It looks like he's equating "pass through" transactions with being a (unlicensed) Money Transfer Agent.
Hypothetically, If I was going to start a PayPal alternative, I would figure out a way to stay somewhat compliant.
If that fails, seek a declarative judgement against XYZ agency to get legal clarification, without dragging all the VCs, Angels and unrelated companies into the case.
Not seeing that this has been date stamped by the court...yet. Typically you scribd the stamped copy so you know it has been filed.
Would a Travel Agent be called a money transmitter?
As someone asking someone else who seems to know more about this than I, does this lawsuit have legs to stand on? [Edit: seemed to be answered here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5677731]
Well maybe this presents the perfect opportunity for these VC and portfolio companies to retreat offshore to the tech seastead they created for their very own special SEZ (semi-jokingly).
This seems crazy.
There is a lot of literature on the topic; some pieces even establish a tie between that notion and the most recent banking crises and scandals. For example, stock options are not just one step removed from currency, but at least two or more.
Interesting stuff indeed.
AFAIK, the only reason these companies would use a credit system is so that people need to buy credits in bulk, reducing the hit received from processing credit card transactions.
http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/christ-what-an-asshole
Except, unfortunately, without notably increasing the humor value, so far.
(1) there are lots of little annoying laws related to money transmitters that makes it very difficult to get new payment stuff off the ground
(2) If you have deep pockets and good lawyers you can pretty much ignore these laws
I strongly suspect that the correct solution is to change the laws, but that this is also an even greater pain in the ass than protecting yourself with highly paid lawyers, esp. since relevant laws vary significantly from state to state. What exactly Greenspan is attempting to prove here is beyond me, but I'm still quite curious as to the results.