News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by cletus on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:15AM (#5744212)
I've had this argument with several people. Their position is that "it's my house/apartment, I should be able to do what I want with it" (even when renting they use this argument).

My argument is that this is not and has never been true. You can't, for example, run a tannery in your apartment.

What's more, as a resident (and especially if I were an owner) I wouldn't want my building being a de facto hotel. An endless stream of people coming and going, having building keys and so on.

I don't believe this ruling is anything new. I believe short stay (<30 days) like this was always illegal in NYC.

A friend of a friend lives in a building where the super was soldering a pipe and managed to burn the entire building to the ground (gutted the inside that is).

Imagine the scenario if an AirBnBer does this with say a cigarette?

Or what if someone is assaulted by such a person?

Residency laws exist for a reason. Honestly, AirBnB just seems like a massive liability time bomb waiting to go off.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by davidw on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:24AM (#5744266)
The term that's involved in this is "externality": costs that are imposed on people not involved in the actual transaction (use of the place for payment).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Externality

You rightly point out, that, for instance, in a crowded apartment building, having something like a dynamite storage facility would probably be a bad idea.

However, other things might be annoying too, such as having children or pets or noisy sex, so you have to 1) get an idea of the actual costs involved, and not just "well, this could happen", and 2) see if there's a framework where people could regulate/resolve their differences on a more local level. Perhaps in some buildings, people would be ok with some AirBnB traffic if they get a small cut of it. The idea being that the more global the solution, the more likely it's going to be inefficient.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:30AM (#5744321)
At some point, the cost of adjusting for the externalities will erase the savings of AirBnB. Which would indicate that the much of the "benefit" of AirBnB simply comes from not paying for the externalities.

Beyond the neighbors, there would also need to be city taxes to pay for the regulation and oversight of the rental (and fire inspections, etc), and the use of city services by visitors (who probably don't pay income taxes in that city.) Basically, "hotel tax", which in some places is 20% or more and right now you don't pay when using AirBnB.

Not to mention additional liability insurance, as you can bet that the level of risk incurred by someone doing short-term rentals is much higher than a normal homeowner -- so they shouldn't be in the same risk pool.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by stephencanon on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:51PM (#5745397)
I recently stayed for a few days in an AirBnB room while my wife and I were in New York. A comparably nice hotel room in the same neighborhood would have run us a minimum of $350 a night; the AirBnB room was $110. While I certainly believe that some of the "benefit" of AirBnB comes from not paying for externalities, it stretches logic to believe that those externalities account for $240 a day for two people in one room.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by textminer on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:05PM (#5745483)
Isn't that less the externalities than the pool of folks using the existing hotel infrastructure (bending supply/demand) rather than exploring AirBnb/couch surfing/etc. I imagine if business travelers and tourists used AirBnB en masse, the prices would more closely approach that of traditional hotels... But with hosts that're less dependable.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by gline on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:20PM (#5745619)
There's a clearing price for hotel rooms in NYC based on the built number of hotel rooms. If everyone viewed airbnb and hotels as fundamentally interchangeable then the range of prices for airbnb units would be similar to the range of prices for hotel rooms at that time - but this would be lower than the current range of prices for hotel rooms, as the supply of available rooms will have increased.

Having said that, I think the airbnb market in NYC is reasonably close to clearing with the hotel market. Probably some listings for very nice apartments and also some for relatively mediocre apartments are underpriced, but the truth is that a night in a decent airbnb apartment is in general commensurate with the cost of a hotel room in the same neighborhood.

The catch, of course, is that there are many airbnb listings in places without hotel rooms at all - Harlem, the far Upper East Side, etc - and in those areas the airbnb prices appear low but of course we don't know the appropriate hotel room clearing price.

But to your basic point, I agree there's probably some discount right now for the general sense that airbnb is "weird" or "idiosyncratic" to the average traveller.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by stephencanon on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:39PM (#5746666)
I’m sure there’s a large component of what you say to it, but that suggests that grandparent’s comment:

> the cost of adjusting for the externalities will erase the savings of AirBnB

is false, which is more or less exactly what I’m trying to get at too: it is not unreasonable to expect that AirBnB will continue to be cheaper than hotels even if externalities are priced in.

As for hosts being less dependable, I’m sure that happens, but the few times I’ve used AirBnB, I’ve been quite pleased. By contrast, it seems like more than half the time I check into a hotel, something is amiss or the room isn’t ready by the time it was promised, or ... something. There are exceptional hotels with great customer service, but most hotels are borderline terrible in my experience.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:30PM (#5747003)
That assumes that the hotel room and the AirBnB room were comparable in terms of amenities and services, which they probably weren't. (Room service? Daily cleaning? Gym? Doormen/porters?) You can get a pretty nice hotel in NY for $350 a night -- the W hotel downtown has rooms for $359 this weekend.

