News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by RoboTeddy on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:47AM (#5667391)
Here's an attempt at an explanation/translation:

HTP ("Hack The Planet") is a group that likes to break into things. Another (unnamed) group of people impersonated a third group of people ("ac1db1tch3z") and tried to cause trouble for HTP.

The impersonators located HTP by examining one of HTP's botnets (a collection of compromised computers that are used to launch things like denial of service attacks). Botnets have to receive instructions (e.g., targets to attack) from somewhere, so it's likely that the impersonators followed the path taken by commands to the botnet, and found the network(s) that HTP uses to organize themselves.

HTP realized this, and wanted to get back at the impersonators. They found out that the impersonators used an IRC channel (chat room) hosted on a network called SwiftIRC. If HTP could break into SwiftIRC (which is hosted on Linode), they could cause all sorts of trouble for the impersonators. So HTP decided to break into Linode, so they could break into SwiftIRC, so they could break into the group of impersonators.

To break into Linode, HTP broke into their domain name registar (name.com). They planned to secretly take control of linode.com, and replace it with a version of linode.com would look and feel and work correctly, but had one additional feature -- it would collect the login information that people typed in. HTP probably hoped to gain the login for SwiftIRC directly, or collect the logins for Linode admins and obtain SwiftIRC's login from there.

But, before they enacted the domain takeover (a maneuver that would likely be somewhat difficult to employ without being noticed), an HTP member discovered a new vulnerability in ColdFusion, the server software used by Linode. The ability to discover a new exploit on demand implies a high level of skill within the group. Using this exploit, HTP obtained direct access to Linode. They proceeded to gain access to SwiftIRC, as well as other sites hosted on Linode, including a well-known security site, nmap.org

The FBI apparently had a mole in HTP, and they alerted Linode that HTP had access to nmap.org. This posed a bit of a problem for HTP: if it became public knowledge that they had obtained access to Linode, then perhaps they wouldn't have time to go after the impersonators using their newfound access to SwiftIRC. So, HTP tried to strong-arm Linode into staying quiet until May 1st. HTP had obtained the customer information and credit cards of all the Linode customers. HTP threatened to widely publish all this sensitive information if Linode didn't stay quiet. If Linode complied, then HTP would just delete all the info.

Linode, though, was forced by the FBI to announce that they'd been broken into. HTP told Linode to just publicly acknowledge that HTP was the group that broke into Linode, and they'd delete the sensitive info. Linode did so (https://blog.linode.com/2013/04/16/security-incident-update/).

HTP conducted an internal investigation to determine which group member(s) were working with the FBI. HTP broke into the mole's computer and turned on their webcam, and saw an FBI employee looking over the shoulder of the mole. They kicked the mole out of the group, so the FBI doesn't have access to HTP anymore.

(Remember, this is the story according to HTP.)

Re:The story around the Linode hack by davidw on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:52AM (#5667407)
> tried to cause trouble for HTP.

Here's hoping the FBI "causes trouble" for the lot of them. Breaking into other people's stuff is not cool. If I leave my door open by mistake, yes, that makes me a bit absent minded, or foolish, but it does not give anyone the right to wander into my house.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by crisnoble on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @03:36PM (#5670227)
Everyone bitching about HTP or AnonOps or any other hacking group that likes bragging should at least be thankful that they talk about their hacks. I would bet that the crime syndicates have better hacks and keep their mouths shut about them. Those vulnerabilities don't get patched, those customers never get notified. I am not defending HTP or the like, just saying, at least they boast.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by jrockway on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:37PM (#5671976)
I worry more about governments than organized crime these days.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by jrochkind1 on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:01PM (#5672068)
Yep, them too, don't tell anyone about their hacks.

(I mean, "More about governments than organized crime? There's a difference?")

