The sheer magnitude of income inequality is a social problem in its own right. It doesn't matter all that much if the inequality happened with or without corruption. What matters is that some people work hard and are rewarded with quite little, and have unnecessarily difficult lives as a result -- and furthermore, that the system appears to be trending towards _more_ of that, not less.
It's much more profitable to do a mediocre job in banking than to do a world-changing job of actually building things. Proximity to money is worth more than actual ingenuity.
The city leaders ask why, since they didn't build the locks or create any of the system that makes it all happen, they should share in the wealth above others, and above the work they do.
The Union leaders reply that the small percentage they're asking for will pay total about the same as they're getting now, and it better aligns the interests of both sides. Of course the city leaders eventually agree. And of course, the "modest percentage" steadily grows over time, with a multitude of clever, more complex shipping arrangements.
That's the financial system we have. They didn't build it; their brain power goes to make it more opaque, and siphon more to them. And with regulatory capture, the federal gov't abets it all.
I'm not saying they're not smart, I'm saying that the proximity to money has a lot more to do with their earnings than the value they're creating for the economy.
http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2011/09/22/are-we-entering-the-a...
First, corporate profits are aberrantly high for a number of reasons, none of which are likely to be permanent. John Hussman, an analyst whom I respect deeply, has a good discussion of this from the perspective of stock valuations, but the basic point is relevant here. [http://www.hussmanfunds.com/wmc/wmc130408.htm]
Second, while I agree that this is "the story" in a purely journalistic sense, it's important not to get too carried in discussions about relative income distributions and miss the forest for the trees, as it were.
Income inequality is not an informationally useful statistic on its own. Income inequality can be thought of as a measure of the strength of incentives in a system. Those incentives can be good or bad on their own. In 3rd world nations, income inequality is a reflection of the strong incentive to be corrupt and steal. In the closed system of Goldman Sachs, income inequality (among employees) is a measure of the incentive to achieve annual performance targets. In the context of the public education system, it is a measure of the incentive to achieve seniority and bureaucratic promotions. In startups it reflects the incentive to get acquired or IPO. Et cetera.
In the United States, when people say that income inequality is too high, what they're usually thinking is that the wrong things are being incentivized and rewarded. That's a fine discussion to have, and I would agree that certain industries [health care jumps immediately to mind] suffer from deep and severe incentive problems that are reflected when you look at income distributions within those sectors.
But the problem is not the income distribution; it's the fact that income is being distributed unequally for the wrong reasons. That is the conversion people should be having.