I'm not saying there aren't great deals out there on AirBnB; right now it's a market of people basically selling unused inventory at very low prices. I'm saying that if they had to incur more normal requirements (safety, taxes, insurance), the pricing would rise and the inventory would decline. If that same AirBnB room cost $250, it might not as interesting to you.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by davidw on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:34AM (#5744356)
Some of the benefit is certainly from skirting regulations, but I can see some big benefits to accessing a much wider range of options, too, so there might well be a place for AirBnB even if it were taxed/regulated a bit more, rather than simply banned.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:37AM (#5744385)
That's fine, but it's unproven that the AirBnB market works at all if renters have to pay 20%+ hotel taxes and apartment owners have to pay income tax. It would both raise the effective rates and greatly decrease the received benefit to the seller -- there might not be a clearing market any more. I'd consider renting my spare room for $100 a night, but not for $40.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by gknoy on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:56PM (#5745432)
I'm pretty sure that the hosts still have to pay income tax, if they are getting paid money for having someone stay in their house.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:33PM (#5745748)
They're supposed to. How many do you think actually are?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by Aloisius on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:37PM (#5746283)
Probably about the same percent as individuals who rent out their apartment long-term?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:41PM (#5747093)
I doubt it. Landlords have to count rent as aggregate gross income on their tax returns, and it's probably both fairly easy to get caught and fairly serious if you do get caught.

http://www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Em...

(If you're just subletting, only any net gain is taxable, which is probably minor.)

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by sliverstorm on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:31AM (#5744324)
Yeah, AirBnB basically seems to be an exercise in converting externalities into profit.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by rayiner on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @12:34PM (#5744812)
Much of what we consider to be profitable, high-growth business is about taking advantage of market failures. E.g. the advertising industry that bankrolls the internet is basically about taking advantage of cognitive biases to get people to make irrational purchasing decisions. Part of the success of e-commerce is due to the heroic efforts of UPS, etc, in reducing the cost of shipping over the years to make e-tailing cheaper than brick and mortar retailing, but a big part is also arbitraging on state sales tax laws.

This is not a moral judgment (I'm too old to make moral judgments). Fact is that purely competitive markets suck because there is no money in them (there's no high growth startups in the dairy industry, even with extensive government subsidies to offset the effects of vicious competition). A good fraction of the opportunities to make money are based on things like arbitraging regulations or exploiting market failures. Much of the rest involves focusing on markets with little competition (either because it's new or because others don't have the skills to target them), but I think people underestimate how much activity is in the former bucket. E.g. with AirBnB: are they in business because nobody thought to do what they're doing before, or because people thought about it before but realized it was illegal?

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by bcgraham on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:45PM (#5745844)
"Taking advantage of the difficulty of contract and regulatory enforcement" finds an equilibrium at some really sour places.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by maxerickson on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:45PM (#5745354)
http://www.businessinsider.com/the-success-story-of-chobani-...

But maybe that is the exception that proves the rule. Or maybe you didn't mean dairy products.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by rayiner on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:54PM (#5745416)
Chobani is unusual in that it brought a different product to the market that was objectively better. There are other new players in the dairy industry, but a lot of that action is applying lifestyle marketing to food products (e.g. getting people to pay more for trendy food when they could get the same food for much less without the lifestyle brand). Think about stuff like flavored water--a product that couldn't get more fungible that exists because marketing makes it seem non-fungible.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by maxerickson on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:55PM (#5747178)
Looking at my comment, the last bit looks sarcastic. I actually meant that I thought you might be thinking more of milk production and less about processed diary.

Anyway, I'm not sure 5 of them would really weaken the point you were making.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:36PM (#5745775)
Converting externalities into profit isn't necessarily taking advantage of market failures. It may just be _creating_ market failure and taking advantage of them.

Let's say all of the restaurants in your neighborhood have to charge extra because of the cost of commercial garbage service. And you start selling food cheaper, because you're putting your garbage into the household trash and passing on the savings. Yes, that's a business, but it's basically just breaking the rules and passing some of the savings on to customers.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by seferphier on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:57PM (#5745437)
Agree. it has been argued that the whole financial industry is indirectly subsidized by the government for being too big to fail.

Elon states that many forbes list billionaires receive huge amounts of profit from the subsidies (oil, agriculture)

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by rayiner on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:07PM (#5745502)
Yes, finance is heavily subsidized, but so are many other major industries. The tech industry is also heavily subsidized, by design, and is indeed one of the original recipients of such subsidies. Many of the land-grant universities founded in the 1800's were specifically designed to train engineers to go into what was the high-tech industries of the time. Crossing the line from providing people a general education to specifically training people with the skills relevant to a particular industry and thereby reducing that industry's training costs is a form of subsidy, one that continues to this day.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by darkarmani on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @12:51PM (#5744930)
That might be true if your worldview started and ended at the edge of NYC. For the rest of us, AirBnB is used across the country in suburbs and less populous cities.

If you have a two family house and "air out" the second apartment, how exactly is that converting externalities into profit?

I'm not sure a densely populated city should really make any objections to externalities.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by namdnay on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @04:10AM (#5749471)
There are still a lot of externalities that people are cutting corners on, even in the suburbs: proper insurance (by not declaring that you're acting as a hotel), tax (by not declaring airbnb income on your income tax), safety regulations (fire extinguishers, smoke alarms, floor plans etc).

Not that all these laws make sense for airbnb, but by not respecting them you're "unfairly" undercutting hotels.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @02:01AM (#5749159)
That would only apply to specific airbnb stays which cause negative externalities like discomfort to other apartment residents. Do you really think that this is a measurable problem?

