News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by SeanDav on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:38AM (#5558319)
Very polished site from the little I saw of it - and there lies the rub - I saw so little of it.

Why don't you allow browsing without registration? I am sure you will miss out on a lot of traffic and future sign-ups because the initial experience is opaque.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by electrichead on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @07:16PM (#5561560)
An email address is not part of a painless signup as we don't know what type and quantity of emails we will receive. As a result, I will sign up with a disposable email and never return. As it happens, I went there on an android phone and found lots of problems with the layout. On that note though, HN is pretty bad for browsing on a phone too.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by alexholehouse on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:40AM (#5558340)
Registration is literally no more than the three boxes on the signup page, which was a pleasant surprise.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by ed209 on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:19AM (#5558614)
I think people are starting to suffer from signup fatigue (even with just 3 boxes). Wherever possible, services should get right into the kernel of the experience and ask for registration later.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by npsimons on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:29AM (#5558687)
Seconded; it may be "only" three boxes, but I can browse SO or SE by filling in zero boxes. This reminded me of a site (can't remember which) that comes up in Google results for some UNIX CLI searches I've done and requires sign-in or payment(!) to view community contributed answers. Bugger that for a lark.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by Thrymr on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:31PM (#5559110)
Quora? I always avoid Quora links for that reason. Worthless compared with SO.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by npongratz on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:39PM (#5559156)
Experts-Exchange[0], perhaps? There were (are?) some workarounds for getting E-E's full results, but SO/SE is so much better, it doesn't matter what's on E-E anymore.

[0] Don't look here for a link from me, I'd rather not encourage them by sending traffic their way.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by npsimons on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @01:09PM (#5559377)
I hate to be a citation dodger, but partly due to laziness, and partly due to not wanting to send any traffic their way, I didn't bother digging up what site it was. I'm all for paying for expert opinion when a) it's better than I could do and b) the people providing the expertise get the majority of the money. Charging money for unverified, uncompensated answers? Too lame. I am one of those people who used SO/SE for quite some time and finally signed up for an account when I stumbled upon a question I had an answer for. I don't mind giving back, much as I didn't mind contributing to CDDB until Gracenote ruined it. Whatever other gripes I might have with SO/SE, I think it's so successful because of its model.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by jblow on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:40PM (#5559164)
Yes. I was interested in the site, went to the page, saw the signup boxes, and left.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:17PM (#5562002)
Went to the site, was annoyed by the sign-in requirements, and left.

Came here to write a comment, then decided to go back to the site. It accepts [email protected] as a valid email. Typed throwaway password.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by polymatter on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @02:59PM (#5560082)
That is still far too much before I even know what it is! At least show a picture or two of what's behind the registration wall.

Tip for others: Just register with fake details in order to see what the site is. There is no email verification step. If it takes your fancy just re-register again properly.

