is going through "Singaporification." I mean, it's not like I haven't noticed the anti-Singaporean sentiments on HN lately - they don't surprise me, since a lot of HN folks are white middle/upper-middle class and lean libertarian[1], which is the exact opposite of Singapore. But using the events in Istanbul as an opportunity to bash Singapore is just... petty and shameless.

I would love to give you a detailed breakdown of the differences between Singapore and Turkey, but that would be an essay. I'll highlight a few important ones.

Singapore is one of the least corrupt countries in the world. Turkey on the other hand is rampant with corruption, especially the current government. That's part of the reason why the protests started: the contractor that was going to build the mall on top of Gezi Park has ties to the Prime Minister, who was going to profit from it. That's just ONE example.

Singapore is extremely diverse culturally. There are several religions and languages. As a result, there are often no culturally accepted behaviors. In a sense, Singapore does not really fit the traditional definition of a nation, and instead has been called a society in transition. In contrast, Turkey has a very strong cultural identity rooted deeply in the country's history and predominant religion, Islam.

The two country's governments are also extremely different. Singapore is a de-facto one-party state; the dominant party, the PAP, has won every single general election since the first one. In contrast, Turkey is a multi-party system, which creates very complex dynamics in the political landscape.

I can go on, but you get the idea. Hopefully.

[1]Table 10 in http://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa580.pdf

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by yzhengyu on Sunday June 02, 2013 @11:42PM (#5811233)
As a Singaporean who just spent the last hour or so rapidly scanning through Turkey's history, it seems the situation in both countries is the entrenchment of political power within a single party.

As for corruption in Singapore, well, let me just say that one of the caveats of these corruption indices is that whether you perceive it. If you are a foreigner visiting Singapore or even a local living here for a while, your daily life in general will probably be pleasant as long as you are not involved in any form of political activism.

Most of the shenanigans in Singapore are related to politics and how the incumbent party has maintained its power. There is a reason for Singapore being placed in the nether regions (144th rank in the Press Freedom Index) in various press freedom rankings and why we are labeled as a "hybrid regime".

As for people who keep gushing about Singapore and how awesome our country is, all I have for them is a wintry smile and the old phrase, "Not all that glitters is gold".

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by JDShu on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:07PM (#5809679)
For the purposes of this discussion, I don't think it's correct to be comparing the current Singapore with the current Turkey, since the premise is that Turkey is on the way to becoming like Singapore. So from this perspective if you examine the points you gave:

- Singapore is the least corrupt country in the world because of extremely tough laws that were enacted in the past.

- I'll give you that Singapore is much more diverse, but note that China also wants to adopt a Singapore model and has an incredibly strong cultural identity.

- A quick lookup shows that Erdoğan has been in office for the longest time since the 60s (three terms). To me, fears of Turkey becoming a de facto one-party state seems justified, at least absent any other information.

I'm not sure if listing the differences and similarities of the two countries is even relevant to this particular discussion. The thesis was that Turkey might be trying to adopt a Singapore model of using economic growth and social order to offset the demand for political freedom. It doesn't actually matter how different the countries are if the government objectives are similar.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by berkay on Sunday June 02, 2013 @05:06PM (#5810101)
"A quick lookup shows that Erdoğan has been in office for the longest time since the 60s (three terms). To me, fears of Turkey becoming a de facto one-party state seems justified, at least absent any other information." You're on to something. One of the underlying reasons of the protests is not only Erdoğan has been in the office for a long time, but also secular sections of the society has lost hope of change of government within the political system (Opposition is in shambles, AKP will likely win the elections again, etc.) There is no political alternative within the system, hence the growing discontent manifests itself in other ways.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by waps on Monday June 03, 2013 @07:03AM (#5812508)
If you think the worst is a one-party state, you've not been following the news. The worst is that Erdogan completes his mission : turning turkey in a middle-eastern islamic dictatorship where women are beaten for walking on the street and every tiniest bit of culture dies, violently and with beheadings.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by afsina on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:55AM (#5812909)
You are joking right? Tell me one thing you could do 5,10,20 years ago and cannot do now that supports your future predictions. I am excluding drinking booze in public places.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by atakan_gurkan on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:33AM (#5813129)
The press could report on these events 10 years ago. Now they don't. The workers could celebrate May day in Taksim square just a few years ago, this year they were banned. People could express themselves more freely if they were not religious or if they were against the government. Now they fear retaliation, losing their job etc. This actually happened to journalists, they did lose their jobs. Hundreds are imprisoned without being convicted or even having a trial for months and years.