I don't. I think that hotels are just pissed because airbnb provides a fairly thin layer of technology that allows property owners and renters to use their property more efficiently (by having it occupied more often) and therefore threatens the very core of their business.

It's the same story with taxi drivers opposing ridesharing services. Does anyone really think that taxi drivers are mad because they're worried that these new services will provide a less safe or comfortable experience to passengers, which is supposedly the point of taxi regulations? Nope. I think they're mad because ridesharing services allow more efficient use of automobiles and therefore threaten the very core of the taxi industry. Any bets on what taxi drivers will think about Google's automated cars when they start offering shuttles for hire?

If we want to talk about externalities, we should at least recognize the possibility (and, I dare say, the near certainty) that many government regulations themselves have considerable negative externalities.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @01:52AM (#5749140)
Pointing out the existence of externalities is not sufficient. You need to show why government (loosely defined here as an organization with a well-accepted legal monopoly on the use of violence to resolve conflicts) will lead to fewer negative externalities than other means of conflict resolution.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:51AM (#5744479)
> You can't, for example, run a tannery in your apartment.

I would prefer that you could, in the (perhaps unlikely) scenario that it was allowed by the terms of your rental agreement. If it's your own property, go right ahead.

> What's more, as a resident (and especially if I were an owner) I wouldn't want my building being a de facto hotel.

Many residents would probably agree, and if enough agree, then there's no reason why the property owner couldn't prohibit the practice in the rental agreements. I live in San Francisco, where airbnb is legal (as far as I know), yet my property owner explicitly prohibits "short term subleasing," effectively banning airbnb rentals. No law or government action required, no criminals made, no taxpayer-funded enforcement, and no problem.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by nathanstitt on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @12:25PM (#5744740)
You cannot be serious. Just because you happen to own the property does not give you absolute rights. What you are arguing against is called zoning and the legality of that is very well settled.

The tannery example is pretty apt here - what right do you have to run a foul smelling eyesore right beside the property where I'm attempting to raise a family?

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by ahallock on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:04PM (#5745959)
That should really depend on the contracts and negotiations between property owners, tenants, etc. Maybe you don't mind living next to that "eyesore" because it's much cheaper and you can afford private schooling for your children. Everything is a cost/benefit, and people may be willing to sacrifice one thing for another, so have a little empathy.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by davidw on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:41PM (#5747096)
I think you missed the point of "externality": the people affected by the externality are not party to the negotiations.

In other words, when I buy the house next to yours, and from one day to the next, decide to use it to store decaying pig shit in the yard, or manufacture high explosives, all of a sudden, you got something really nasty that you did not choose. It's not as if you chose to move next door knowing full well what goes on in my business. All of a sudden, the value of your house has dropped, and you haven't been compensated for it at all.

I agree that zoning and restrictions should be regulated at a local level so that multiple solutions can arise, but it seems like trying to involve neighbors in contract negotiations becomes quite complicated quickly. The guy 2 houses down has seen his house fall in value too, although maybe not quite so much. The guy 20 houses away might still smell things on a bad day, so he's affected a little bit too, should he be included in negotiations as well?

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by ahallock on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @06:43PM (#5747522)
I agree with what you're saying for the most part. I think, though, that people want to get along and social pressure can work for a lot of these situations. Regulations do not always work in your favor, though, and do not always protect people.

For example, where I live in Cleveland, there used to be a rule that policeman (and I think most civil servants) had to live inside the city limits to work there. Once they removed the regulation, these workers sold their homes and left. The property value has dropped considerably as a result.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by TeMPOraL on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:56PM (#5745425)
> what right do you have to run a foul smelling eyesore right beside the property where I'm attempting to raise a family?

He has every right to do this. Why do you assume that your family is more important than his tannery?

The regulations against things like tannery in an apartment are only there so that you can, when e.g. choosing a place to raise your family, find a place that will suit your requirements. It's like labels on food. You want something without sugar? You go and find something labeled "sugar-free". Regulations are there only to help you choose what you want. You don't look at a sugar drink and then ask "what rights does a food company have to put sugar in my drink when I'm trying to stay on keto?".

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by HarryHirsch on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:32PM (#5745742)
You could argue that this question has been discussed before, and that that is the reason why there are laws against noxious businesses in populated areas. If you want to operate that tannery of yours you had better have a good case and make it.

If it's just your right against theirs, that is the short path to "direct action", and you cannot have that in a civilized society.

You could also argue that you have the right to operate that tannery of yours but choose not to exercise it out of consideration of the people who will suffer from the stench. That would be the aristocratic viewpoint, argued eloquently by Ernst Jünger in the "Ledge at Masirah".

Either way, there is such a thing of society, and anyone arguing cleanly has to take that into account.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by wavefunction on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:26PM (#5745682)
That's why we have zoning, so tanners can go tan hides and residential areas remain for residing.

It's like y'all are trying to reinvent practices long derived from observation and common sense. If you don't like a property's zoning, then don't buy it or go through the process to change the zoning.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by nathanstitt on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:21PM (#5746110)
As HarryHirsch says, no he absolutely does not have that right. Zoning is far from a new invention, it's been around since the industrial revolution at least.

I'm honestly shocked that people apparently would want to live in the kind of an environment where at any second the property next door could be turned into a tannery. How could anyone have confidence in their property's value in a society where that was allowed?

