Would sentiment among the public or pros have changed with the times?
In addition, the pilgrims from the Mayflower Pilgrims were not individuals fleeing religious persecution, they were given a "patent" or license by the King of England to settle Virginia, they were actually corporate recruits and given stock in the company in exchange for the risk they took to settle the New World with all assets (crops, livestock, ect...) to be owned by the company.
I am not sure if sentiment about taxation has ever changed over time, going to the Bible and Jesus was betrayed by Judas, a tax collector, the disciples vilified Judas before he became a disciple. Then again Jesus himself in relation to taxation may have said render unto Caesar what is Caesar's for ours is the Kingdom of heaven. Sure you have people like Warren Buffet publicly claiming they are willing to pay more, but the reality is nothing is currently stopping him from paying more, he does not need a law mandating him to pay more, he could take it upon himself to pay a flat tax of 35% across the board, but he does not, he still pays less than his secretary. Otherwise as of late the US has helped lower corporate taxation through the advent of the "election to be taxed as a small corporation" (S-election) and the more recent advent of the LLC, both of which which offer a single taxation structure down from the double taxation of your standard corporation.
There are practical reasons to tax more or less. But no moral ones. Without ordered civilization real wealth creation, beyond the savage subsistance level Franklin points out, is not possible and by virtue of that fact there are no moral limits on taxation.
"Property is the fruit of labor...property is desirable...is a positive good in the world. That some should be rich shows that others may become rich, and hence is just encouragement to industry and enterprise. Let not him who is houseless pull down the house of another; but let him labor diligently and build one for himself, thus by example assuring that his own shall be safe from violence when built." -- Abraham Lincoln
Regardless of whatever fine tuning is needed for long term sustainability, the solutions that have already allowed so many humans, with a good portion of them even having an excellent quality of life, are not possible through the naive exercise of brute force.
Of course, that all goes to reinforce the idea that complete independence and self-sufficiency are unrealistic—the planet can handle far more humans living in communities and cities than it can handle humans as hunter gatherers or humans farming for themselves without trade—and that no one today is successful independent of the economic environment where they find themselves, but it doesn't mean that there is something "unnatural" about people other than warlords having the most influence and power.
I didn't say it was "unnatural." Indeed, given history, you can say that it's the natural tendency of humans to organize into collectives. The term "state of nature" usually refers not to whatever humans do naturally, but rather the condition that exists prior to the creation of society.
I think guns and the 2nd Amendment help the "weak" much more than taxes.
But in a sense you're right. Under our system someone who might be a warlord is stuck bagging groceries. Whether he still benefits is a philosophical question. He may be better off in absolute terms in a society with modern medicine, even if he is a grocery bagger in that world. But psychological research shows that humans perceive prosperity in relative terms. Better to be a warlord in a primitive society than a peasant in a modern one.
Say that to workers who have to pay 40-50% of their tax & mandatory pension saving only to see it being swiped out by the government on the next recession.
Society functions by and large by public services which, whether you like it or not, need money; not magic. Every functional society has had tax collection in some form or another as a result.
There are communities that don't charge taxes for things, and they're heavily de-regulated as a result. They also heavily favor self-reliance and don't feature luxuries such as Police or Firefighters.
I had a more "radically libertarian" view before I "settled down" (bought real property, got married, made a child). I've increasingly bought into the idea that paying a fair fee for the services that society offers is a reasonable bargain. Paying the fee isn't the issue for me anymore. Rather, the uncivil political discourse and refusal to make reasonable compromises to deal with disagreements about how that money should be spent (and how government, defense, and social service programs can be sustainable) is what irks me. Living in the US makes me feel like a large part of my taxes are nothing but throwing good money after bad (even though I know it's really not as bad as I think it is).
...to
"No. Taxes are a service fee paid as agreed to in your social contract (which you signed by participating in said society). If you disagree with this contract, you're free to move elsewhere that is a. Devoid of taxes (good luck) or b. Devoid of society."
...but then proceed to say:
" Paying the fee isn't the issue for me anymore. Rather, the uncivil political discourse and refusal to make reasonable compromises to deal with disagreements about how that money should be spent (and how government, defense, and social service programs can be sustainable) is what irks me."
...which I actually agree very much with.