There are other indications that Turkey is turning into an Islamic (Sunni in particular) state and our culture is being destroyed. Scientists and artists are ridiculed routinely by the politicians in power. They destroyed Turkish Academy of Sciences. They shut down Feza Gürsey institute. They fired majority of people who made Pardus GNU/Linux distribution and Göktürk satellite from TÜBİTAK.

Unfortunately, this is no joke.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by afsina on Monday June 03, 2013 @09:59AM (#5813287)
This was a personal question actually.

I am no supporter of current Government, but most things you say can be counter-answered.

- Some press reports things less than you like. Some reports with exaggeration. Blame the first group if you want for their cowardice. If second group is alive and kicking, your point is proven to be false.

- Taksim Square was actually totally closed to 1st of May events from 1978 to 2010 . It was this government allowed opening it again. This year there is construction so it was not allowed. I remember the horror in Kadikoy in 1996 tough.

"People could express themselves more freely if they were not religious or if they were against the government. Now they fear retaliation, losing their job etc." This is just your opinion. I cannot really prove the opposite either. Nepotism is there tough, and cannot be avoided regardless of any government.

Journalism issue is problematic and a shame. Most are really PKK related and probably this will change. I cannot say this is something new tough.

"Scientists and artists are ridiculed routinely by the politicians in power" they push each others wrong buttons, and politicians are less tolerable indeed. But apart from 1-2 incidents this cannot be generalized. It is a shame that PM does not have a sense of humor.

To me, Turkish Academy of Sciences issue is overrated. "Most" guys there weren't doing anything useful in terms of science there anyway. They continue their work in universities or in Tubitak without a loss. Handling of Science and Technology by this government can be criticized but for better or worse, they pour perhaps x10 more money on R&D than previous governments.

Do not know what really happened behind pardus and Gokturk issue. Sattelite is on the sky and Pardus turned to Debian, that is what I know.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by atakan_gurkan on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:06PM (#5814014)
When the events were escalating, while there were clashes between the police and thousands of protesters and hundreds were walking across a bridge over the Bosphorus only one TV channel reported these. And you are dismissing this neglect of the media by "Some press reports things less than you like. Some reports with exaggeration."???

The events unfolding at the moment shows that it was possible to celebrate the May Day in Taksim. "This year there is construction so it was not allowed." does not hold water.

As I gave an example (the journalists being fired), it is not my opinion, it is a fact. And if you do not observe other examples around you then you are simply not looking. Of course every government benefits their supporters to some extent, but getting journalists fired? When was the last time did that happen? And regardless of this happening before or not, is it not suppression of free speech?

You say, "To me, Turkish Academy of Sciences issue is overrated", to me it is not. To a lot of my scientist friends it is not (For the record, I am an astrophysicist). People spent a lot time and energy to build the Turkish Academy of Sciences and the Feza Gürsey Institute. And I know these developments did hurt scientists for a fact; I work in a university and I am personally affected. They may be pouring more money into R&D but did you look at the projects in the last science project fair? http://www.sendika.org/2013/05/kuran-mucizesinden-seriat-huk... Do you recall what the Science and Technology minister said about faculties of science or the theory of evolution? That's where a lot of money is going. It is hard to quantize how much real science is getting.