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:30PM (#5747002)
There is more than one to solve social problems. Centralized, violent, compulsory action (government) is one way, but there are others. Opposing "the government solution" is not the same thing as denying the problem or refusing to fix it.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by namdnay on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @04:12AM (#5749479)
How are zoning regulations "violent"?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by vacri on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @09:13AM (#5750520)
It's a standard libertarian meme. Resist the government long enough and eventually - eventually might take years - someone wearing a gun will come and arrest you. Since they're arresting you with superior arms to the point of perhaps pointing them at you, this means doing so is violent, hence everything the government ever does is 'backed by violence', hence everything they ever do to limit you in any way is 'violen', no matter how minor that limitation might be. It's one of the more tortuous aspects of libertarian rhetoric.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:02PM (#5751734)
This is one of those ideas that became a meme because it is unquestionably true. Ideas which are true tend to spread quickly. And, regarding this specific example, it's ludicrous to claim that it might take years if you violate zoning regulations. It would be more like hours.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by vacri on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @05:44PM (#5753962)
Ideas which are true tend to spread quickly.

Nonsense. History is full of true ideas getting pounded flat. Sensationalist journalism is more effective than true journalism. So on and so forth. If "true ideas spread quickly", then religion would be dead in the water, all around the world.

And seriously, hours between doing some tanning and getting arrested for violation of zoning laws!? Zoning law violation rarely ends up in arrests in the first place - you get fined, then if you don't pay your fines, down the track they'll start the process.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @10:35PM (#5755027)
> History is full of true ideas getting pounded flat.

That is not the logical complement of what I said. I only said that true ideas tend to spread quickly, which is obviously true. True ideas which were pounded flat are not counterexamples, because I'm talking about tendency.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by vacri on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:26AM (#5756087)
It is a counterexample, because clearly untrue ideas also spread quickly, and history shows that untrue ideas stick far more easily - pursuing reason requires a lot of effort.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:21PM (#5758036)
That's still not a logical complement of what I said. I didn't say that only true ideas tend to spread quickly, or that they tend to spread more quickly than untrue ideas.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by vacri on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:18PM (#5759898)
Really? The whole point of saying the statement at all is that 'true' ideas have this feature than other ideas don't have as much of. Now you say that non-true ideas spread just as quickly, the statement is utterly pointless.

If the 'trueness' of the idea is irrelevant to how quickly it spreads, as you've just said here, then your statement becomes "Ideas tend to spread quickly, regardless of their truth", which is pointless given the context.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:31PM (#5761132)
Read closely. All I said is that the particular idea in question spread quickly because it is true and because true ideas tend to spread quickly. It is completely irrelevant if non-true ideas also spread quickly. What I said still holds.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by namdnay on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:14PM (#5751829)
> This is one of those ideas that became a meme because it is unquestionably true

It sounds more like a rhetorical truism than a "true idea". Of course the police enforce the laws, that's what they're there for.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:26PM (#5751923)
> It sounds more like a rhetorical truism

And yet, people frequently dismiss it as a "libertarian meme." One doesn't have to look far on the Internet to find someone that will deny that government enforcement of things like taxation or zoning regulations do not constitute violence.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by namdnay on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:03AM (#5756014)
What I meant by truism is that it may be a logically consistent position given the initial assumptions, but it brings no additional knowledge. If you accept the government=violence condition, then ANY law, rule or regulation is upheld by violence.

When you don't pay alimony: violence. When you jaywalk: violence. When you litter: violence. When you wear shorts instead of trunks at the swimming pool: violence...

OK, great, we've established that there is violence everywhere. But what has that brought us? Nothing.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by vacri on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @08:16PM (#5754615)
Really, it depends on whether you're using the English definition of 'violence' or the libertarian definition of the word.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @10:38PM (#5755035)
I'm just using the definition that seems to be the first one listed in many English dictionaries.

"Violence is the intentional use of physical force or power, threatened or actual, against a person, or against a group or community, that either results in or has a high likelihood of resulting in injury, death, psychological harm, maldevelopment or deprivation." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Violence?redirect=no

"Physical force exerted for the purpose of violating, damaging, or abusing" http://www.answers.com/topic/violence

"exertion of physical force so as to injure or abuse" http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/violence

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by vacri on Thursday May 23, 2013 @06:35AM (#5756105)
Your last two definitions don't fit unless you've a priori decided any government action is abuse - which is the wrong way to define things. Your first definition is so belaboured and tortuous that it sounds like libertarians have been at it.

And it's interesting to note that none of your definitions allow for natural phenomenon to be violent, yet we quite naturally talk about things like violent storms in English.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:13PM (#5751821)
How are they not violent? What would happen if you really did set up a loud assembly in a Manhattan apartment?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:26PM (#5746973)
> What you are arguing against is called zoning and the legality of that is very well settled.