The "If you disagree with this contract, you're free to move elsewhere" argument offends me greatly, my interpretation of that is that the author believes they hold the ultimate final wisdom on the subject, and you either take it, or you leave.
I fully agree that there should be some taxes, and different people should pay different amounts (from each according to his ability) not so much because it is "right", but because it is "wise", it is (I think) the best way to structure a society to maximize happiness (not the right word really). I believe it is best that those who are more able are forced to pay more (in absolute numbers, if not necessarily percentage, but maybe that too), but I also believe the people who are on the other side of that deal should also be made (somehow) to know how good they actually have it, and it wouldn't hurt them to maybe say "thanks" now and then.
Now, imho money in society is largely ending up in the pockets of people who in no way actually earned it, so some of the above doesn't apply. I don't think someone making minimum wage should be saying thanks to a Wall Street banker for example. I think money "should" be flowing to people who genuinely innovate to raise the standard living of his fellow man, and citizens of the world. I'm thinking innovations in manufacturing, distribution, medical & health advancements, some forms of software, etc. Things that make a real difference.
I also happen to feel/guess that the real, righteous innovators who are really improving the world, probably would be very ok with getting just "very rich" despite how much they've given the world, whereas many of the recipients of the big money flows today (who in very many cases have really done nothing beneficial for the world, often the opposite even), want to keep all of their money, and will do almost anything to keep it, things that they very well know are morally wrong, by most any definition.
The problem is, who is wise enough to make these decisions, of what is the right amount of taxation, what is the right amount of privatization vs socialization, etc. I think we need some social enlightenment, and I don't see that happening any time soon. We've had great experiments of different models in different countries throughout the world, I think we have plenty data for wise open minded people to make a very accurate judgement in some cases. But then, it is also extremely culturally driven, and with current immigration and reproduction rates around the world, I think the makeup of societies are now changing so quickly, that the "best" solution that would have worked in a particular region 20 or even 10 years ago, might now be nowhere close to the best solution. For example: I grew up in a small, close knit community, where everyone knew everyone. There were always some layabout people and families who were always sucking on the public teat, but that's just the way it was, and no one really got overly upset. But if multiple families like this start moving into my neighborhood from other countries, and they don't seem particularly interested in the community or my culture, and choose to associate only amongst themselves, while still helping themselves to the rich social programs that are largely a product of lifetimes of extremely hard work and sacrifice of my ancestors, well, I'm not so ok with that.
I'm not sure what my point is really. I think on one hand, our technology and highly automated manufacturing allows us to get 75% of everything else wrong and still have a high and extremely widespread standard of living. On the other hand, I think if we could get that other 75% down to around 25%, perhaps the wealth could be spread around more fairly (one class who's getting royally screwed is the current generation of workers in Chinese factories) without everyone getting bent out of shape, and we could perhaps have some leftover to work on some of the really important problems in the world, that can almost only be solved by a socialized effort.
I encourage people to donate to their local volunteer fire and ambulance services for this very reason. Also, if your local police are having a fundraiser, you should consider helping. You can side-step the inefficiencies of government distribution (and the bickering) if you take an active role in directly funding these essential services.
Most of these should also be tax-deductible so you're just basically side-stepping the middle-man (the bureaucracy) and making sure the money is going where it's needed directly.
I mean, honestly, considering how many people are clustered together these days, we're just not equipped to deal with the chaos that will come about if there was no social infrastructure. These things run on tax money.
There's nothing inherently wrong with being libertarian (after all, the root "liberty" is in there). I'm just very uncomfortable with the casual disregard for all authority, order and in many cases, common sense, that some folks who claim to be libertarian tend to espouse. Last I checked being libertarian required a great deal of common sense, a sense of fairness and above all else, order and self-control.
Virtually none of the tax money goes to help the downtrodden or to build necessary infrastructure.
As a property owner you are getting big tax breaks and so your support has been bought.
That's not really true. A large part of your taxes goes to the military, but that's not co-extensive with the Iraq and Afghanistan war. That money goes towards maintaining the largest most powerful military in the world, enabling the U.S. to continue to be the supreme world power. If you don't think that primacy is directly relevant to your quality of life as an American (a people who as a category consume a disproportionate share of the world's resources relative even to other highly developed countries), I'm not sure what to tell you.
The quality of life of a lot of countries is influenced by the American military, both good and bad.
