Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by alexholehouse on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @10:40AM
(#5558340)
Registration is literally no more than the three boxes on the signup page, which was a pleasant surprise.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by ed209 on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:19AM
(#5558614)
I think people are starting to suffer from signup fatigue (even with just 3 boxes). Wherever possible, services should get right into the kernel of the experience and ask for registration later.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by npsimons on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:29AM
(#5558687)
Seconded; it may be "only" three boxes, but I can browse SO or SE by filling in zero boxes. This reminded me of a site (can't remember which) that comes up in Google results for some UNIX CLI searches I've done and requires sign-in or payment(!) to view community contributed answers. Bugger that for a lark.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by Thrymr on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:31PM
(#5559110)
Quora? I always avoid Quora links for that reason. Worthless compared with SO.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by npongratz on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:39PM
(#5559156)
Experts-Exchange[0], perhaps? There were (are?) some workarounds for getting E-E's full results, but SO/SE is so much better, it doesn't matter what's on E-E anymore.
[0] Don't look here for a link from me, I'd rather not encourage them by sending traffic their way.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by npsimons on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @01:09PM
(#5559377)
I hate to be a citation dodger, but partly due to laziness, and partly due to not wanting to send any traffic their way, I didn't bother digging up what site it was. I'm all for paying for expert opinion when a) it's better than I could do and b) the people providing the expertise get the majority of the money. Charging money for unverified, uncompensated answers? Too lame. I am one of those people who used SO/SE for quite some time and finally signed up for an account when I stumbled upon a question I had an answer for. I don't mind giving back, much as I didn't mind contributing to CDDB until Gracenote ruined it. Whatever other gripes I might have with SO/SE, I think it's so successful because of its model.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by jblow on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @12:40PM
(#5559164)
Yes. I was interested in the site, went to the page, saw the signup boxes, and left.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:17PM
(#5562002)
Went to the site, was annoyed by the sign-in requirements, and left.
Came here to write a comment, then decided to go back to the site. It accepts [email protected] as a valid email. Typed throwaway password.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by polymatter on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @02:59PM
(#5560082)
That is still far too much before I even know what it is! At least show a picture or two of what's behind the registration wall.
Tip for others: Just register with fake details in order to see what the site is. There is no email verification step. If it takes your fancy just re-register again properly.
Edit: I realise I sound a bit negative, so I want to say that everything I didn't mention was a positive. The site looks beautiful, what content is there is fantastic and you should definitely keep it up.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by bsilvereagle on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:30AM
(#5558696)
This site doesn't necessarily need off-the-bat registration, so forcing users to register when we think registration isn't a necessity is the issue I think.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by moondowner on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @11:10AM
(#5558559)
3 boxes, or 1 social sign-in, is the norm nowadays.
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by JabavuAdams on Tuesday April 16, 2013 @09:18PM
(#5562005)
That doesn't make it good. Maybe you're arguing that the target market won't care?
Re:I've created a community and learning platform for math, ...
by moondowner on Wednesday April 17, 2013 @03:32AM
(#5563214)
I'm just saying that this is the standard way now. Everybody wants to make it as easy as possible for new users to sign in.