Indeed. I am seriously arguing against zoning, or rather, against the necessity and wisdom of government (i.e. violent, compulsory) action to solve this problem.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by HarryHirsch on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:39PM (#5747079)
The alternative would be a society not based on the law, but on connections and reputation - real-life examples would be a Brazilian favela, Wikipedia, the Iceland of the Sagas. Not something I'd prefer.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @10:24PM (#5748443)
That is not the alternative. Depending on your definition of "law," it doesn't necessarily imply government. In fact, a lot of functioning "law" today is non-governmental (one reason for this is the unsurprisingly high cost and inefficiency of the government's conflict mediation system). But moreover, even regardless of your definition of "law," it's naive to assume that the way government works isn't "based on connections and reputation" in just as bad of a way as you expect a government-less society might be.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by saurik on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:25PM (#5747782)
(I am sorry: I accidentally down-voted you on my iPhone when I meant to up vote you. I leave this explicit note to make certain you know you should have two more points on this comment than you do.)
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by JohnTHaller on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @12:21PM (#5744708)
Every lease I've seen of my group of friends prohibits subletting without express permission of the landlord/owner. It's already the standard in NYC. Realistically, every AirBNB within a rental unit in NYC is likely violating the terms of their lease.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by oijaf888 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:57PM (#5745435)
It might say that but is that an actual enforceable provision?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by FelixP on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:42PM (#5745820)
Yes, absolutely. My family has evicted tenants from some of our units for repeatedly violating this clause of their leases.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by oijaf888 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:54PM (#5746758)
It seems in NYC at least, the landlord can't refuse to let someone sublet so long as they are properly notified and the sublet is reasonable. The way most leases are written though, it makes it sound as if the landlord has the final say vs it defaulting to permitted (with notification) unless the landlord makes a good case why it should be denied.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:30PM (#5745723)
> I live in San Francisco, where airbnb is legal (as far as I know)

Its generally not (its illegal in San Francisco to rent a unit for less than thirty days in a residential building with more than four units.) New York and San Francisco are the two US locations that I've seen the most news coverage for AirBnB's legal issues in.

> yet my property owner explicitly prohibits "short term subleasing," effectively banning airbnb rentals. No law or government action required, no criminals made, no taxpayer-funded enforcement, and no problem.

All contracts, and especially lease agreements where the ultimate enforcement action is eviction, depend very much on law, government action, and taxpayer-funded enforcement action.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by ahallock on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:57PM (#5745908)
So because there is dependence on some monopolistic entity for contract disputes (there really shouldn't be), then that gives justification for that entity to intrude on voluntary actions? Seems like a logical fallacy to me. How about we let people transact peacefully and deal with the problems on a case-by-case basis instead of lumping everyone under the same law that allows no room for exploration.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:55PM (#5747181)
> So because there is dependence on some monopolistic entity for contract disputes (there really shouldn't be)

Its definitional: if you aren't seeking the threat of state enforcement to enforce a set of mutual promises, you don't have a contract, you have a mutual set of promises that lacks the intent necessary to form a contract.

> then that gives justification for that entity to intrude on voluntary actions?

Yes, using the threat of action by other people to get what you want gives those other people a right to a voice in what you can use that threat to support.

> Seems like a logical fallacy to me.

Subjective appearance can say as much about the one seeing as the thing being seen.

> How about we let people transact peacefully and deal with the problems on a case-by-case basis instead of lumping everyone under the same law that allows no room for exploration.

Enforcement of existing laws, civil and criminal, is done on a case-by-case basis by actual people; even if something creates a civil or criminal cause of action, the party (the prosecutorial authority of the state, in criminal cases) with the cause of action may choose not exercise it, and jury nullification is thing, so, largely, what you call for is the status quo.

If you think the specific parameters of the existing law are drawn incorrectly, you probably ought to address your specific problem rather than calling for abstract features that already exist in the current system.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by ahallock on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @07:14PM (#5747719)
> Its definitional: if you aren't seeking the threat of state enforcement to enforce a set of mutual promises, you don't have a contract, you have a mutual set of promises that lacks the intent necessary to form a contract.

That is one definition, but not the only. And I'm sure there are creative ways to enforce contracts without State force--third-party arbitration could be an option, social pressure, etc. Most contract disputes I've been involved with have been resolved without the need for legal action. There are plenty of social dynamics that come into play.

> Enforcement of existing laws, civil and criminal, is done on a case-by-case basis by actual people; even if something creates a civil or criminal cause of action, the party (the prosecutorial authority of the state, in criminal cases) with the cause of action may choose not exercise it, and jury nullification is thing, so, largely, what you call for is the status quo.

This is true, but I don't think it's working. Looking at the current prison population, something is deeply flawed. Are most jurors even aware of jury nullification?

> If you think the specific parameters of the existing law are drawn incorrectly, you probably ought to address your specific problem rather than calling for abstract features that already exist in the current system.

Fair enough.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @01:44AM (#5749117)
I'll add: third-party arbitration is already quite common, and in many cases is very deliberately used to avoid the government alternative. The definition proposed by that commenter indicates to me that he or she is simply unaware of the existence and commonness of arbitration.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by HarryHirsch on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:55PM (#5752131)
Anywhere outside Hackernews, mandatory arbitration is considered a way to prevent trial by jury. It's safe to say that "trial by jury" got written into the constitution is because the drafters had experience with arbitration and were aware that at times it can be seriously unfair and inequitable to one of the parties.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by infinite8s on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @08:55AM (#5750399)
What do you think a representational government is except the exertion of social pressure backed by force?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:22PM (#5751898)
One key difference is that the representational government's monopoly is backed by force.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by infinite8s on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:46PM (#5746702)
By monopolistic entity, do you mean society? If you don't want to live by the rules of the society you are in, you are free to withdraw yourself and find somewhere else without such onerous restrictions. Likely you'll find it much worse place to live.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @10:39PM (#5755040)
I don't mean society. I mean a very small portion of society called "government."
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dev_jim on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @12:41PM (#5744854)
> If it's your own property, go right ahead.