And actually, the US doesn't spend nearly what most people think it does, as a percentage of GDP.
There are of course other sides to the contract. Where I'm from one of the other sides is inflation-adjusted pensions. I work just like everybody else did, future and past. Yet I do not have the right to inflation adjusted pensions anymore.
Now that contract, when I read it at age 20, really did not seem to leave any leeway to cancel them, but of course the state is sovereign. No matter how (legally) solid a promise or contract, the state is under no obligation to execute it (not even for people who are current pensioners, and have very little power in the current system. The ones that trusted the government to hold up it's end of the bargain got screwed. Some got screwed, aged 70 or so, and became homeless. I knew one of those).
That event has opened my eyes. What I'm paying taxes for, ~40% goes to paying pension, both of which are getting canceled. Another 50%+ goes to national health insurance and unemployment insurance (I'm in Europe), and in Brussels it is obvious that this part of the system is collapsing, but is also begin used as "bread and circuses" for most of the inner-city population, leading to fast growth. People blame immigration for this, and while that's a significant chunk, the root of the problem is that low-paying jobs are a lot worse than unemployment to any rational person. They're much more likely to demand overtime and extra work than high-paying ones, and the commute costs money, and the whole thing is just so much more stressful than actually doing something.
So there's 2 factors here that I find most offensive about taxes. First, I'm being held to tax law, but the government is not being held to it's promises (like my pension). Second, the government has created a feedback loop that uses my taxes and makes people dependent, brought the whole thing close to the breaking point, and expects me to pay for it.
Screw them. This is not rational on any level. Sorry. I do not volunteer my time on one-sided contracts, where the other side has zero intention to fulfill it's end of the bargain. Whatever I can do to lower my taxes, I do. And I don't consider it morally dubious even. Whatever one can do to make this bread-circus system collapse faster should be done, for the longer it takes the bigger the suffering will be.
It isn't all or nothing, we can have low, honest taxes and a decent society with a more vibrant private sphere.
Your point is valid in an idealized world where taxation is fair and spending transparent. But in today's world progressive taxation is simply a tool to extort complacency from the masses and allow the powerful to start costly wars using terms like "evil" and "evildoers" rather than having to make a rational cost/benefit analysis.
> Spending must be transparent. No argument here.
> Wars of aggression (already illegal) must stop.
> War on drugs, and other likewise stupid expenditures must stop
(slow, but getting there)
These will only change when politicians start representing the people that voted them into office. Remember that: Only the people that voted them into office. Not those who hold the majority sentiment. The two groups aren't necessarily the same.This is what Plato has Socrates argue in Crito, but it is bullshit outside of perhaps a limited few scenarios (such as: if you are an older adult with the capacity to be politically aware, the means to remove yourself, and the emotional hardening or ideological emphasis necessary to abandon your friends and family.... in other words, if you are Socrates.) Those who actually have the ability to do as you implicitly suggest they should if they do not consent are a very small minority.
"If you don't like it, leave it" is the cry of those who are in privileged positions in society and think that those below them should suck it up and deal with it.
(Of course "leave" also becomes difficult for the extremely wealthy since, unlike in Athens at the time ("Any one who does not like us and the city, and who wants to emigrate to a colony or to any other city, may go where he likes, retaining his property."), we have "exit tax" for those people. These few people must be taxed in order to opt-out of being taxed.)
We can deal with Uncle Sam's cut and how it's spent with the ballot box.
I would caution, however, too many people vote candidates into office on only one or two of their pet issues. I understand no one will find a candidate they agree with 100%, but there's a lot more to a person than just taxes, just guns or just environment etc... This has to change.
People need to look at what they're really getting themselves into by voting for the right people after thinking very carefully and objectively. And of course on more than one or two issues.
"Stealing" is "stealing". "Taxes" are not "stealing". "Taxes" are what is used to pay for the services used by and benefit the people. Money collected under whatever other label you give that is not used for these purposes is "stealing".
You're saying that if legal money collection benefits society it is "tax", but if it does not benefit society it is "stealing"? Sure, if you split the words that denote legal money collection into these two forms, then tax is not theft. I simply define tax as legal money collection.
I'm not anti-tax, btw, but neither do I subscribe to the view that just because a government passes a particular money collection law that it's a just law.
