News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by sologoub on Saturday May 18, 2013 @09:43PM (#5731377)
Funny you quote Ben Franklin, because in his day, the taxation looked very very differently than it does now: "The tax mechanisms used during first 150 years or so of U.S. tax history bears little resemblance to the current system of taxation. First, the U.S. Constitution restricted “direct” taxation by the federal government – meaning taxes directly on individuals. Instead, the federal government relied on indirect taxes including taxes on imports (tariffs) and excise taxes. Tariffs were the major source of U.S. government receipts from the beginning of the nation up to the early 1900s. For example, in 1800, custom duties comprised about 84% of government receipts." (Source: http://www.eoearth.org/article/History_of_taxation_in_the_Un...)

Government activity was also a tiny part of the economy: "Another important difference is the scale of government taxation and expenditures relative to the entire economy. Government spending is currently a major portion of the total U.S. economy – in 2002 government expenditures and investment at all levels comprised about 20% of total economic output. In the late 1800s government expenditures were responsible for only about 2% of national output (earlier data on national output are not available). " (Source: http://www.eoearth.org/article/History_of_taxation_in_the_Un...)

Another source of similar info: "But lets start with what was levied initially: 1. Excise taxes: First levied July 4, 1789, they accounted for 80-95% of all federal government revenue. Tariffs were the main source of government revenue through the 1800s. 2. Property tax: One of the earliest taxes imposed. In 1634, property taxes were assessed by the colonies. In 1796, 14 of the 15 states collected property tax. Delaware levied tax on income from property, but not on the property itself." (Source: http://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/2011/08/25/snaps...)

By looking at these taxes, seems like it would be a no-brainer to pay them. As a property owner, I will gladly pay to ensure I have security, safety and infrastructure around my property. Safe, clean areas with good schools tend to promote better property value growth. As a consumer, if I want something that is imported or otherwise taxed, I will probably still buy it. I may consume less of it due to the price. There has to be an exemption for essentials, but overall, if a Honda or BMW happens to cost 30% more because it's imported, whether I buy it or not will depend on whether it's 30% better than the alternative (if there is one).

What we have today is hardly what Ben Franklin was talking about. Today, those who consider themselves upper-middle to upper class are paying 10-22% (top 1% is around 28%). (Source: http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/07/15/the-real-...) For that, they don't get any type of real retirement guarantee, nor any health care guarantee, or even truly free education. Even the public schools cost money because the free services are bare minimum and do not include anything to do with sports or education outside of classrooms. In order to have any of those social safety nets kick in, those upper-middle class members have to hit financial ruin.

Also, funny math in the referenced Forbes article - 3 of the lowest quintile supposedly get money back that they did not earn... I haven't verified the math, but it's a bit disturbing that the tax system is being used as a means to directly redistribute wealth, and not actually provide services to all of society. Somehow in my mind, taking money from person A and directly giving it to person B strikes me as wrong. Taking money from person A and providing health care accessible to person A, B and C, does not result in the same emotional response for me, because person A actually gets to enjoy some of the benefit of this social good.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by rayiner on Saturday May 18, 2013 @11:20PM (#5731631)
Your argument is unresponsive to the quote.

Read the relevant part again: "All Property, indeed, except the Savage's temporary Cabin, his Bow, his Matchcoat, and other little Acquisitions, absolutely necessary for his Subsistence, seems to me to be the Creature of public Convention. Hence the Public has the Right of Regulating Descents, and all other Conveyances of Property, and even of limiting the Quantity and the Uses of it. All the Property that is necessary to a Man, for the Conservation of the Individual and the Propagation of the Species, is his natural Right, which none can justly deprive him of: But all Property superfluous to such purposes is the Property of the Publick, who, by their Laws, have created it, and who may therefore by other Laws dispose of it, whenever the Welfare of the Publick shall demand such Disposition."

What Franklin is saying is that property in surplus of what a man could acquire in his savage state is the result of society and therefore society is entitled to direct its disposition as it sees fit. The only moral limit to the amount of taxation, according to him, is the point at which society takes away what the man would have had in his savage state (i.e. he is made worse off by the existence of society and its taxes). Taxing someone making hundreds of thousands of dollars at 28% is of course nowhere near that limit.

