http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Size_Me
I thought we were lovers of Science on this site? I thought we believed in testing claims through evidence, not some slick marketing video.
The founder has blogged in detail about the evolution of the recipe and effects on his body, http://robrhinehart.com/ (site currently appears to be down).
It's not science.
I'm disappointed to see that blog -which mean people correctly pointed out is not scientifically useful- is being used to sell this product.
That sounds like a pretty reasonable argument to me. Pointing out that the soylent proponent's "evidence" does not stand up to scientific scrutiny does not sound like "argument from authority".
1) Have some (at least one) long term, large cohort, controlled studies proving the efficacy of this diet.
2) Be someone I can trust with being careful and honest with your scientific method over a long period of time.
So saying that you shouldn't trust some mixture put together by some computer programmers in their 20's is just a shortcut to the the two statements above. He (assuming gender here) was absolutely right in his assertion.
Why don't you summarize them here, and ask if the people behind Soylent have utilized them?
"Is it safe? We have been testing Soylent on ourselves for several months and the data shows it to have a positive nutritional benefit."
The well established, scientific method is a double-blind clinical trial, in which neither patient nor investigator know whether the patient is receiving the substance being tested or the control substance.