What I would like is a home cloud server which would handle all the services I could get from the cloud with explicit sharing with chosen people (e.g. my family).
If you plug together a handful of off the shelf Amazon components, slap a label on it, and open the doors, perhaps that is rightly called a "cloud" service ... the end provider has no accountability to you (or your users) and you have no idea what's going on behind the curtain. It's all just magic happening many layers of abstraction away.
But if you build systems, own the platform, write the architecture and provide something that you understand and have accountability for, end to end, I think it can satisfy the skeptics (of which I am one).
So in this case, the researcher that can't store the documents on dropbox ... hopefully he could upload them with duplicity to an online storage platform that was built and run like this[1].
And I hope that this would be possible because such a distinction could be made ...
http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/transporterguy/transport...
http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/clintgc/space-monkey-tak...
(But it's pretty cool. I'm an alpha user.)
If you're ok with relying on obscurity, you already have it - you are one person among billions on this planet. Who else cares about your photos?
http://www.synology.com/dsm/home_file_sharing_cloud_station....
Maximum capacity is 96T, that should be enough for most home servers.
1. even in Seattle, internet response time is erratic. Delays anywhere from a second to a couple minutes is commonplace. Using an app requiring constant traffic over the internet is quite unpleasant.
2. The backup problem. If my cloud account "goes dark" for whatever reason, I'm dead in the water, and I'm helpless to fix it.
3. I simply won't use a cloud solution that doesn't encrypt the data on my machine before sending it to the cloud server. Encrypting it after it gets to the cloud server is unacceptable. I currently use Jungledisk for backups on Amazon's cloud service because it does encryption locally.
[1] http://www.daemonology.net/blog/2011-06-03-insecurity-in-the... and its discussion here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2616634
[2] http://push.cx/2011/retracting-my-jungledisk-recommendation
Isn't the cloud part of your back-up strategy? For example, I use OneNote for all of my notes. It syncs the notes on my PC to the cloud. As long as I'm connected, I have a backup online.
Changes also sync to my other computers when they're online.
Additionally, the notebooks are included in the local data backups we make (in our case off-sited to our ISP).
Sensitive stuff is encrypted in TrueCrypt, and the TrueCrypt volume is stored on DropBox. MI5/CIA could probably break the encryption, but there are easier ways for them to get at it.. http://xkcd.com/538/
But what advantage does that offer over a native application? You’d then need a ‘native’ web server and would still rely on the local browser in a way that opens you up to more incompatibilities than just using the native interface framework?
An interesting usecase would be a LAN-local server, which would (with server-side data processing) avoid the slow uploading of data over the internet and could still utilise native computation speeds on the server.
On the other hand data on an encrypted disk is not exactly the same thing. It must be made available to the OS whenever the user is logged in. Any breach in security say from an email attachment or malicious website would expose its unencrypted contents.
I wonder what the required policy is for backups? Can they be stored on servers if encrypted? Remote servers?
Back when I was part of a EU research project, we could not use Skype, DimDim or any other video-conference platform because a lot of stuff we worked was protected as the author comments under a lot of privacy contracts.
A lot of the time, these requirements are more about auditing and liability than about technical security measures.
"Many developers assume that everyone wants their data to be “in the cloud”, but that's actually not true for a lot of my customers. Professional researchers often sign agreements in their children's blood stating that their data will be stored on an encrypted disk, won't leave their laptop, and will be destroyed when the research project is completed. “The cloud” is the last place they want their data to go."
There are so many great note taking and productivity application that I just can't use because the majority of my notes are of a confidential nature. If my company provided macbook where to be compromised I would not be held liable, however if my personal dropbox or evernote account where compromised I would be held accountable.