Yep, this is the problem with services like AirBnB and Uber. It's embraces a purely selfish attitude in individuals with blatant disregard for the rest of the community.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by brown9-2 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @12:45PM (#5744888)
How does Uber harm the community?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by rayiner on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:35PM (#5746649)
The problem with Uber isn't necessarily, that it harms the community, but that it unfairly competes with the taxi monopoly. Now, your first reaction might be to say "well that's the taxi monopoly's problem" but there is more to it. The taxi monopoly is a bargain struck between municipalities and service providers. The bargain is that taxi cabs get monopoly protection in return for their agreeing to function as an extension of the public transit system. As part of the bargain, taxi companies agree to do things that they wouldn't do in a free market--agree to drop people off anywhere in the city, agree to serve poor neighborhoods, etc. If the municipalities allow Uber to operate without those constraints, they are going back on their end of the bargain.

Maybe the right answer is to end the bargain entirely--buy out the medallions and end the monopoly protection, and let everyone compete on a level playing field. But allowing Uber to ignore taxi regulations while still imposing them on the cab companies is not fair.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @01:46AM (#5749122)
> The taxi monopoly is a bargain struck between municipalities and service providers.

Indeed. It's an agreement of which Uber and its customers are not members.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by greghinch on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:00PM (#5745007)
Seriously. Just the other night I had an Uber ride from a guy, he had previously spent years working as a single taxi operator. Within the past year on Uber, he's been able to expand out on his own, and now owns 6 additional cars which he leases to other Uber drivers. He's also training all of them on how to do the same thing, and one of them is soon going to likely strike out on his own with 2 cars to start. These are small, independent business people, who would not have these opportunities otherwise.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by DanBlake on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:09PM (#5745517)
Uber is different in that (in my mind) they do NOT break the law, nor entice others to do so. The law around taxi based operations is on 'hailing fares' - Which involves a taxi driving and seeing you with your hand sticking out and picks you up. Uber cannot do that, its not a taxi. Its a on demand, car pickup service with licensed drivers.

Now, on the other hand- I think that lyft would be a better comparison to airbnb. I believe they let users without a taxi license do the same thing as uber.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baddox on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @10:40PM (#5755044)
It doesn't. Some people just don't like people making money peacefully without the government's permission.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by lotsofcows on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @03:26AM (#5749358)
"go right ahead" Yeah! My neighbours can go fuck themselves! Always complaining about my 3am parties and my friends from the Silencers Are a Crime Motorbike Club. It's my turn to be selfish!
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by brudgers on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:38AM (#5744387)
Oh, its more serious than that.

(IANAL) Using a dwelling for short term rental may be a violation of the covenants upon the deed and may allow someone previously holding title to the land to reclaim it - this is why Home Owner Associations are obligated to enforce the regulations of deed restricted communities and what allows them to impose sanctions against violators.

I once was involved with a waterfront parcel deeded to the city for a park in the 1920's. It was never developed as such and an adjacent property owner - a trauma surgeon - offered to purchase it. I became involved nine years on after the surgeon had tracked down and obtained a quit-claim from all the surviving heirs of the previous owners. That was in 2002 as part of the city's approval of the sale.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dev_jim on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:30AM (#5744314)
Agree. AirBnB is the ultimate John Galt system in NYC. Apartment renters get cash for their apartment (that they usually don't even own) and then everyone else in the building gets to deals with the fallout of a revolving set of neighbors who share the lobby, amenities, hallways, and walls. Good riddance.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by durango on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:16PM (#5745125)
When you forced to pay $300/night in Manhattan at the W hotel, Atlas Shrugged.

Not a AR fan btw, just saying both sides of the fence have their pros and cons. I'd place higher value on an apartment complex that explicitly did not allow short-term renting within their contract.

The other problem is... what's the difference between me using AirBNB and me knowing a friend who let me stayed at his place for 6 days and I just happened to give him some money as a thank you gift?

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dev_jim on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:33PM (#5745251)
> When you forced to pay $300/night in Manhattan at the W hotel, Atlas Shrugged.

No one is "forcing" you to spend $300/night in Manhattan for a hotel. You should read that book again because you are also not using "Atlas Shrugged" in a meaningful context.

> Not a AR fan btw, just saying both sides of the fence have their pros and cons. I'd place higher value on an apartment complex that explicitly did not allow short-term renting within their contract.

Laws and regulations around housing are put in place to protect all residents, the landlord, the community, regardless of what Joe the landlord remembered or didn't remember to put into his stock lease.

> The other problem is... what's the difference between me using AirBNB and me knowing a friend who let me stayed at his place for 6 days and I just happened to give him some money as a thank you gift?

And what's the difference between cooking for friends who give you money for groceries and opening a restaurant in your apartment? You can always make an argument that appeals to the extreme in making your case, but thankfully that doesn't make it a legally relevant argument.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:42PM (#5745321)
> what's the difference between me using AirBNB and me knowing a friend who let me stayed at his place for 6 days and I just happened to give him some money as a thank you gift?

