News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by onemorepassword on Thursday May 09, 2013 @01:10PM (#5681597)
> When it comes to privacy and PII, Google holds itself to an extremely high standard.

With all due respect, but you've gotta joking.

Google doesn't even hold itself to the standards set by the laws in countries it operates in. Laws that are for now still full of loopholes Google happily exploits with zero restraint, despite knowing full well (not in the last place because they've been warned on a regular basis) that this at the very least violates the intent of those privacy laws.

Also, Google has been actively lobbying against privacy protection laws in the EU for several years now.

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by dbrian on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:19PM (#5682078)
Considering that, for years, Facebook had a universal password that would log you into anyone's account, I'd say that Google's standards are significantly higher than other players in the social sphere.

http://therumpus.net/2010/01/conversations-about-the-interne...

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by grimman on Friday May 10, 2013 @02:55AM (#5684987)
This is a non-argument. Just because other actors do certain things does not excuse ANYTHING. Period.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by vsl on Friday May 10, 2013 @04:32AM (#5685205)
Well, the claim was that Google's standard is higher than that of (some) other actors, so the behavior of the other actors is kind of directly relevant...
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by dmbass on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:09AM (#5684576)
What exactly makes you think Google doesn't have this feature?
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by rajivm on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:16AM (#5684756)
From my experience interning twice at Google, I was very impressed by their standard for privacy and the protections they had put in place. They have teams dedicated to just researching ways to improve information security.

Two projects I found fascinating: 1) A system that analyses all attempts and actual accesses to user data by employees (this access it self was very regulated on a need-only basis), determining whether the given user that was accessed falls somewhere within the employee's likely social graph, and flagging anything suspicious to their security team. So if an employee tried to view their ex's info, or their friend's roommates info, etc. the system would auto-flag them and an investigation would likely result in that employee being immediately terminated.

2) Much of Google's data is accessible by many production services. This is a security weakness, however, there was a project to make the data layer enforce security constraints so that applications could only access data relavent to them, and additionally also enforcing security on a user-level (so an app could only access that user's data if it had an access token for that user). Mind you, this is not even limiting admin access, this is actually preventing the code from accessing the data even if the app's built-in security features fail.

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by pyre on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:18PM (#5682068)

  | Also, Google has been actively lobbying
  | against privacy protection laws in the EU
  | for several years now.
Don't some of those same laws have data retention requirements[1] or are those separate laws?

[1] Could be a requirement or a limitation. If your company keeps data indefinitely, then maybe a law saying, "everyone keeps records 2 years, then destroys them" is a limitation. On the other hand, if you retain no information, then it's an extra burden, and an erosion of privacy.

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by smsm42 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @01:31PM (#5681741)
Not all laws in all countries are worth holding oneself to. For example, Russia has official internet censorship, does it mean Google should now support censorship too because some country has laws about that?
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by rhizome on Thursday May 09, 2013 @01:52PM (#5681878)
By what legal standard should Google be held, then? Are you really advocating the multinational/Internet companies pick and choose what laws they follow according to their own needs and whims?
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by smsm42 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:34PM (#5682161)
I'm not advocating anything like that. I'm saying before criticizing Google for trying to avoid or change the laws, it may be useful to consider if these laws are actually good idea. If they are not, all props to Google for trying to circumvent or repeal them.

I do not see why one needs "legal standard" to evaluate somebody's actions. Why not use the standard that is supposed to be the base for the legal standard instead? If in some country it is illegal to publish links that the government thinks are inappropriate, and Google doesn't like it - why would we consider Google being in the wrong?

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by rhizome on Thursday May 09, 2013 @03:03PM (#5682319)
You need a legal standard because the Russian censorship you describe is a matter of existing law. Also, note Yahoo's experiences with France.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by smsm42 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @03:54PM (#5682557)
It is a matter of law - means the government wants to enforce it. But why I have to agree with it? I do not have any obligation to respect anything the government of Russia or Iran does.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by rhizome on Thursday May 09, 2013 @04:09PM (#5682631)
If you're doing business there, you do. If you're not, then let their firewall or whatever deal with it, but I doubt that's Google's situation.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by danenania on Friday May 10, 2013 @01:53AM (#5684842)
To the extent that it is feasible, we should follow moral and ethical principles, not laws.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by oillio on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:38PM (#5682186)
In an online chat discussion? Google should be held to the standards of decency described by the poster himself.

Stating, "Google is not good at privacy because they violate some law and I like that law." Is a perfectly valid argument.

Stating, "Google is bad because it doesn't follow a privacy law I won't describe, in a random country I won't name." Does not advance the conversation in any meaniful way.

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by RestlessMind on Thursday May 09, 2013 @04:34PM (#5682782)
Whats wrong with lobbying against the laws which you think are bad? In a democratic process, you can (and do) end up with laws which are crappy/outdated/unjust. Lobbying is a legitimate way to tackle this problem.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by LaGrange on Friday May 10, 2013 @10:04AM (#5686206)
s/bad/unprofitable for a corporate entity/

Fixed that for you.

Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by RestlessMind on Thursday May 16, 2013 @01:58PM (#5719964)
You just made my general point in a specific use case. Anyone (individuals, groups of individuals, corporate entities...) should have freedom to voice against laws they don't like.
Re:LinkedIn: The Creepiest Social Network by davorak on Thursday May 09, 2013 @11:25PM (#5684406)
Could you provide some examples and some links if possible. I do not know the specifics of what you are talking about.