But I don't think it's hair-splitting to call the collection of funds for the benefit of society (and actually used for societal projects) taxes and those collected to stuff the coffers of politicians and their cronies as stealing.
In other governments, where order is kept at the end of a barrel rather than with a vote, I imagine stealing takes place quite flagrantly, but then the rest of the wouldn't call that a "tax" at all (secretly, those citizens would also call that stealing).
Government activity was also a tiny part of the economy: "Another important difference is the scale of government taxation and expenditures relative to the entire economy. Government spending is currently a major portion of the total U.S. economy – in 2002 government expenditures and investment at all levels comprised about 20% of total economic output. In the late 1800s government expenditures were responsible for only about 2% of national output (earlier data on national output are not available). " (Source: http://www.eoearth.org/article/History_of_taxation_in_the_Un...)
Another source of similar info: "But lets start with what was levied initially: 1. Excise taxes: First levied July 4, 1789, they accounted for 80-95% of all federal government revenue. Tariffs were the main source of government revenue through the 1800s. 2. Property tax: One of the earliest taxes imposed. In 1634, property taxes were assessed by the colonies. In 1796, 14 of the 15 states collected property tax. Delaware levied tax on income from property, but not on the property itself." (Source: http://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/2011/08/25/snaps...)
By looking at these taxes, seems like it would be a no-brainer to pay them. As a property owner, I will gladly pay to ensure I have security, safety and infrastructure around my property. Safe, clean areas with good schools tend to promote better property value growth. As a consumer, if I want something that is imported or otherwise taxed, I will probably still buy it. I may consume less of it due to the price. There has to be an exemption for essentials, but overall, if a Honda or BMW happens to cost 30% more because it's imported, whether I buy it or not will depend on whether it's 30% better than the alternative (if there is one).
What we have today is hardly what Ben Franklin was talking about. Today, those who consider themselves upper-middle to upper class are paying 10-22% (top 1% is around 28%). (Source: http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/07/15/the-real-...) For that, they don't get any type of real retirement guarantee, nor any health care guarantee, or even truly free education. Even the public schools cost money because the free services are bare minimum and do not include anything to do with sports or education outside of classrooms. In order to have any of those social safety nets kick in, those upper-middle class members have to hit financial ruin.
Also, funny math in the referenced Forbes article - 3 of the lowest quintile supposedly get money back that they did not earn... I haven't verified the math, but it's a bit disturbing that the tax system is being used as a means to directly redistribute wealth, and not actually provide services to all of society. Somehow in my mind, taking money from person A and directly giving it to person B strikes me as wrong. Taking money from person A and providing health care accessible to person A, B and C, does not result in the same emotional response for me, because person A actually gets to enjoy some of the benefit of this social good.
Read the relevant part again: "All Property, indeed, except the Savage's temporary Cabin, his Bow, his Matchcoat, and other little Acquisitions, absolutely necessary for his Subsistence, seems to me to be the Creature of public Convention. Hence the Public has the Right of Regulating Descents, and all other Conveyances of Property, and even of limiting the Quantity and the Uses of it. All the Property that is necessary to a Man, for the Conservation of the Individual and the Propagation of the Species, is his natural Right, which none can justly deprive him of: But all Property superfluous to such purposes is the Property of the Publick, who, by their Laws, have created it, and who may therefore by other Laws dispose of it, whenever the Welfare of the Publick shall demand such Disposition."
What Franklin is saying is that property in surplus of what a man could acquire in his savage state is the result of society and therefore society is entitled to direct its disposition as it sees fit. The only moral limit to the amount of taxation, according to him, is the point at which society takes away what the man would have had in his savage state (i.e. he is made worse off by the existence of society and its taxes). Taxing someone making hundreds of thousands of dollars at 28% is of course nowhere near that limit.
Indeed, the change in the economy since Franklin's time cuts in the opposite direction, under his reasoning. Today, people have far more property in surplus of the subsistence level than they did in Franklin's time. Taxing a middle-class farmer of Franklin's time 75% might have taken him below the subsistence level, and have been immoral according to Franklin, but that would not be the case today with a middle-class programmer.
Of course it's probably not, from a utilitarian standpoint, the best idea to tax everyone to the subsistence limit, in a world where people can vote with their feet and countries can compete on taxation levels, but under Franklin's reasoning there is nothing morally wrong with even very high levels of taxes, as long as no one is worse off by virtue of the existence of society than they would have been in the savage state.