Indeed, the change in the economy since Franklin's time cuts in the opposite direction, under his reasoning. Today, people have far more property in surplus of the subsistence level than they did in Franklin's time. Taxing a middle-class farmer of Franklin's time 75% might have taken him below the subsistence level, and have been immoral according to Franklin, but that would not be the case today with a middle-class programmer.

Of course it's probably not, from a utilitarian standpoint, the best idea to tax everyone to the subsistence limit, in a world where people can vote with their feet and countries can compete on taxation levels, but under Franklin's reasoning there is nothing morally wrong with even very high levels of taxes, as long as no one is worse off by virtue of the existence of society than they would have been in the savage state.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by dpatru on Saturday May 18, 2013 @11:59PM (#5731709)
The error in the reasoning of this excerpt is the assumption that the government can justly create any law that it wants, short of taking away a person's bare necessities. By this logic, slavery is fine as long as the slave has food, water, and shelter. The slave has no right to complain as long as he's better off than he would be in the most primitive state of nature.

The declaration of independence expresses a better view: we are endowed with liberty by our Creator and it is the role of government to protect that liberty. Under this view, government's actions can be judged.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by rayiner on Sunday May 19, 2013 @12:03AM (#5731722)
A slave's participation in the system is not voluntary. Your participation in society is voluntary (i.e. complain about taxes before you get rich--don't complain about the bargain after you've seen how it plays out!)

Also: if you assume God exists, then there is a moral framework that's externally imposed which makes arguments like these moot. But whose God are we talking about that creates these endowed rights? And where in the Bible does it talk about taxes?

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by mdturnerphys on Sunday May 19, 2013 @03:13AM (#5732134)
"And where in the Bible does it talk about taxes?"

Not really relevant to the discussion, but since you asked, here's what comes to mind:

- "Render unto Caesar that which is Caesar's"

- Matthew (as in "The Gospel of") had been a tax collector

- Jesus was born in Bethlehem because Joseph and Mary had to go there for a tax census

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by rayiner on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:52PM (#5731562)
"Also, funny math in the referenced Forbes article - 3 of the lowest quintile supposedly get money back that they did not earn."

What you "earn" (in the sense of deserve) in a modern integrated economy with extensive division of labor is mostly a fictional number. Apple makes $0 without people to assemble iPhones and iMacs, and it also makes $0 without the designers in Cupertino designing the products. Given that both groups' labor is necessary (in the causation sense) for Apple to earn any money at all, what allocation of the proceeds is appropriate between the groups? We create a particular distribution on the front end through our legal system, then adjust it on the back end also through our legal system. It's all equally arbitrary.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by yummyfajitas on Saturday May 18, 2013 @11:12PM (#5731618)
Given that both groups' labor is necessary (in the causation sense) for Apple to earn any money at all, what allocation of the proceeds is appropriate between the groups?

This is a disingenuous question. The money taken from the designers in Cupertino is not given to the (mostly Chinese) workers who assemble the phones.

Instead, it is given to people who did not contribute at all to the production of the iPhone (retirees, other non-working Americans, etc).

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by sologoub on Sunday May 19, 2013 @03:20PM (#5734071)
Not at all arbitrary - if the person from whom the share is being taken gets to participate equally in the benefit it then provides, I don't have a problem with that (so long as the redistribute still affords person A to have a better standard of living). What I see as wrong, is when person A pays the bill, but does not get to enjoy any of the benefits.

