Does the market need a cheaper printer, or a better one?
These are not mutually exclusive; and I'd go so far as to argue that they are necessarily linked. You will not get better printers (within reasonable price reach) without the market growing to increase scales of production, and you won't get that without bringing in more consumers -- which is precisely what the race for cheaper printers does.This is not the better printer you are looking for, but it is helping to bring about that possibility.
And, minor nitpick:
All the printers had ugly, clunky software
A huge section of this kickstarter is devoted to showing off their user-friendly software.Isn't that the point of crowd funding? Commenters on Hacker News don't decide what the market needs, but rather the market itself does.
Though, $250 was just too good to be true, so I went against instinct and bought one anyway. :D
For machine price, it's a race to the bottom. These are actually easier to manufacture than ink jets, so I can easily see $100 machines.
Hardware -> $0 as software is the real differentiator for simple 3DP. Then, on the top-end, there's Objet with ~$300K for a multi-material machine.
>Does the market need a cheaper printer, or a better one?
Yes. Some are in the market for a cheaper printer as demonstrated by the popularity of this kickstarter. Some are in the market for a better one. There is plenty of room for both.
It kind of reminds me of the Sinclair ZX Spectrum, i.e. don't expect too much (!).
I've used 6 types of 3D printers. (Extrusion type, ABS or PLA) 3 from the 'consumer' grade and 3 from the 'pro' grade. Each of the consumer grade printers was an exercise in frustration.
All the printers had ugly, clunky software, but the pro printers would almost always make the thing I wanted.
The consumer printers I've tried take 3 or 4 failures to get 'set up' then a few more tries to find the bugs most of the way through a build, and eventually you might get one nice print. (After 4-6 hours)
The difficulty of getting a good print scales dramatically with the initial footprint, and not as much with height.
I have no intention of actually buying a printer until I've seen one work that I can afford. I can't manage the cost of most pro machines, but I can't accept the headache of 'consumer' printers today.
I'm glad 3D printing is taking off, but I think we've reached an inflection point where we need to go from possible to easy.