Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con...
by anigbrowl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:27PM
(#5548131)
I guess what I am confused by is that the transaction processing is much easier than mining (ie it's not going to get more and more difficult to do do over time) so you'd need to be processing a very large number of transactions before you'd need an ASIC. If you're a bank or BTC exchange then it's a no-brainer, but I wonder if more than a small number of these devices will be able to do enough work to justify their power consumption as time goes by.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con...
by lenazegher on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:45PM
(#5548218)
>I guess what I am confused by is that the transaction processing is much easier than mining (ie it's not going to get more and more difficult to do do over time)
Are you sure this is true?
My understanding is that the proof-of-work requirements will be the same even after no new coins can be mined. Otherwise, the integrity of bitcoin would be threatened.
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con...
by maxerickson on Sunday April 14, 2013 @04:48PM
(#5548228)
By easier, do you mean less competitive?
The transaction fees are won in the same fashion as the mining rewards, so given a high enough level of paying users there should be incentive to run nodes (the transaction fees might even overtake the mining rewards before the last new coins are awarded, if things play out in a bitcoin friendly manner).
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con...
by anigbrowl on Sunday April 14, 2013 @05:15PM
(#5548343)
But if you are mining, there are fewer and fewer new coins to be discovered over time, so you have to compute more and more hashes in hopes of finding a new one. My (possibly incorrect) understanding is that processing a transaction 1 year from now will be no more difficult than processing one today, whereas in the future you'll have to mine for longer to have the same chance of getting a BTC.
In other words, doesn't the workload for processing each transaction stay the same over time?
Re:Bitcoin Miners Are Racking Up $150,000 A Day In Power Con...
by maxerickson on Sunday April 14, 2013 @06:21PM
(#5548611)
Yeah, actually adding a transaction to a block is trivial. But that block still has to be added to the block chain, which is exactly what mining is.