For example, take Sweden or Canada, there is a baseline health care system. Every citizen participates. Some pay more than others, but everyone is protected. Not so in US - you have to fall well below middle class in order to get any real help.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by dpatru on Saturday May 18, 2013 @11:28PM (#5731649)
What you earn depends on the market, the bargain you strike with other free people. It's not arbitrary.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by rayiner on Sunday May 19, 2013 @12:02AM (#5731718)
Those bargains only exist in the context of an arbitrary legal framework for enforcing them. As soon as you make certain actions illegal and certain ones not (e.g. Burning your boss's house down is illegal, firing someone just when they find out they have cancer is not) you've descended into the realm of arbitrary. There is nothing fundamental about setting wages using a peculiar flavor of free bargsining in which people are not really free (and you're never free if physical coercion is off the table). It's just how we do it.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by dpatru on Sunday May 19, 2013 @12:19AM (#5731756)
Rights are not arbitrary. Like the laws of physics, the gory details of what rights are may be hard to pin down exactly, but this doesn't mean that they don't exist. In the examples you gave, it's had to imagine a just society in which it would be OK to burn down another's house (violating physical property) or to be forced to hire someone or keep them employed (violating the right to contract.)
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by ralfn on Sunday May 19, 2013 @08:36AM (#5732701)
It is not arbituary, but it is mostly subjective. For example, here in Holland, an appearantly unjust country, you can not fire someone without cause after they've worked a steady year for you, in most but not all cases. This rule is the result of negotiations not between the individual employer and the employee, but between the brance of the economy, labour unions and the central government.

The problem with just having the employee and the employer come to a contract, is that the negotiation position is not on equal terms. And since the economy is here to serve us; not the other way around; we democratically elected this policy and have preferred it for almost half a century.

Your notion of rights, esspecially economic rights, as somehow inherent to reality as laws of nature, seems awfully short sighted. My neigbour is not free to have himself exploited, as it will affect my negotiation position as well.

And i honestly dont understand why so many Americans keep focusing on their rights to be exploited and abused in an economic sense. Of all inalienable rights i can think off, like autonomy of your own body (drugs? sex?) or freedom of speech (swearing?), that do not legally, socially or culturally apply to americans, the narrative limits itself to guns and slaves (exploitable workforce). The only two situations where it obviously does affect others, aand therefor the right can not be inherent.

I would not trade my rights for yours.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by rayiner on Sunday May 19, 2013 @10:42AM (#5732961)
Both physical property and right to contract are arbitrary. A hyena cannot sue in civil court if a lion violates his right of owning chattel property by divesting him of a carcass!
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by newbie12 on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:06PM (#5731434)
Well put, but the top income tax rate in the US is now nearly 40%. Plus there's 12.4% for Social Security (employer+employee but it is economically all your salary) and state income taxes. And if you invest anything after that, there's capital gains and dividend taxes.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by kip_ on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:42PM (#5731541)
Social Security taxes are only on the poor and middle class. If you make more than $113,700/year you're only out the $14,098.80

Source: http://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10003.pdf

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by Game_Ender on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:52PM (#5731563)
SSI is forced retirement savings program. You get out an amount proportional to what you pay in. It makes sense from that perspective to have a cap on the amount of income taxed, because they have cap on the benefits you can receive.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by hobs on Sunday May 19, 2013 @02:34AM (#5732061)
Except that it is a was originally designed as a widows benefit.

It is not about getting what you put in, it is about a safety net for old poor people who have no income, whether or not you agree that we should do that, to me it is clear that is what the goal of SSI clearly is.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by greghinch on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:16PM (#5731460)
I think the parent was referring to effective tax rate. Tax rates are applied in graded steps, so you will only pay 40% on income over a certain amount.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by jacques_chester on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:19PM (#5731467)
As your total income rises, your effective tax rate converges to the headline marginal rate.

(Granted this is a mathematical problem for millionaires, but still...)

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by dripton on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:57PM (#5731579)
Except that the truly rich tend to get most of their income from capital gains rather than wages and salaries, and there's a much lower rate for capital gains than for earned income. The "Buffet pays a lower tax rate than his secretary" problem.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by jacques_chester on Saturday May 18, 2013 @11:24PM (#5731639)
Quite, though the arrangements vary from place to place.

There's a lot distortion and unseemly outcomes that flow from having misaligned personal, capital gains and corporate tax rates.

Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by beefman on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:52PM (#5731565)
Unless you pay the AMT.
Re:Google insider exposes ‘immoral’ tax scam by beefman on Saturday May 18, 2013 @10:52PM (#5731560)
Total FICA is 15.3%. And don't forget sales tax (approaching 10% where I live, on purchases made with after-tax income).