You can get a Garmin GPS watch for about $100. Less than a Pebble, and you can take it swimming. I wouldn't recommend taking your phone in the pool. :) RunKeeper integration is cool, and handy for those that already use it (or for those that already carry a phone while running, which I don't). But I'm not ditching my Garmin FR610 just yet.
As for the unpairing problem, if it happens then I can never trust it. I had that happen a lot with my iPhone, but not with a Nexus running Android. Looks like a bug in iOS, but regardless of fault I can't trust it to keep me from missing phone calls or an email message when using iOS.
These things will get worked out eventually, but for now I view as a kind of neat, if not entirely reliable, gadget that happens to tell time. But that's just my use case, YMMV.
I really don't have many complaints. The battery life is fine but then again I charge it every night on my nightstand. The construction is great and I especially appreciate the fact that I can swim with it on. I replaced the watch band with one I liked better so I'm glad I was able to do that.
I have had the watch become unpaired from my iPhone a couple times which is bad news since I turned off all sounds and vibrations on my phone since receiving my Pebble. But it hasn't happened for a long time now.
I'm excited to start developing apps for it, too. The two-way messaging they just added to the SDK is going to open up a world of possibilities.
All in all, I'm a very satisfied backer so far.