Re:The story around the Linode hack by davidw on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:36AM (#5673160)
You should pay a visit to Sicily or Naples if you don't think there's a difference.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by jrochkind1 on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @09:13AM (#5673916)
And I hope none of us ever pay a visit to Guantanamo.

But seriously, yeah, of course there's a difference, but government is also often in league with organized crime, from local levels of corrupt cops and drug leaders, to international levels of the CIA and arms traders and 'our' 'freedom fighers' -- I bet this is also true in Sicily and Naples, that many parts of the government act in league with organized crime.

But yeah, to go back to the actual topic/thread, mainly, I think the guy is right that the government is the other main actor which is going to keep it's security exploits to itself, and just use them to monitor you silently. (And that's probably more likely in the US than any other country on the planet, at the moment).

Re:The story around the Linode hack by rdl on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @05:30AM (#5673291)
I'd generally prefer government to organized crime, but would probably take the Yakuza over NK or Belarus or wherever.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by davidw on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @08:00AM (#5673619)
So you're comparing what might be the "best" of something in one category with some of the dregs in another.

Italy is not known for having particularly good politicians or government, but I'd take the government here any day over the Mafia or Camorra. Despite any romanticized movies you may have seen, those guys are pretty cold-blooded SOB's. Recently, a man was shot dead waiting to pick his son up from pre-school in Naples.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by reeses on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @06:29PM (#5677411)
You mean, how much did the 'mole' see/hear/do before getting booted from HTP?
Re:The story around the Linode hack by jrockway on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @10:23PM (#5678411)
No, that's not what I mean. What I mean are things like the Chinese government hacking Google and the New York Times, not HTP hacking some IRC provider for revenge.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by reeses on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @10:51PM (#5678495)
Let me be more clear. You mean, like employees or contractors under the direction of the FBI hacking sites, at least Linode, while 'investigating' HTP?
Re:The story around the Linode hack by sbank on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:27PM (#5672157)
Honestly, the two are very often synonymous.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by plaguuuuuu on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @12:11AM (#5672450)
Yep. Knowing various people who have done security work for banks and similar organisations, I've heard a few hair-raising stories.

They never ever disclose when they get hacked. And they do get hacked.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by CleanedStar on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:13PM (#5672114)
I'm afraid your analogy is stretched a little too far for me - that your open door leading to someone physically wandering into your personal living space is the same as some corporation with tens of millions of revenue a year that has some script kiddie sitting in his mom's basement seeing some Linode stuff come onto his screen. I guess when I think of some kid snooping around some corporation's computers, I'm supposed to compose a mental image of some thug physically invading my own home. Yes, I can see why corporations want people to think this way, but it's a rather silly metaphor as far as I'm concerned.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by davidw on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:42AM (#5673176)
Actually, these guys cost people a whole hell of a lot more time and money than someone breaking into a home probably ever did. Just for starters:

http://blog.phusion.nl/2013/05/07/phusion-server-security-re...

Re:The story around the Linode hack by conductor on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @07:17AM (#5667470)
Well then you are not a hacker. And I hope FBI can not cause trouble for them, they did not do anything unethical in my POV. The server is not a house. Black hat hacking is a mixture of art and politics (I never support hackers who hack for stealing money), and if you want the analogy, they just spotted a fancy lock on the door of some institution (not a private house), lock-picked it and looked what's behind the doors. This may be illegal, but this is the way they can confront the forces they don't like and outline their position. They did not brake or delete anything (no vandalism).
Re:The story around the Linode hack by canttestthis on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @07:26AM (#5667500)
Please give me the password to your regular email account so I can read your emails. I won't delete any of them, but your email server is not a house, and I should have the right to read your emails.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by conductor on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:48AM (#5667815)
A right? I didn't say they have a right. They hacked into. Did the US/Israel have a _right_ to use Stuxnet against Iran? No. They hacked into. When did you accuse the US secret service or hope that they will be punished? Double standards?