Edit: I realise I sound a bit negative, so I want to say that everything I didn't mention was a positive. The site looks beautiful, what content is there is fantastic and you should definitely keep it up.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by bsilvereagle on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:30AM (#5558696)
This site doesn't necessarily need off-the-bat registration, so forcing users to register when we think registration isn't a necessity is the issue I think.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by moondowner on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:10AM (#5558559)
3 boxes, or 1 social sign-in, is the norm nowadays.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:18PM (#5562005)
That doesn't make it good. Maybe you're arguing that the target market won't care?
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by moondowner on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:32AM (#5563214)
I'm just saying that this is the standard way now. Everybody wants to make it as easy as possible for new users to sign in.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by mike_ivanov on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:32AM (#5558709)
Look, the thing is, the only reason why you are asking for registration is building an email database. If you stated that clearly like "please provide your email so we'd contact you later" or whatever -- that would be perfectly acceptable. However, by forcing me into surrending you my email address you make me wonder what else I'm going to be forced into down the road. So, thanks, but no, thanks.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by CamperBob2 on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:34PM (#5561400)
True. He's more than welcome to email [email protected] with whatever further information he would like to release.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:19PM (#5562008)
True, but the site accepts [email protected] ... so ...
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by mrgoldenbrown on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:44AM (#5558364)
Why can't I see anything without signing in? Do I need to pay?
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:45AM (#5558372)
No need to pay. You can sign up within a few seconds and you're in! :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by mkl on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:52AM (#5558418)
It really seems like a pointless obstacle. The value of a site like this is in the content, which is inaccessible without handing over an email address, so nobody can tell if it's worth it. I think you would get far more participants if you made it openly viewable (and hence google-able).
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by mrgoldenbrown on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:54AM (#5558433)
So is it a policy decision to not allow browsing unless you're signed in? Or just a beta thing? Saying it's easy to register doesn't address the question of why it's necessary :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:59AM (#5558475)
I just launched it a week ago. So, things will surely change with time. How about something like StackOverflow? You can view everything, but to vote or answer you have to login. All this feedback is really going to help a lot! :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by joey2714 on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:18AM (#5558612)
I think that is a good idea, or something along those lines. I too clicked the link to the site, but when I noticed I had to register first, I came back here to check the comments rather than continuing. Showing more content before forcing a signup should gather a lot more interest. Looks nice though, and you seem very receptive to feedback, so I guess I will go sign up anyway! Good luck!
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:30AM (#5558691)
Thank you!! I would also like to add that the content would NOT be greyed out for non-registered users and it would be licensed under creative commons :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by SeanDav on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:03AM (#5558503)
Sorry, I accidentally downvoted you.

I wanted to say yes, this. Allow viewing of everything but to participate, you have to register.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:20PM (#5562013)
Yeah, that's better. You at least need to offer something before asking me to trust you.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by mrgoldenbrown on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:29PM (#5562520)
Yes. The model they have is ideal IMHO - viewing the site doesn't require a login, and then when you do sign up, it is an extremely low friction process.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by vishaltelangre on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @01:21AM (#5562812)
Oh, I really feel bad when I try to access http://functionspace.org/topic/22 without signing in, and it redirected me to homepage to sign in! How the content of this site become crawlable to search engines, huh? I am in a doubt!
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by det23x on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:36AM (#5558302)
So what do you want to achieve here, because such a platform is just useful if you find either people that are willing to answer specific questions - such as in mathoverflow - or if you want to read something up (and then you probably go to wikipedia or grap another introduction to a topic). Anyway, it is nicely done, but I wonder if there was another intention than "because we can". I have read the "How Function Space is different?" section, but it is not that convincing.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:50AM (#5558402)
I wanted to create a complete learning environment for these three subjects. So apart from discussions and articles, there are various other things like Video lectures, book reviews, problem solving techniques, subject groups and visualisations(which will soon evolve to virtual labs). Rather than quickly-learn,quickly-forget model, I wanted to implement a model that is based on solid understanding of concepts.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by alexholehouse on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:39AM (#5558332)
I actually think that for a lot of maths/CS/Physics issues, wikipedia is a horrible introduction to people unfamiliar with the topic. A site which curates explanations in normalspeak with some form of interaction (i.e. "Can you explain why...") would actually be a very useful resource for a lot of people, myself included.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by det23x on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:52AM (#5558413)
Yeah, that's true, but you can also use free ebooks, slides from lectures, etc. and you often find really good stuff. Furthermore one should not have to register for such a service ... consider wikipedia would require you to login to find out how, e.g. merge sort works.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by pvarangot on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:41AM (#5558765)
Wikipedia is supposed to be static, without questions from readers on any engagement besides reading and maybe correcting or expanding something.

Also, no serious Wikipedia article about math or physics is thought of as an introduction. Sometimes its the other way around, its written for experts and goes into surface or line integrals, or sometimes even tensor notation, when an introduction would not.

I think this website is trying to reduce friction for user interaction and aggregating it, and also tries to curate material into different levels of difficulty. Both things merit asking for a login, for social its obvious why, and to curate for difficulty its helpful to use the feedback from users as a signal of an innadecuate label.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by jonahx on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:01AM (#5558485)
khan academy, among others, already addresses this
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by kyzyl on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:15AM (#5558590)
Khan academy is nice for the material it covers, but anybody going beyond high school will find it rapidly becomes obsolete (according to the content ca. the last time I checked). The treatments are simply too elementary and the topics too low level.

