News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by dustcoin on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:06PM (#5547848)
The power numbers cited by this article are very inaccurate when considering current mining hardware and software.

"* Electricity consumption is estimated based on power consumption of 650 Watts per gigahash and electricity price of 15 cent per kilowatt hour. In reality some miners will be more or less efficient."

Most serious miners pay less than $0.15/kWh.

An Avalon ASIC does 65Gh/s on 620W (9.5 J/Gh)

A BFL Single FPGA does 800Mh/s on 80W (100 J/Gh)

Even a dual ATI 5970 rig will do 1300Mh/s on 600W (461 J/Gh)

Currently over 1/3 of the network is ASICs (300 * 65Gh/s of Avalons + 7Th/s from ASICMINER) and another 1/3 is probably FPGAs.

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by Retric on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:35PM (#5547961)
The problem is people also mine on dual core CPU's. When looking for total energy consumption you need to include the long tail of horrible hardware because of botnet's / school computers where the miner does not directly pay for energy costs and so does not care about efficiency.

PS: Consider a ten hour 600 mile trip by a 60mpg car and a 6mpg camper. The average fuel consumption is not (60mpg + 6mpg) / 2 = 33mpg, but (2*600miles)/(600miles/60mpg + 600miles/6mpg) or 10.9mpg.

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by rb2k_ on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:50PM (#5548004)
> The problem is people also mine on dual core CPUs

That would only be botnets though? You'd probably make more money walking around outside and and hoping to find quarters

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by archangel_one on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:46PM (#5548224)
Yes, but the person running the botnet is not paying for it, so they don't care about efficiency.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by hippich on Sunday April 14, 2013 @06:03PM (#5548536)
but person running botnet always have a choose what to do with it. and mining bitcoins with cpu would be last thing he would do I guess..
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by nwh on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:49PM (#5547995)
Nobody mines on a CPU anymore, there's absolutely no point. At the current difficulty, you would barely even get a single share. For example, a single share on p2pool is at difficulty 725 now, there's no way a CPU miner can solve that.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by thatthatis on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:32PM (#5548153)
Botnets. School computer labs. Kids in their parent's basement.

No rational person who bears the full cost of their actions would mine on a CPU anymore. But 1) not everyone is rational and moreover 2) not everyone bears the full cost of their actions.

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:14PM (#5547884)
Are these ASICS going to be good for anything after mining coins? I can't help thinking they're like a shovel that only works within a goldfield and has no utility (other than as a doorstop) once superseded by faster technology or obviated by the last Bitcoin being mined.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by lreeves on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:21PM (#5547914)
Literally nothing. The point of ASICs are specialized circuits for a single task really.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by fnordfnordfnord on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:39PM (#5547972)
I can't believe someone junked your post. It is an answer to the question, and it is the correct answer.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by lreeves on Sunday April 14, 2013 @11:31PM (#5549586)
Sorry what does "junked your post" mean?
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by fnordfnordfnord on Monday April 15, 2013 @01:44PM (#5552887)
My apologies, "junked" is slang for downvoting on another forum I visit.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by Drakim on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:24PM (#5547923)
Even after the last bitcoin is mined you can still mine for transaction fees.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by SilasX on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:08PM (#5548074)
Since they're optimized to compute SHA256 hashes, then yes: any application requiring such a computation.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by wmf on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:29PM (#5548139)
Keep in mind that hashing data and brute-forcing a hash function require different hardware. There are no real applications that brute-force chained SHA hashes.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by SilasX on Monday April 15, 2013 @02:25AM (#5550077)
Password-cracking. (Um ... for penetration testing ... that's it.)
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by ef4 on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:17PM (#5548101)
After the last Bitcoin is mined (and actually much sooner than that), the profit from mining will have shifted away from new coins and into transaction fees.

Mining new coins and processing transactions are the same thing. So the hardware can remain useful as long as Bitcoin stays in use.

(Could it get obsoleted by better hardware? Of course, but that's true of every piece of electronics.)