I won't give my email or its password to you, but if you can find it, hack it and decrypt my emails, then it would be only my fault, and you will have my respect.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by bradleyland on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:52AM (#5668101)
You're not getting it. No one is saying that Stuxnet was "right". That conversation is set in an entirely different context than the Linode hack. Iran is seeking to produce a nuclear weapon with the openly stated goal of launching it against another country. There is no segue from Stuxnet to this Linode hack.

"Fault" is not in question here either. Let's say I leave my front door unlocked. If you enter my home without my permission, you have trespassed and can be charged with a crime. The only thing I would be "at fault" for is making a lackluster attempt at securing my home. I don't forfeit protection from trespass under the law for that act though.

You see, locks are not what govern access; laws are. HTP is clearly in the wrong here. They forced entry in to Linode's systems, then attempted to extort Linode in an effort to achieve their goals. Swap out Linode's servers for Linode's offices, and there's no question that HTP are operating outside the boundaries of ethical behavior.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by conductor on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:27AM (#5668287)
I admit Stuxnet was a bad analogy to black hat hacking. But either is the analogy of hacking into a server and physically trespassing into a private property.

The main goal of my comments is to object to the opinion that hacking is somewhat comparable to physical break and enter actions. This is an age where one can find himself in prison for tens of years for hacking and getting access to information (the prospects of Aaron) or even for IP violations, as it were a murder or rape.

Being in an underground hackers crew is much fun and possibilities to learn things for young men who are smart and different than their friends. Those guys and gals are the future top-class engineers at Google and other IT giants and I want them to continue hacking and growing personally and professionally, not rotting in the prison.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by bradleyland on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @02:49PM (#5669949)
You keep getting buried because you've hitched your wagon to the wrong horse. Your core argument seems to be that punishment for hacking is often disproportionate to the crime committed.

For example, poorly written laws make even simple port scanning a risky activity. I agree that this is ridiculous, but you needn't defend HTP here in order to take that position. If anything, HTP are to blame for the overreaction from policy makers. They are having a very difficult time distinguishing between mischief and mayhem.

The law should take context in to account. If you were caught exploring an old, abandoned warehouse, you might end up with a misdemeanor trespass charge (hopefully), but if you're caught probing a corporate server, the current climate seems to dictate that you'll land a felony in short order. You've got groups like HTP to thank for that because of their extortion activities and willingness to leverage the well being of innocent people in their trivial games.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by jonknee on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @11:40AM (#5668656)
> Being in an underground hackers crew is much fun and possibilities to learn things for young men who are smart and different than their friends. Those guys and gals are the future top-class engineers at Google and other IT giants and I want them to continue hacking and growing personally and professionally, not rotting in the prison.

Or the next members of the many criminal syndicates on the internet who steal/harass/blackmail with little regard of the consequences.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by analog on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @01:14PM (#5669318)
Offtopic, but have you got a source for "Iran is seeking to produce a nuclear weapon with the openly stated goal of launching it against another country."

I had a quick look on the Wikipedia page but couldn't see anything there.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_program_of_Iran

Re:The story around the Linode hack by bradleyland on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @02:43PM (#5669912)
This is the world stage, so objectivity is hard to find, but there is a substantial amount of posturing from Mahmoud Ahmadinejad that shows a pretty aggressive stance toward Israel, if not open contempt [1].

That's really besides the point though. Anyone who seeks to boil "right and wrong" down to a simple principle that applies in all cases is holding simplicity above practicality. "Simple principles" are no more sustainable than utopian ideologies. The reality is that right and wrong are subtle and contextual. Bringing Stuxnet in to the Linode discussion is just an effort to sidetrack the topic.

Any way you slice it, HTP has dragged "innocents" in to the fight. It's not right when governments do it on the world stage. It's not right when thugs and gangsters do it by terrorizing neighborhoods with gang violence. It's not right when crackers do it during their internet turf battles.

