News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:34PM (#5758127)
I hate to be a jerk, but why so many first-world problem startups?

Is keeping a handle on your cat pictures and food shots really that big a deal, something that keeps Joe Sixpack up at night?

Here's an idea: instead of helping hipsters heap hi-res headshots of healthy hobos into the cloud, do something that matters.

For example, go after the giant clusterfuck that is medical image sharing. Again, it's cloud data storage of images, it's sharing on all kinds of devices, and it's technically challenging (privacy concerns, etc.)--and it actually helps people.

Why don't you take this tech and use it to help patients move their medical images between practitioners?

Re:Why we're building Loom by pg on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:05PM (#5758374)
a) Photos are a fundamental form of data, and better infrastructure for managing them helps everyone.

b) We did fund a startup for managing medical images: Clariso, in the last batch. You don't hear as much about b2b startups as consumer ones, because unless you're e.g. a radiologist, they're not trying to reach you. Which means if you try to estimate the number of consumer focused startups based on which ones you happen to hear about, you'll overestimate.

Re:Why we're building Loom by sthommes on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:26PM (#5758528)
pg is right- fundamental.

angersock also touches on a higher level, fundamental need here: the ephemerality of human memories.

Technology should be able to help and this is exactly the problem that Jan and his team at Loom are trying to solve.

Our memories- of our grandparents, our parents, our loves, our children, our grandchildren- they should last forever, and not be ephemeral like clouds and the Cloud.

Technology should help them endure like the cave paintings in Lascaux France. They were created by the earliest, most primitive human technology and remain to inspire awe in all of us.

More than that, our memories- the visual stories of our lives- should be available on any device: any iPhone, any iPad, any Android. And even any TV, Windows or Glass- wherever we are, and wherever we go.

Memories should be memorable and shareable with those we cherish most. An heirloom of us.

Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:13PM (#5758433)
Fair enough.

My comment was more rooted in seeing a rough area of application for what I presume their tech and backend must be capable of, and then thinking about where else it could be put to use outside of the consumer market.

How'd the Clariso folks end up? Still around, I hope?

How much interest do you gauge for these sorts of things (better tech in medical, which is admittedly a whole can of worms)?

Re:Why we're building Loom by abbasmehdi on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:35PM (#5758584)
Yes, Clariso is still very much around. In fact, I introduced their product to an organization that is used by large hospital chains to outsource radiology reports to, these guys have tens of full-time, in-house radiologists looking at hundreds of reports all day, every day. Their immediate reaction after checking out the product? Blown away! The best alternative costs them over $100k/year and it feels like Windows95. Their CTO could not believe such a solution was even possible. The CEO (a radiologist with >25 years of report-reading experience) said to me that this could be "revolutionary".
Re:Why we're building Loom by macspoofing on Thursday May 23, 2013 @05:16PM (#5759584)
It "only" works in Chrome. That's a problem.

//

Limited in ie, firefox and mobile.

Re:Why we're building Loom by kibibu on Thursday May 23, 2013 @07:43PM (#5760301)
If it saved your company > $100k a year, you'd probably rollout Chrome or at least ChromeFrame
Re:Why we're building Loom by spartango on Friday May 24, 2013 @03:49AM (#5761671)
While this trivializes the issue substantially, it is true that if you depend on chrome there are ways to roll out nice site-specific chromium apps that keep everyone happy.
Re:Why we're building Loom by spartango on Friday May 24, 2013 @03:58AM (#5761696)
I'm curious about what differentiates Clariso from other PACSs, as that space has been crowded and active for nearly 20 years (since radiology went digital).

There are some big players in the PACS space that major medical institutions are pleased with, and there's considerable lock-in/inertia associated with these types of products.

As someone working on a medical imaging product who decided that building a PACS was not a good starting point, I'm curious to see what others are doing to sell PACSs.

Re:Why we're building Loom by rdl on Saturday May 25, 2013 @07:20AM (#5766930)
Pretty much all current PACS suck, actually.
Re:Why we're building Loom by spartango on Saturday June 01, 2013 @03:26AM (#5803140)
While this is true, getting institutions to adopt a new PACS is a non-trivial process. I'm curious as to what improvements Clariso bills as big enough to warrant adoption/switching.
Re:Why we're building Loom by famousactress on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:55PM (#5758305)
I'm pretty cynical as a rule, but I'd be careful about classifying startups as trivial or first-world. Facebook was a startup based on the notion that ivy league kids wanted another exclusive place to themselves, and it's obviously put a dent in the world.