I would think a site where people can ask anything, ala stackoverflow, would yield more useful results for many physics/math/cs students.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by bradddd on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:25AM (#5558650)
That may have been true a couple years ago, but they are rapidly expanding. They now include calculus and diff eq with plans to go beyond. They're even researching med school related content for the future.

That being said, I wouldn't take that as a reason to not pursue this.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by kyzyl on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:51PM (#5566682)
Looking at what's on there, I'm really not convinced. You could not get through an physics, engineering or math program on the material that is there, not even close. If I search for, say, complex analysis, all of the material I get is about complex arithmetic. No multivalued functions, branch cuts, p.v. integrals, harmonic functions, DEs, nothing. It's all what they expect you to know going INTO the course, or that they cover in the first two days.

Similarly, if I go into the physics topics, they are all <= intro courses, at best. Optics? Doesn't talk about fourier optics, lasers, etc. E&M? Doesn't seem to mention Maxwell's Equations anywhere... enough said. Quantum mech? Nothing. Statistical mech? Nothing.

Okay, how about math? Take a look at the differential equations stuff. No higher order, no series methods, no numerical methods, no coupled systems, no non-linear. Probability? No markov chains, MCMC methods, or anything except basic RVs and statistics (which is not the same thing as probability). Same for linear algebra: no fitting methods, no matrix decomposition, no graph theory.

I could go on. The point is that they cover the most basic elements of each subject, and they miss a hell of a lot of important subjects. That's okay, but don't claim that they're anywhere close to being able to educate you at a university level.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by claudius on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @03:59PM (#5560484)
> They now include calculus and diff eq with plans to go beyond.

So first year of uni tops, where most of calculus is still high school.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by grwgreg on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:10PM (#5562443)
The differential equations videos have been up since 2009.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by orillian on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:37PM (#5559139)
khan academy does so but with a definite focus on children, this feels a little more grown up.

Besides, just because khan does similar things does not reduce the value potential this has.

There is a lot more of a social SO type feel with Function Space whereby a user can ask questions and receive answers in an open forum. That is more hidden on khan.

For those of you complaining about the login. Give it a shot, there is a fairly well thought out site behind that login and the dev has expressed his intent to make things more open. With a site like this being able to ask and comment is kinda key to it working anyways.

Use your spam address on the site until you feel it's worthy of your "personal" one. But do check it out.

Free and open access to knowledge and knowledgeable people needs to be done in as many places and formats as possible. I hope this goes far.

O.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by strangestchild on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:01AM (#5558486)
Looks good - I've signed up :)

I would say though that I think your articles and lectures could do with a bit more organisation. In both cases, the user would benefit from posts having tags denoting subject content, and from a search facility so that I can find things that specifically interest me. If you have five hundred videos about mathematics, finding one on Analytic Topology, say, by scrolling through them would be a bit painful. I also think it would be good if the lectures had some way of tying subsequent videos together - it seems a tiny bit messy to have 'Cosmology - Lecture 1', and 'Cosmology - Lecture 2' as separate entries. I'm also not certain that you want to limit lectures to being videos. A well-written explanation of a broad subject is sometimes better than a video that I can't search or skim through - and I think it serves a different purpose from the articles. It's also easier for your community to add written content than videos.

Hope that was useful to you - but obviously take it all with a pinch of salt. You know your strategy better than some guy off the internet who's only spent ten minutes on your site :)

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:09AM (#5558542)
Thanks for signing up! And thanks a lot for positive criticism. I have noted your feedback regarding Lectures and Articles. Will surely implement it within few days! :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by mdkess on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:43PM (#5561112)
Really like the idea of this, and especially enjoyed that you took the time to make the 2 minute video walkthrough (it made it easy for me to say "ok, I'll give you 2 minutes, let's hear your pitch"). I think the idea of having a focused community will work quite well.