Its the difference between an informal, non-contracted exchange of gifts between parties known to each other with an established relationship on the one hand, and a contractual, arms-length agreement between strangers through a third-party intermediary with arms-length contractual relationships with both parties on the other.

As a general rule, in most domains, the latter tends to be subject to greater regulation than the former, both because, as an arms-length agreement, there is greater need for protection from abuse and, as a contractual agreement, it necessarily invokes the threat of state action.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by durango on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @12:11PM (#5751804)
> No one is "forcing" you to spend $300/night in Manhattan for a hotel. You should read that book again because you are also not using "Atlas Shrugged" in a meaningful context.

Good luck finding a hotel for cheaper than $200 at least in Manhattan :) And you're right, you're not forced, you're more than welcome to sleep on the public streets.

> Laws and regulations around housing are put in place to protect all residents, the landlord, the community,

To a certain extent this is true, but this does not take away the fact that me selling my house for a few days that I'm gone to someone else should be illegal. You're also assuming that I want to throw out EVERY SINGLE LAW OMGBBQ. Talk about being "extreme." Good gosh Charlie Brown.

> regardless of what Joe the landlord remembered or didn't remember to put into his stock lease.

There's this magical thing called lawyers. They're pretty cool once you get to know them, even the "sharks." Without them, writing contracts would be to hard for my small brain :(

> And what's the difference between cooking for friends who give you money for groceries and opening a restaurant in your apartment? You can always make an argument that appeals to the extreme in making your case, but thankfully that doesn't make it a legally relevant argument.

I'm actually a big advocator of people starting up restaurants in small capacity places (remember, we can be a vegan restaurant with absolutely no use of a stove, only an oven which means a safe, contained, and controlled environment) such as homes and/or "food trucks".

And you were right about the AS comment, good call :) (like I said not an AR fan I was under the presumption that it had to do something with business owners leaving due to all of these rules and leaving the "big guys" to look after everyone).

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by bhb916 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @03:10PM (#5746005)
The only difference that matters between friendly exchanges (cooking and room/board) and AirBnB or underground restaurants is that one set of actions threaten the existing power brokers who have the ear of City Hall. No one blinks when you disrupt file sharing or social networking, but disrupt automotive, taxis, or hotels (for example) and you're in a world of legal hurt. I fully understand that these zoning laws that AirBNB is running afoul of have existed for some time, but, as others pointed out, there are plenty of private, non-coercive ways to solve this same problem. They were codified into law because some powerful incumbent business sought to benefit financially from it.

The other differences between these different transactions, while perfectly valid distinctions, are simply ex post rationalizations made by those who support the entity in power (in this case city hall).

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by dev_jim on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @05:54PM (#5747168)
> The only difference that matters between friendly exchanges (cooking and room/board) and AirBnB or underground restaurants is that one set of actions threaten the existing power brokers who have the ear of City Hall.

I think it's a shame that most people are too cynical to understand why laws and regulations around food, housing, transportation, etc. exist. Odd in particular that you think preventing underground restaurants has anything to do with protecting the power brokers when there's a big public health case to be made for ensuring that food is prepared in a sanitary environment. I'm guessing you're in favor of a solution that let's people get sick/die and then let the free market enact it's revenge on the restaurant. Good thing we decided to leave that model out with the 20th century.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by bhb916 on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @03:37PM (#5753217)
More ex post reasoning. And it's not being a cynic that makes me believe this -- it's an honest look at the empirical evidence.

There is really vibrant underground restaurant industry in Seattle. I don't think people are getting sick/dying in massive numbers. Also, I would favor a solution where a restaurant is held legally (and perhaps criminally) liable if they make a diner sick or die. As it stands now, they can hide behind the health code.

I think it's a shame that most people are too cynical to understand that there are solutions to problems that don't require the use of force.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by baby on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:32AM (#5744338)
I can't agree more with you, and in the mean time I feel really bad because AirBnB is a blessing in this world.

There's no real efficient way to enforce such a law though, I don't really know for the US but we have many craig-list style websites in France where you can find a place to rent for a week (and avoid AirBnB's fee). AirBnB just made everything simpler, and safe (rating people, profiles, etc...)

One more thing. AirBnB is especially relevent in big cities like New York, Hong Kong, ... where hotels are super expensive and rent as well.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by fragsworth on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:26PM (#5745683)
> What's more, as a resident (and especially if I were an owner) I wouldn't want my building being a de facto hotel. An endless stream of people coming and going, having building keys and so on.

I can understand your desire to have things this way, but as an individual, I see no reason why you would want to force this rule on everyone in your city. If you don't want your neighbors renting their place out, go live in an apartment complex that doesn't allow tenants to do this. If you don't want your tenants doing this, then make it against the terms of your rental agreement.

What business licensing really does is foster a kind of local monopoly, often as a favor to the existing businesses. It's anti-competitive, by making it very difficult to start a business. Most people are completely unaware of these very real motives behind local licensing laws.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by FelixP on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:37PM (#5745779)
> If you don't want your tenants doing this, then make it against the terms of your rental agreement.