The amount of visual information we're collecting nowadays is vast, and I think the idea that it's cute but that it's value ends at individual nostalgia might be shorting it's potential quite a bit.

Further, I'd love to see sharing of medical information get easier, in fact that's literally what I do at the startup I work for... but a big part of what makes what we build possible is the enormous amount of technology in the form of other people's ideas and software (most of it open-source). Loads of that tech came from people working at shops taking shots at problems you might consider first-world.

Yeah, it'd be neat if more people were geeked about working in healthcare. (I'd sure love it if we could find it easier to hire!) But to suggest that everyone else is wasting their time is ridiculous.

Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:02PM (#5758354)
To your point about collecting visual information:

Look, I agree it's awesome and all, but consider that I can still hold the physical photographs of myself from five years ago, of my parents thirty years ago, and my grandparents fifty years ago.

I can't get at the images I uploaded to Facebook two years ago.

So, while I agree that the data is great, I don't exactly think that turning all of it over into the cloud is going to do much for permanency.

Re:Why we're building Loom by famousactress on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:14PM (#5758435)
What I heard you say: Putting my pictures in the cloud isn't working for me today

Gee, that sounds like a pretty solid defense for someone trying to do it better :) Of course, I did notice you also concluded that because we haven't gotten it right yet, we should give up. That's even better. When people say that, that's when I really start to believe there's a problem worth working on here.

If a good number of people don't think it's impossible or silly to do (or that it's already been done poorly and that's the best we can hope for), it's probably gonna be boring to work on.

Re:Why we're building Loom by TechNewb on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:02PM (#5760832)
Agreed. Solving any real problem is a good problem to solve. Cell phones have changed the way Africans communicate with each other, as well as any other developing country/area, but I don't think the initial problem was to solve poor tele-com infrastructure in developing countries.
Re:Why we're building Loom by vec on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:03PM (#5758359)
Largely because with big business in general, and especially with medicine, modernization is more of a political and economic problem than a technical one. There's been medical records keeping software that's better than paper for 30 years now, but a lot of hospitals still use filing cabinets full of handwritten charts.

Switching systems for a major enterprise is hugely expensive. In addition to retooling and retraining, there's the cost of paying someone the often thousands of hours to import all the existing records. Plus six months (optimistically) of dealing with lost records, transcription errors, and learning curve errors from staff unfamiliar with the inevitable quirks of the new system. Not that this is good for any business, but in a hospital setting that can mean dead patients.

Remember that "I'm to entrenched to make major changes" is emphatically not an engineering problem. Neither, for that matter, is "I don't have the money or political power to get access to technology". They are real problems and need real solutions, but throwing more tech at them is not an effective strategy.

Re:Why we're building Loom by chrislloyd on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:50PM (#5758250)
Isn't cloud medical image sharing a "first-world problem" too? I can't imagine it being one of the top 10 things a doctor in a 3rd world country would ask for.
Re:Why we're building Loom by spartango on Friday May 24, 2013 @03:48AM (#5761666)
Actually, it is something that 3rd world country doctors desperately want. Why?

Turns out that in many parts of the world, there's a lack of specialists to read and interpret these images (radiologists, pathologists), even though there are technicians skilled enough to generate them. Fewer still are specialized to handle cases effectively. Thus patients wait long periods of time for diagnoses as slides are transported to places where they can be read, suffering throughout.

Teleradiology and telepathology are burgeoning fields which are necessary across the globe, with the potential to save lives and make money. There are quite a few aggressive players in these spaces, and we're excited to see what they do.

I'm working in an extension of one of these spaces; feel free to reach out if you're curious...

Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:55PM (#5758296)
It's true, it's true.

Holding startups to the criterion of helping the poor, unwashed masses is, however, rather unreasonable.

Re:Why we're building Loom by Terretta on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:24PM (#5759924)
box.net is now HIPAA compliant. (And S3 can be to, if you're careful and want to build something.)
Re:Why we're building Loom by skue on Thursday May 23, 2013 @09:29PM (#5760718)
Not necessarily. AWS doesn't sign Business Associate Agreements, as required by HIPAA/HITECH for any healthcare payers/providers who want to use their services today, and for any Health IT companies who want to use them starting in September (per the new Omnibus Rule announced in March).

AWS and Rackspace have both hinted that they are considering becoming BAA compliant, but they aren't today. Azure (Enterprise) and pricier services like Firehost are.

It is possible that you could make a legal case for storing encrypted patient data on S3, but this is still a gray area, especially when some states (like Mass.) have enhanced patient privacy laws that trump federal laws. And before anyone replies, note that it's a LEGAL question of possession of data, not a technical one about encryption algorithms. We have very expensive HIPAA attorneys who do understand how encryption works but are still undecided on this.