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday April 14, 2013 @06:28PM (#5548647)
I don't know enough about the system but is it also possible to mine for "lost" coins?

So someone started out mining and their wallet was corrupted or their hard-drive failed or what-have-you but at the time BTC were worth a few ¢. Is it possible to cryptographically reclaim those lost coins by claiming to have a hash or something and seeing if it verifies? Could one test, like a brute force check, in a separate environment so as not to leak that you're trying to reclaim a coin.

Or is this impossible within the restraints of the system.

[I can't see how it can be mathematically impossible, if a coin was verified and placed in a wallet then there's some "code" that says "I have the wallet with that coin"; perhaps though it's impossible at present to mine for that code successfully in a worthwhile way??]

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by shawabawa3 on Sunday April 14, 2013 @06:55PM (#5548751)
It's impossible to reclaim coins. You would have to guess the private key that secures them, and if that was possible bitcoin would be useless.

However, I guess it's possible for the network to agree to mine some new coins at some point in the future.

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday April 14, 2013 @07:17PM (#5548810)
So not impossible, you _just_ have to guess the owners private key?

Presumably you could in theory brute force that in a million years or whatever. Also if there were an example of data encrypted with that key (is there in the block chain by virtue of the protocol?) then if the private key system were broken - eg by advance in quantum computing or a weakness found in the crypto used - then perhaps it would then be feasible.

The corollary of this appears to be that you'd then be able to take anyone's bitcoins?

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by shawabawa3 on Sunday April 14, 2013 @07:29PM (#5548850)
> So not impossible, you _just_ have to guess the owners private key?

Yes, by impossible I meant computationally infeasible (at the moment)

> The corollary of this appears to be that you'd then be able to take anyone's bitcoins?

Yes, there's no way of recovering long abandoned coins (e.g. the genesis block coins) that couldn't be used to steal newly minted coins

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:27PM (#5548131)
I guess what I am confused by is that the transaction processing is much easier than mining (ie it's not going to get more and more difficult to do do over time) so you'd need to be processing a very large number of transactions before you'd need an ASIC. If you're a bank or BTC exchange then it's a no-brainer, but I wonder if more than a small number of these devices will be able to do enough work to justify their power consumption as time goes by.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by lenazegher on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:45PM (#5548218)
>I guess what I am confused by is that the transaction processing is much easier than mining (ie it's not going to get more and more difficult to do do over time)

Are you sure this is true?

My understanding is that the proof-of-work requirements will be the same even after no new coins can be mined. Otherwise, the integrity of bitcoin would be threatened.

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by maxerickson on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:48PM (#5548228)
By easier, do you mean less competitive?

The transaction fees are won in the same fashion as the mining rewards, so given a high enough level of paying users there should be incentive to run nodes (the transaction fees might even overtake the mining rewards before the last new coins are awarded, if things play out in a bitcoin friendly manner).

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @05:15PM (#5548343)
But if you are mining, there are fewer and fewer new coins to be discovered over time, so you have to compute more and more hashes in hopes of finding a new one. My (possibly incorrect) understanding is that processing a transaction 1 year from now will be no more difficult than processing one today, whereas in the future you'll have to mine for longer to have the same chance of getting a BTC.

In other words, doesn't the workload for processing each transaction stay the same over time?

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by maxerickson on Sunday April 14, 2013 @06:21PM (#5548611)
Yeah, actually adding a transaction to a block is trivial. But that block still has to be added to the block chain, which is exactly what mining is.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by hollerith on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:17PM (#5548100)
>An Avalon ASIC does 65Gh/s on 620W

Wow! That's less than 1.5 percent of the (average) cost estimated by the OP.

Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con... by mtgx on Sunday April 14, 2013 @03:14PM (#5547888)
From the moment I saw this I immediately thought it's probably wrong, because they think the biggest volume of mining is done with PC's, when in fact it's with ASIC's and FPGA's now, which are far more efficient than PC's.