It's actually a violation of most standard residential rental agreements; sub-tenancy is often tightly controlled and only permitted with the express permission of the landlord.

Source: my family owns apartment buildings in several different cities.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by bcgraham on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:43PM (#5745823)
It probably is against the rental agreements for most of the people doing it.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by chrisbaus on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:53PM (#5745410)
In my opinion, this should be left to the owners of the specific building and not a city wide restriction. I own a property in Florida and the HOA restricts rentals less than a month. It isn't necessary for the municipality to get involved.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by DanBlake on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:17PM (#5745595)
The tannery thing is a bad example because its not a inherently illegal activity.

Renting out units under 30 days is plain and simple illegal as the laws are written.

With that, a much better example would be running a brothel. It is as cut and dry illegal as this is. Both have city laws saying "This is not allowed". The city certainly has more priority in enforcing one over the other mind you.

You can argue all day airbnbing your unit should not be illegal, but it currently is. Lots of people argue prostitution should be legal though as well, so best of luck.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by voidlogic on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:08PM (#5745511)
>>Imagine the scenario if an AirBnBer does this with say a cigarette?

How is the situation different if you have a friend stay over night? What if they house sit for you a couple of days?

The only difference above is they are not paying you, but how does that affect liability?

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by namdnay on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @05:28AM (#5749675)
Your home insurance will cover damage caused by friends staying over. They won't cover damage caused by customers of your (undeclared) business.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by willbill on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @02:49PM (#5745867)
One of the main problems I have with it is that in New York, I know of people who are doing a taking account AirBnb rates when calculating a break even for their sublets/extra rooms. This will push rents up in the city and ultimately not help a lot of the actual residents.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by doughj3 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:21PM (#5746572)
> I believe short stay (<30 days) like this was always illegal in NYC.

If by "always illegal" you mean "since two years ago": http://skift.com/2013/01/07/airbnbs-growing-pains-mirrored-i...

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by uptown on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @04:27PM (#5746600)
Separate from that law, literally every New York lease I've ever seen has included terms forbidding the rental behavior that AirBNB promotes, and I'd be surprised if the bylaws of every co-op didn't include house rules forbidding this type of activity. Some condos may be more-flexible in their laws - but there's always been a pretty-strong legal framework in-place forbidding re-renting an apartment in this manner.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by snambi on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:22PM (#5745168)
if someone owns the property, they should be able to rent their house or condo. Illegal sounds like city is trying to protect other businesses such as established hotels. Define, the rules, so that people can follow them.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by radiusq on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:24AM (#5744268)
Your argument is completely shallow and void of reason..

> You can't, for example, run a tannery in your apartment

Why not? Whats your argument?

>What's more, as a resident (and especially if I were an owner) I wouldn't want my building being a de facto hotel.

If I owned a building then I set the rules/laws. This is about property rights, not about what you think is right or wrong. If I want to turn my home into a transient hotel then I should have the right to do so. Existing residents should abide by my rules under the current terms of their lease.

>Imagine the scenario if an AirBnBer does this with say a cigarette?

And what if an existing resident did that? Whats your point?

You completely leave out any actual reasoning to support your statements. A very shallow argument.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by evan_ on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:36AM (#5744372)
>> You can't, for example, run a tannery in your apartment > Why not?

Because tanning hides requires strong acid and a bunch of other chemicals and it will stink up the building and probably break some kind of regulation for residential spaces. If you happen to be a tanner and you disagree with it, pretend he said "Nuclear reactor" or "shooting range".

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by coldtea on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:40AM (#5744408)
>If I owned a building then I set the rules/laws.

He is talking about when you own an apartment, not the whole building.

And even when you own a building you still don't get to "set the rules/laws". There are tons of laws about what you can, and what you cannot do with and in your building. And in some areas, like e.g. Santa Fe IIRC, there can even be rules about what your building should look like.

Given those, starting your response with "your argument is completely shallow and void of reason.." is certainly ironic.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by aegiso on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:32AM (#5744337)
It was less an argument than a statement of fact. These are the laws.

If you want to argue what fundamental rights should or shouldn't be afforded to a property owner, HN probably isn't the place. This stuff has a long and complicated political history, which I humbly encourage you to learn more about.

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by greghinch on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @01:03PM (#5745030)
Laws which are not set in stone. The point is that services like Airbnb can be the impetus for changing the law to make more sense for modern times. When these laws were created, something like Airbnb was impossible, so how can you think they took the concept into account when crafting them?
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by scott_s on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:30AM (#5744315)
I think the tannery comment was a statement of fact: there are laws against using residential spaces for business purposes. If you own a building, you set the rules, but not the laws. Again, this is not a moral statement, but a recognition of how things work.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by ta26262 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:35AM (#5744364)
> > You can't, for example, run a tannery in your apartment

> Why not? Whats your argument?

Because it smells bad: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tanning#History

Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by Jun8 on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:28AM (#5744299)
Owning a building and an apartment are different things. If you own an apartment or condo, you are bound by the home owner's association rules, which can be pretty limiting.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 21, 2013 @11:31AM (#5744333)
Even if you own a building, you are still subject to zoning laws and other regulations like the fire code.
Re:NY official: Airbnb stay illegal; host fined $2,400 by beedogs on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @08:51AM (#5750380)
Ugh. libertarian alert.