The declaration of independence expresses a better view: we are endowed with liberty by our Creator and it is the role of government to protect that liberty. Under this view, government's actions can be judged.
Also: if you assume God exists, then there is a moral framework that's externally imposed which makes arguments like these moot. But whose God are we talking about that creates these endowed rights? And where in the Bible does it talk about taxes?
Not really relevant to the discussion, but since you asked, here's what comes to mind:
- "Render unto Caesar that which is Caesar's"
- Matthew (as in "The Gospel of") had been a tax collector
- Jesus was born in Bethlehem because Joseph and Mary had to go there for a tax census
What you "earn" (in the sense of deserve) in a modern integrated economy with extensive division of labor is mostly a fictional number. Apple makes $0 without people to assemble iPhones and iMacs, and it also makes $0 without the designers in Cupertino designing the products. Given that both groups' labor is necessary (in the causation sense) for Apple to earn any money at all, what allocation of the proceeds is appropriate between the groups? We create a particular distribution on the front end through our legal system, then adjust it on the back end also through our legal system. It's all equally arbitrary.
This is a disingenuous question. The money taken from the designers in Cupertino is not given to the (mostly Chinese) workers who assemble the phones.
Instead, it is given to people who did not contribute at all to the production of the iPhone (retirees, other non-working Americans, etc).
For example, take Sweden or Canada, there is a baseline health care system. Every citizen participates. Some pay more than others, but everyone is protected. Not so in US - you have to fall well below middle class in order to get any real help.
The problem with just having the employee and the employer come to a contract, is that the negotiation position is not on equal terms. And since the economy is here to serve us; not the other way around; we democratically elected this policy and have preferred it for almost half a century.
Your notion of rights, esspecially economic rights, as somehow inherent to reality as laws of nature, seems awfully short sighted. My neigbour is not free to have himself exploited, as it will affect my negotiation position as well.
And i honestly dont understand why so many Americans keep focusing on their rights to be exploited and abused in an economic sense. Of all inalienable rights i can think off, like autonomy of your own body (drugs? sex?) or freedom of speech (swearing?), that do not legally, socially or culturally apply to americans, the narrative limits itself to guns and slaves (exploitable workforce). The only two situations where it obviously does affect others, aand therefor the right can not be inherent.
I would not trade my rights for yours.
It is not about getting what you put in, it is about a safety net for old poor people who have no income, whether or not you agree that we should do that, to me it is clear that is what the goal of SSI clearly is.
(Granted this is a mathematical problem for millionaires, but still...)
There's a lot distortion and unseemly outcomes that flow from having misaligned personal, capital gains and corporate tax rates.
"The Remissness of our People in Paying Taxes is highly blameable; the Unwillingness to pay them is still more so. I see, in some Resolutions of Town Meetings, a Remonstrance against giving Congress a Power to take, as they call it, the People's Money out of their Pockets, tho' only to pay the Interest and Principal of Debts duly contracted. They seem to mistake the Point. Money, justly due from the People, is their Creditors' Money, and no longer the Money of the People, who, if they withold it, should be compell'd to pay by some Law.
"All Property, indeed, except the Savage's temporary Cabin, his Bow, his Matchcoat, and other little Acquisitions, absolutely necessary for his Subsistence, seems to me to be the Creature of public Convention. Hence the Public has the Right of Regulating Descents, and all other Conveyances of Property, and even of limiting the Quantity and the Uses of it. All the Property that is necessary to a Man, for the Conservation of the Individual and the Propagation of the Species, is his natural Right, which none can justly deprive him of: But all Property superfluous to such purposes is the Property of the Publick, who, by their Laws, have created it, and who may therefore by other Laws dispose of it, whenever the Welfare of the Publick shall demand such Disposition. He that does not like civil Society on these Terms, let him retire and live among Savages. He can have no right to the benefits of Society, who will not pay his Club towards the Support of it.
That being said I think it's a problem that needs to be fixed in the culture and governance of a people, not in Google itself, since attempting to assign any civic duty to a multinational is probably laughable. Singling out Google probably doesn't do too much good, except maybe to make people think of "favorite company X"'s role in society.