A suggestion: Redis has a very cool documentation system, where the documentation is "live" - for example, http://redis.io/commands/set (scroll down to the example, you can type in the box). It'd be really neat to have something like that integrated with the code side of things.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by dusklight on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @01:50PM (#5559639)
Clicked on link -- I am interested in learning about math, physics and CS.

Saw registration screen. Closed window.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by vitno on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @01:11PM (#5559391)
Have you considered integrating something like Persona? While I have never like FB sign up, this is the exact situation where I would be tempted to use it. Possible interest, but I don't really wanna go through the sign-up. I keep hoping to find a site in the wild using Persona.

of course... in the time I typed this I could have just signed up. :P

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by MartinMcGirk on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:26AM (#5558665)
Looks good, I look forward to exploring the site properly after work. One small niggle for you to address though. Log out and go to your home page. Navigate to the About page. Now try and get back to the home page without using your browsers back button.

I would expect your site logo in the top left to take me to your home page, especially as it appears clickable, but it doesn't. It puts a # at the end of the url and that's it.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:33AM (#5558722)
Thanks!! Fixing it now! :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by prezjordan on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:27AM (#5558241)
Interesting. LaTeX support?
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:28AM (#5558246)
yes, LateX support is there! Inbuilt visual equation editor coming in a week or so! :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by prezjordan on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:36AM (#5558299)
Excellent, site looks great :) I'd love the ability to edit/delete my "opinions" though.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by cing on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:02PM (#5558905)
Cool site. I think you should include a citation importer and exporter for people referencing published articles in their posts.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:16PM (#5558998)
Thanks!! Point noted! :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by _chrismccreadie on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @07:49PM (#5561680)
I love the look and feel of the site, well done. I understand some of the frustration in the discussion about required registration but the site is still definitely worth a look. The half alive/half dead cat icon for quantum mechanics made me laugh, kudos to whoever designed it.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by Splendor on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:35PM (#5562308)
Home page tells me nothing, just wants me to sign up for something I don't understand yet. That's when I closed the tab. If you want idiots like me to signup you'll need to sell me before you ask me to type.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:49PM (#5562588)
There's a video on the home page :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by Splendor on Thursday April 18, 2013 @04:53PM (#5573020)
Ain't nobody got time for that.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by Wonderdonkey on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @01:58PM (#5559688)
aditgupta, What I saw of this was pretty neat. Have you considered adding Common Core alignment for high school students/teachers who would benefit from it?

Heads up: I left the site, and it didn't remember me when I came back. I forgot my random password and requested a password reset. Got a confirmation that an e-mail had been sent, but that hasn't arrived after a good 30 minutes so far.

Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @02:03PM (#5559722)
Thanks! I am considering some kind of tie-up with schools and colleges. I see that a mail has been sent to some emails. If you can send me your email id, I will cross-check it for you.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @03:39PM (#5560337)
Thank you all for such an overwhelming response! I will deal with the sign-up issue ASAP. All other suggestions would also be implemented soon. :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by jsanders128 on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:31PM (#5559106)
Great idea! How did you make the website? Ie, did you contract out or make it yourself? And if so, how were you able to do it? Thanks.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by aditgupta on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:37PM (#5559142)
Thanks! It took me about 2 weeks to design and a month to develop. I left my full-time job for Function Space. My wife also helped me out with some ideas. The biggest motivating factor was my love for these 3 subjects. :)
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by nilkn on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @03:44PM (#5560366)
How do you plan on monetizing Function Space?
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by solistice on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:21PM (#5561329)
On this tangent, I wouldn't suggest premium features, unless they're minor because they tend to tear apart communities (look at all the games). I'd suggest nonintrusive ads and/or affiliate links to books, which would fit this site nicely. You could also put a store in there selling things relating to these topics, either setting that up yourself, or again going the affiliate route. Honestly, you could just look into how similar sites are doing their financing, and see what you can copy from their methods.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by andreros on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @05:45PM (#5561122)
The favicon is slightly unreadable, and could easily be improved.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by solistice on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @06:23PM (#5561347)
A FAQ would also be nice/neccesairy. If it's allready there, put it somewhere where people can find it.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ... by findomia on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:26PM (#5559067)
Great site your created. Thanks!