They played a hunch and lost. The linked post details lots of mistakes, but this particular one doesn't seem like one to me.
You've got a business when people repeatedly exchange value with you. Kind words are validation of a sort, but the weakest kind. To go from there to spending a year building a platform is basically hearing what you want to hear. Better not to ask than to believe what you hear uncritically; if you don't ask, at least you know you don't know.
The data that was lost right here: "After that moment we basically stopped talking to artists for a year [...]"
Find customers as early as possible, engage with them as often as possible, and really really listen to what's being said. This is a huge benefit of bootstrapping. Customer engagement from the earliest possible time is vital to the process of transforming an idea into a product.
These are money-losing businesses. As we speak.
Real life is much more complicated.
There's so much retro-active quarterbacking that goes on (especially in the VC-world) that says X company was success because they applied this-thing-I'm-just-now-naming as a rule. Even though, Apple has taught us things like you're users don't always know what they want or need.
With launchrock + adwords this has become stupid easy.
Why was that sufficient data to justify spending months and months of your life bringing this startup to fruition?
EDIT: I did not intend to make a sly insult toward the author. I've seen people do startups with similar justifications and I am confused.