Re:Why we're building Loom by blader on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:56PM (#5758311)
Which is why you're working on stuff like that right? As opposed to third world problems like video games?
Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:59PM (#5758336)
I'm spoken for by my cofounder at the moment (profile info is a little out of date). After that, well, I'm in the best town for healthcare.

What does Hey do again, anyways?

Re:Why we're building Loom by blader on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:05PM (#5758371)
We're making a journal that writes itself, to help people remember their lives. It is most definitely a first world problem, but I also think those are fine to work on. =)
Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:10PM (#5758405)
Ah, cool. It didn't seem immediately obvious from your landing page or about page what you all did. Good luck on your work!
Re:Why we're building Loom by blader on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:12PM (#5758418)
Thank you! We're still pre-launch so the site is still unfortunately vague. Best of luck to you as well sir.
Re:Why we're building Loom by hablahaha on Friday May 24, 2013 @01:43AM (#5761436)
I assume you're talking about Houston, right? ;) If not, then what are people considering the best town for healthcare?
Re:Why we're building Loom by skybrian on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:12PM (#5758425)
This isn't very imaginative. There's nothing first-world about taking photos; people everywhere like to do this. Furthermore, it's not just entertainment but a practical tool; I take photos of shopping lists and whiteboards all the time, and people everywhere will find it useful for remembering things. Uploading photos to the cloud is great way of backing up information on paper, which might be hard to preserve in challenging environments.

The difference is that people in the third world will likely only have cell phones and no desktops. So I would think that making photo sharing work well on mobile (particularly with low connectivity) counts as a third-world problem. And hey, this might even be useful for medical practitioners in remote locations too.

Re:Why we're building Loom by gnok on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:01PM (#5758351)
I don't know anything about Loom, but perhaps the first step to building a HIPAA compliant image store is to simply build an image store? Perhaps Loom's roadmap or eventual plan is to build an image store for a very specific business purpose? Perhaps its more than just cat pictures?

I don't know either way, but I sure wouldn't assume its designed for the exclusive purpose of "helping hipsters heap hi-res headshots of healthy hobos" (nice alliteration btw).

Re:Why we're building Loom by jwarren on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:01PM (#5758350)
People prefer to parse problems that personally perplex.

I have strong opinions and knowledge about what I'd want from a photo sharing service. A medical image sharing service? Not a clue.

Nice alliteration, btw.

Re:Why we're building Loom by haukilup on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:11PM (#5758412)
The first-world tends to care about first-world problems.

It'd be great if everyone's ambitions and efforts were grande and noble, but that's not the world we live in.

Some people need to care about the first-world problems. One reason the first-world is so comfortable is because people have put effort into solving such problems.

Fact is, products and services like this will impact peoples' lives - otherwise it wouldn't be very successful in business.

Re:Why we're building Loom by ukd1 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:41PM (#5758181)
If they're doing something people want (which they are), does it matter?
Re:Why we're building Loom by KevinMS on Friday May 24, 2013 @02:05AM (#5761468)
I think angersock is going to be right about this one. Looks like nothing more than a dropbox with hooks into camera and image viewing apps. Ultimately resulting in TBs of scruffy selfies.
Re:Why we're building Loom by nfoz on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:35PM (#5758137)
Yo, that takes actual work, investment, and domain-specific knowledge.
Re:Why we're building Loom by angersock on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:38PM (#5758160)
:(

I weep for our generation of engineers.

Re:Why we're building Loom by macspoofing on Thursday May 23, 2013 @05:07PM (#5759550)
> hate to be a jerk, but why so many first-world problem startups?

Short answer, because it's easy. Any developer can build a photo management app. It's a known quantity.

Re:Why we're building Loom by bluedino on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:43PM (#5758194)
First-world problems are accessible.
Re:Why we're building Loom by mahyarm on Thursday May 23, 2013 @03:09PM (#5758799)
The first world has the money.

Medical image sharing has more red tape, it's more challenging.

Re:Why we're building Loom by matt2000 on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:23PM (#5758511)
Dear "angersock", it appears in fact you don't hate to be a jerk. The entire contents of your comment indicate the opposite, you enjoy being a jerk. However, there's an interesting question of what's worth working on in the comment, so let's rephrase so we can maybe discuss:

"Is photo storage really broken as the post says? Do we really need more of this kind of technology? I know of some real inefficiencies in medical image sharing which seems like it'd be a similar problem to solve, but to my eyes much more valuable. What would it take to convince people problems like that are worth tackling?"