The satellite is in the sky and the team that built that satellite is mostly fired. Pardus was an independent distribution, the team that built Pardus is also gutted and the distribution is now a (badly) translated Debian.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by afsina on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:10PM (#5815611)
When talking about press, I was talking in general. But yes, on recent events, few press focused on police brutality, and some focused on protester's vandalism. I still believe all mass media is business so I am not shocked with their behavior.

May Day issue. To me it holds water. You are dismissing the fact I told you. I put my money on this, once the re-construction is finished (if ever) I bet they will allow it. Mark this thread to remember.

Yes, I dislike the way Government's handling of press. They should never interfere. However, journalists are not being fired by PM. They are fired by their bosses. No matter what, blame and shame is on them. Also, my personal opinion, the fired journalists were mediocre at best. Perhaps they just screwed up and got fired afterwards. They could easily find places in anti-government press. Where are them now?

Sorry that you got personally effected from the Turkish Academy of Sciences issue. But from what I see Academy is very much alive and doing okay. Probably we will not reach to an agreement on this issue. I am not a believer of so called autonomous science academies. For fundamental science, I prefer actual research. And Universities are the places for that.

Also ouch!. Do you base your ideas on a single stupid project on a science fair for high schools? You are a man of Science, I would expect better.

Pardus was meant to replace MS dependency in government desktop and servers. It was funded by Tubitak. There were many full time paid developers. Initial developers were very strong - top notch. Some of them I know personally. But they left the project one by one. It was long ago. Call it miss management, or lack of vision of higher hierarchy, apparently they could not deliver afterwards. After the change of administration, group is dissolved and they went to plan-B. My point of view, Pardus was gone long before. It was not an ideological issue but a management problem. People may disagree with me, or shed light on the issues I do not know, but that is how I see this. I cannot comment on the satellite crew fired because it is hard to follow the correct information. If they were fired without a good reason, why didn't then fight using lawyers and Union? I do not know.

I do believe there is excessive nepotism and communitarianism in governmental institutions today (They may see it as their right, a form of 'revenge'. I call it bullsh*t). Of course It was there before opposing governments, even when republic was founded. There is no way of getting rid of it. Perhaps libertarians are right on this, you can only beat it by making government as small as possible. Okay I am carried away and wrote too much when I could do actually useful things instead.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by mda on Sunday June 02, 2013 @04:08PM (#5809896)
I partially disagree with your comment about corruption. This part:"Turkey on the other hand is rampant with corruption, especially the current government."

Corruption on upper levels probably never disappears, but at least on the lower levels, where people really got hurt and dreaded most, things got better with current government. As someone who lived in Turkey for quite long time, I can say I was pleasantly surprised that one didn't have to bribe anyone buy a small property. Before, it would be impossible to buy property without bribing everyone in the land register office including janitor and tea server.

Also, in the recent perceived corruption index charts Turkey's position is not so bad, wish it is much better (54.th in 176 countries, Singapore is 5th. Source: http://www.transparency.org/cpi2012/results)

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by wavefunction on Sunday June 02, 2013 @06:05PM (#5810291)
Interesting map, but I have to question it a bit. I mean, Switzerland is 6th which speaks highly to their local situation, but their banks enable all manner of international corruptions.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by lostlogin on Sunday June 02, 2013 @08:33PM (#5810707)
Excellent comment - the saga of stolen Jewish stuff took just a wee while to start to be repatriated...
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by lmm on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:55AM (#5811946)
The fact that swiss banks stuck to their rules and required ownership to be established in the normal way even in the wake of such a dramatic tragedy speaks to their incorruptibility.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by lostlogin on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:41AM (#5812258)
It's a pity that wasn't done with the initial deposits.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by lmm on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:35AM (#5812424)
Huh? The burden of proof for for pulling property out of someone else's account in their name is and should be higher than for depositing things in your own account.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by lostlogin on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:42AM (#5812446)
Absolutely agree. Some of the looted stuff was obviously just that however, and they hung onto it rather too long as well. Just who they should give it back to wouldn't have been easy though.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by fakeer on Monday June 03, 2013 @02:43AM (#5811731)
USA, the land of the free - land of no corruption - land of emancipator - land of liberating bombings - land of the powerful, ranks 9. Wow! Interesting map.