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahmoud_Ahmadinejad_and_Israel

Re:The story around the Linode hack by analog on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @03:39PM (#5670252)
I do see you point about the inferred goals of Iran, it's just the statement "openly stated goal" is untrue and I think it's important to be accurate about these things where we can be.

I certainly agree with you about the actions of HTP being unethical.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by gruseom on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @02:03PM (#5669656)
That statement is untrue. Among journalists I know of, the one who has studied this the most and reported on it in the most detail is Gareth Porter.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by mpyne on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:13AM (#5668221)
> I won't give my email or its password to you, but if you can find it, hack it and decrypt my emails, then it would be only my fault, and you will have my respect.

Ah yes, the "might makes right" philosophy that we all know and admire from primary school.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by mtowle on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:48PM (#5675683)
Not everybody believes in rights, per se. He did put scare underscores around the word. Just saying, if you believe your position to be the moral high ground, you shouldn't need to mischaracterize the positions of others.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by criley on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:54AM (#5668112)
Did you honestly just use militarized cyberwarfare as an example of legitimate black hat?

The US/Israel are involved in a proxy war with Iran that involves cyberwarfare, clandestine operations and conventional military strikes (in the case of Israel striking Iranian-sourced Syrian weaponry).

It's an extremely poor example to use open cyberwarfare between nations engaged in everything but overt warfare to attempt to legitimize black hat hacking.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by err_badprocrast on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @04:08PM (#5670437)
I'm curious how you would classify China's crack teams engaging in industrial espionage. Is that black hat activity, or legitimate cyberwarfare by a nation-state?
Re:The story around the Linode hack by chc on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:24PM (#5671761)
I think criley's point is that if your activities closely resemble international warfare, they probably aren't "legitimate" by any reasonable standards.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by err_badprocrast on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:57PM (#5671864)
after re-reading it, you do appear to be correct. Thanks for the correction.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by jstanley on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:13AM (#5667926)
"spotted a fancy lock on the door of some institution (not a private house), lock-picked it and looked what's behind the doors."

And then collected private information of everybody who works for or is a customer of the institution, and then threatened the owners of the institution if they spoke out about what had happened.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by Dylan16807 on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @12:41AM (#5672525)
If they spoke out within two weeks. That's not very long. Hell, you can take down sites for two weeks just by filing a DMCA notice.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by alan_cx on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @11:49AM (#5668715)
I kinda get where you are coming from. I'm guessing you like the idea of sticking it to the man, as it were. Well, yeah, I like that too, I tend to lean to wards what these guys do, when it suits, but as ever, the problem is with intention and trust. Do you really trust them 100% to only look? The same people who do that could raid my current account, and none of us can be sure they wont. Or, sell on details to raise funds for their "great" works, or cynically line their pockets. We just don't know.

I think quite a number of people tread this fine line between approving of sort of Robin Hood types and criminals. And that can change given the target. So, "fantastic" if they embarrass the FBI, not so comfortable if its our bank.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by qw on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @03:47AM (#5673037)
If they only "looked" it would not be too bad, but they did much more here. They threatened to release credit card numbers, user names, emails and passwords of customers. Do you think it's fair that someone's personal information is released just because they are customers of Linode?
Re:The story around the Linode hack by ozh on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:47AM (#5668077)
Why bother reading novels or watch thriller movies when there are comments like this? :)
Re:The story around the Linode hack by mertdumenci on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:57AM (#5667417)
That helped a lot, thank you.
Re:The story around the Linode hack by viame on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @01:01PM (#5669231)
This translation makes more sense. If this is all true, this is a great story and I want to make a movie out of this. Also, who cares that Linode got hacked. Facebook/Twitter have more information on you than Linode, and they share it with the Gov. The only thing that I wouldn't want is my data to be lost (if i didn't have any backups)

Just a personal opinion.

Re:The story around the Linode hack by s884812 on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @01:06PM (#5669266)
lol i think this story can be filmed.