News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by steve19 on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:00AM (#5684542)
It is not that they don't understand how the internet works, but legally you cannot export blueprints about weapons without an export license. The State Department is absolutely correct. Blueprints of weapons cannot be exported. Everyone in the firearm/defense industry knows this.

The ITAR rules are even worse for some types of equipment. For example it is a felony to allow a foreigners (non-citizens or non-green card holders) to look through high-end (Gen III) night vision equipment. Guns shops all over the country unwittingly violate this rule every day. Technical discussions of night vision equipment on a forums accessible from foreigners is also illegal.

Edit: Also worth pointing out that those model files are also being hosted on GitHub [0]

[0] https://github.com/maduce/defcad-repo

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by btilly on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:24AM (#5684619)
Wow. According to the government's theories, I as a dual citizen of the USA and Canada am not allowed access to this stuff because for ITAR purposes I count as a Canadian national.

I wonder whether under the 14th they actually have the right to restrict my 2nd amendment rights in this way. That's in addition to the obvious 1st amendment issues.

(I somehow thought that the USA lost The USA vs the Progressive but Wikipedia corrected me that the case was dropped after it was obviously moot.)

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by Radix_ on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:43AM (#5684687)
Is that really the case? I'd heard that the US did not technically recognize dual citizenship but other nations do. So wouldn't you technically be just a US citizen as far as the US is concerned?
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by btilly on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:12AM (#5684747)
That is really the case. Under international law, all "dual citizen" means is that there are two countries whose national laws consider you a citizen. The USA used to have laws against retaining your citizenship if you took out another one, but they kept losing in the Supreme Court, so stopped trying to enforce them in 1990. (I took out Canadian citizenship less than 3 months after that policy change.)

According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Traffic_in_Arms_R... that makes me a foreign national (despite also being a US citizen) which causes ITAR to apply to me.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by glenra on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:09AM (#5684579)
> legally you cannot export blueprints about weapons without an export license.

Wow. That seems incredibly stupid. How did this manage to survive first amendment challenges? Or has it not been tested?

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by fianchetto on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:16AM (#5684595)
> How did this manage to survive first amendment challenges?

This goes back to what Phil Zimmerman said about ITAR and such almost 20 years ago when they threw it at him for PGP:

"The Government has made it illegal in many cases to export good cryptographic technology, and that may include PGP. This is determined by volatile State Department policies, not fixed laws."

This has nothing to do with law and everything to do with those same volatile policies a generation later.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by adastra on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:55AM (#5684717)
ITAR, like all US federal regulations codified in the CFR, have the full force and effect of the law. See the first couple paragraphs here for further explanation: http://library.law.unh.edu/AdminLaw

How do you know if something is subject to ITAR? The State Department has a big list. It's called the US Munitions List (USML). At the time Zimmerman said that, PGP probably wasn't on the list. But I assure you, blueprints of guns are absolutely on the list.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by fianchetto on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:18AM (#5684761)
> At the time Zimmerman said that, PGP probably wasn't on the list.

It wasn't on the list yet, proving his point about volatility.

> full force and effect of the law.

All decrees, from Hammurabi onward, have the same qualities.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by mgarfias on Friday May 10, 2013 @02:41AM (#5684944)
What's really funny is that 2d blueprints of the m16 and others exist and are readily accessible. Also, the army has published in the past various handbooks for insurrection. The "improvised munitions handbook" comes to mind.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by olympus on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:23AM (#5684614)
The law's main reason for existing isn't really about handguns, but that doesn't stop it for being applied to them. I don't think the U.S. government is really all that concerned about a single shot pistol, but someone got all in a tizzy about it and decided that it should be shut down before it becomes a problem (not that I agree with that thinking).

These export controls primarily exist to keep our advanced military technology out of enemy hands. I am not a lawyer, but I am reasonably certain that these laws would be upheld by the courts. Even though the first amendment promises free speech, the Supreme Court has said that there are some things you still aren't allowed to say, like "Fire!" in a movie theater. Things that could harm public safety, such as distributing weapons plans, are not protected under the first amendment.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by jlgreco on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:29AM (#5684638)
> Even though the first amendment promises free speech, the Supreme Court has said that there are some things you still aren't allowed to say, like "Fire!" in a movie theater. Things that could harm public safety, such as distributing weapons plans, are not protected under the first amendment.

The "clear and present danger" thing has not been true for many decades now. The current standard is if the speaker intends to cause imminent lawless behaviour.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imminent_lawless_action

Of course the case where the "fire in a movie theater" thing first came up was about a war protester telling people that the draft was unconstitutional...

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by olympus on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:42AM (#5684682)
Thanks for filling me in, jlgreco. However, I still don't think any part of ITAR or AECA is going down because of this.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by nness on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:14AM (#5684591)
My knowledge is quite basic on the subject, but how would this be a first amendment issue?
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by ctdonath on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:31AM (#5684644)
Nobody doubts the shutdown is to prevent citizens from seeing the files, not foreigners. Ergo, censorship.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by hawleyal on Friday May 10, 2013 @09:09AM (#5685944)
It's censorship either way.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by glenra on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:13PM (#5687010)
In most contexts we interpret "speech" quite broadly. Speech is the transmission of information. Blueprints consist of information structured in a particular meticulous way which can be beautiful as well as practical and informative. Novels and paintings also fit that description. A painting could show how a bomb is constructed. A novel could explain how to commit a crime.