I really do not know what this map considered as corruption. A little explanation shall sure help!

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by drzaiusapelord on Monday June 03, 2013 @04:19PM (#5815672)
I've never had to bribe anyone, ever in the US. In my parent's home country this is absolutely not true.

I hate this overly cynical "i get all my politics and ideas from wikileaks and reddit" on how horrible the US. The US is a fairly pleasant place to live in. If you think a speeding ticket is oppression then its really time to grow up.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by ascotan on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:32AM (#5812417)
RTFM? The source questions are listed in the download.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by kenbellows on Monday June 03, 2013 @12:01PM (#5813993)
The list I'm looking at ranks the US at 19th. did something change drastically in the last 9 hours?

Also, who says the US is the "land of no corruption"? The US has some famously corrupt cities, states, senators, even a President or two, and has throughout its history. I don't think we're claiming superiority in that department. Are we?

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by bad_user on Monday June 03, 2013 @08:25AM (#5812786)
> Singapore is one of the least corrupt countries in the world. Turkey on the other hand is rampant with corruption

I haven't lived in either, but I did live as a child under dictatorship until I was 7 years old and 1989 happened. My parents and grandparents have fresh memories of the dynamics at play in our country and did their best to explain them to me.

I do have a problem with the quoted statement.

It really depends on how you define corruption. If you define it as fraudulent behaviour by those in power, well, technically those in power do not need to behave fraudulently if they bend the law to support whatever they want to do. On paper, at some point Romania was amongst the least corrupted countries in the world. In practice, our society was rotten at its core.

Ending corruption is not the end goal in itself, corruption being a symptom of other problems in society, like the ability to live free, free to build a business, free to own stuff, free to put food on the table, free to have your own voice and your own opinions and beliefs, free to be happy. Not having corruption can either mean that the problems have been solved, or that those in power forwarded whatever agenda they wanted while crushing all opposition. This is especially doable if the country is doing well economically, such that its citizens do not have to worry about putting food on the table, or providing quality health-care to their family or whatever basic needs humans have. The true test that a form of government faces in regards to corruption is not when things are going well economically, but rather when things go awry and one thing to keep in mind is that corruption also goes bottom-up, starting with normal people closing their eyes at fraudulent behaviour of which they themselves are guilty of.

Also, I do have Turkish friends and I have visited Istanbul twice and judging by their own stories of Istanbul, by how the city evolved during my visits and by how dynamic it is, Istanbul is in my top 10 cities I'd want to live in, while Singapore is not.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by balsam on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:57PM (#5809857)
You know, actually the US isn't that much freer in practice compared to Singapore. In theory, perhaps. And the reason has less to do with the decline of rugged individualism amongst soccer moms than the existence of a constant low-level background threat, whether from terrorism, a sizable underclass, law enforcement, or (this might be embarassing for some) alcoholism. They don't check IDs for alcohol in Singapore. If you want to see actual practical examples of freedom, you have to go to western Europe. However, if you say that it is the US which makes sacrifices to provide those freedoms, I will actually agree with you. For the record, I was born and raised in Singapore and have lived in the US for the last decade.

EDIT: all these debates have the political reek of programming language wars... US <-> Lisp; Singapore <-> C++.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by WildUtah on Sunday June 02, 2013 @04:37PM (#5809995)
If you want to see actual practical examples of freedom, you have to go to western Europe.

You have to go where?

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/1009...

I think if you want to see practical examples of freedom, you can conquer your own island and start inventing them. No modern nation is going to tolerate very much of it.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by smutticus on Monday June 03, 2013 @03:51AM (#5811932)
For all its faults the USA has very strong 1st Amendment protections.