So I'm surprised public-domain blueprints aren't already considered "speech" as a matter of settled law. In the case of commercial blueprints I suppose I could imagine an argument for considering them "proprietary information", but in this case where the producer wants the information to get out and is not claiming copyright over it...posting a blueprint on the web is like posting a flyer on a telephone pole. It's a speech act. The federal government isn't generally allowed to prohibit speech acts.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by hawleyal on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:23AM (#5684613)
How is censorship of speech a violation of freedom of speech? AYFKM
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by tks2103 on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:50AM (#5684708)
don't beg the question.

there's no need for cursing.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by hawleyal on Friday May 10, 2013 @09:18AM (#5685988)
That is not what "beg the question" means. Begging the question refers to a form of argument in which the final conclusion was earlier presented as a given. That is, a circular argument.

I restated the question, to highlight the absurdity of it. That is not begging the question.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by tks2103 on Friday May 10, 2013 @11:37AM (#5686774)
restating the thread:

steve19: 'legally you cannot export blueprints about weapons without an export license'

glenra: 'how did this manage to survive first amendment challenges?'

nness: 'how would this be a first amendment issue?'

in nness's comment, i am assuming 'this' is 'exporting blueprints about weapons without an export license'

in other words: 'how would exporting blueprints about weapons without an export license be a first amendment issue?'

you restated this as: 'how is censorship of speech a violation of freedom of speech?' first amendment issue very easily transforms to freedom of speech, but 'exporting blueprints about weapons' does not easily transform to 'censorship of speech'

nness question is essentially 'how does exporting weapon blueprints relate to freedom of speech?' it is not an absurd question.

you responded by equating 'exporting weapon blueprints' with 'censoring speech' with no argument, presupposing the conclusion from the question. ergo, begging the question.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by hawleyal on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:17AM (#5684596)
TIL the internet constitutes import/export from country to country.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by maratd on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:56AM (#5684720)
> The State Department is absolutely correct.

The State Department is legally correct and morally bankrupt. What a disgusting restriction on my first amendment rights.

Whatever I create or modify is my right to distribute as I see fit, regardless of what I created. Period. There's an absolute for you.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by carbocation on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:39AM (#5684812)
> Whatever I create or modify is my right to distribute as I see fit, regardless of what I created. Period. There's an absolute for you.

This is a silly thing to say. Especially in a thread about weapons. Especially to say so in an "absolute" way.

You absolutely don't have the right to distribute chemical, biological, nuclear, or even some conventional weapons. Nor should you. I'm drawn to this extreme list because of your "absolute" assertion.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by skrebbel on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:33AM (#5684798)
That would render any country with any sort of weapons/alcohol/drugs control "morally bankrupt". So either I misunderstand your comment, or you're a libertarian nutcase(1) trying to hijack this thread.

(1) for the easily insulted, i do not imply that all libertarians are nutcases, but rather that libertarian nutcases are nutcases.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by maratd on Friday May 10, 2013 @04:53AM (#5685255)
> So either I misunderstand your comment, or you're a libertarian nutcase(1) trying to hijack this thread.

Nope, you didn't misunderstand. You're just a controlling jackass.

See? I can call people names too.

Why don't you try using your head and make a cogent argument for restricting an individual's right to create and distribute CAD files, hmm?

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by angersock on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:16AM (#5684594)
I was originally going to rage a bunch about the government here, but then I saw they were invoking ITAR, and I was like "yeah, okay, that is the one card they could've played that I wouldn't have complained about".

Then again, it's not like blueprints for single-shot infantry weapons are exactly the key to America's military supremacy, the loss of which will result in the final storming of our golden cities by barbarous hordes.

Were somebody to post up a mod of their RepRap fabbing an explosive lens or something, now that would be interesting to watch the banhammer on.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by jlgreco on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:19AM (#5684601)
> Were somebody to post up a mod of their RepRap fabbing an explosive lens or something, now that would be interesting to watch the banhammer on.

I am not exactly sure what it is referring to, but the State Department's letter includes mention of a data file for a "125mm BK-14M high-explosive anti-tank warhead".

Maybe that is a model for a mold for warheads? I don't think anyone has a printer printing with high-explosives yet.

Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by angersock on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:22AM (#5684609)
I'm not going to lie--if they did, that would be really cool.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by malandrew on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:42AM (#5684822)
What is an explosive lens? (TBH, I'd google it, but knowing how the US is becoming, I feel more comfortable voicing my curiosity here, where my intents are obvious, then via search where some automated tool could flag my curiosity as intent.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by mgarfias on Friday May 10, 2013 @02:38AM (#5684932)
Not an expert here, but I believe it's the bit of a nuclear warhead that squashes the plutonium pit and causes it to go critical.
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by tlrobinson on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:47AM (#5684700)
Is this situation like crypto in the 90's where you just had to have an agreement stating you were a US citizen (or whatever), and a checkbox, then it was all ok, or do you have to actively verify they're a US citizen?
Re:State Department Demands 3-D Gun Blueprints Be Removed by baddox on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:05AM (#5684733)
Enforcing a stupid law doesn't make it any less stupid.