I also find it strange that most western European countries outlaw the Nazi party and denying the holocaust. I suspect this only serves to give them more legitimacy in the eyes of society's downtrodden. The American model of dealing with these groups just seems more sustainable. Give them enough room to say all kinds of stupid things.

Le Pen is an ignorant racist. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't give her every opportunity to say all the stupid shit she wants to say.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by ascotan on Monday June 03, 2013 @06:39AM (#5812439)
Depends on what your talking about. I didn't get a caning (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore) last time i threw gum on the sidewalk in the US.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by brendoncrawford on Monday June 03, 2013 @11:19AM (#5813766)
This is a myrh.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by lostlogin on Monday June 03, 2013 @05:46AM (#5812279)
Practical example of freedom? Having your bag searched before entering a museum (Paris)? Bomb detectors at a church (Vatican)? Stopped for random police checks (London)? Passport recorded by hotels to use the Internet (Italy)? If this is freedom, I'm not impressed. (Examples are about 5 years old, things may have changed, I hope they have).
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by Havoc on Sunday June 02, 2013 @05:57PM (#5810263)
>anti-Singaporean sentiments on HN lately

To be honest I doubt Singapore is on the radar of most HN participants in any shape or form whether positive or negative. Thats not to say that its insignificant - its just that there haven't been any 40k people riots there lately...so not at the front of people's minds.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by skore on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:33PM (#5809771)
I remember your comment from yesterday, where you wrote about what is happening in Ankara, stating "I don't live there right now".

Of course, not even living anywhere near where you are, I cannot qualify this myself. But my question (that I hope you won't understand as offensive) to you is: Is it possible that you are victim to your somewhat limited horizon and to the possibly biased information that you get from your government?

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by enraged_camel on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:43PM (#5809804)
I don't get any of my information from the government. They are censoring all the newspapers and channels... Social media is a lot more reliable to get up-to-date information. Tumblr, Twitter, Facebook, etc.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by skore on Sunday June 02, 2013 @03:54PM (#5809847)
Then this comment of yours doesn't make much sense: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5802911

Do you still think this means "fuck-all"?

(And again: Just trying to get a clear picture of what it is you're saying.)

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by enraged_camel on Sunday June 02, 2013 @04:01PM (#5809878)
I meant it as in the regime won't resign because of these riots.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by Jun8 on Sunday June 02, 2013 @07:08PM (#5810448)
Well, reading your comment, especially in the light of how distraught Erdogan seemed in his 1.5 interview with Fatih Altayli, it definitely seems off. Also, Erdogan's party is not a homogenous block, although he's holding everybody in check right now. Even now, some dissident voices among AKP intelligentsia started worrying about the loss of support.

Assuming the government will go after a few days of riots is naive; however, this is a very significant data point for Erdogan.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by enraged_camel on Sunday June 02, 2013 @07:40PM (#5810560)
The interview was staged, or at least well-rehearsed. You will notice that Altayli could not dare to ask any serious questions or question Erdogan's reasoning in any shape or form.

Basically, Altayli is a spineless coward and lost the respect of the Turkish people.

(He reminded me of the way Wolf Blitzer moderated some of the presidential debates here in the US. Blitzer also didn't have the balls to ask anything difficult.)

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by Tloewald on Sunday June 02, 2013 @11:43PM (#5811237)
Blitzer has always been useless.
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by look_lookatme on Sunday June 02, 2013 @02:31PM (#5809560)
"Singapore is one of the least corrupt countries in the world."

You should ask Shane Todd about that.

Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by dsrguru on Sunday June 02, 2013 @06:42PM (#5810384)
The latest as of May is that suicide is much more likely than foul play. See the last paragraph in the introduction on Wikipedia (beginning with "A different picture"): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Shane_Todd
Re:What is Happening in Istanbul? by doodyhead on Tuesday June 04, 2013 @05:24AM (#5818429)
For me the greatest truth in this comment lies in the necessity to live in a place to truly understand it. Living in a new and entirely different country challenges your prejudices and preconceptions.