Looking at it, it's Tesla that failed to emphasise these benefits properly.
For a firm that is supposed to be innovative and disrupting the industry, this "deal" looks like standard car salesman fud. The only innovative thing is the buy back scheme, which is a little lost beneath the $500 stuff.
They'd be better off saying; look, the Tesla S will cost you ~£1,000 per month, but based on what you've entered the best alternative you could have would be $600/mo car, with $400/mo fuel cost (maybe pick some example cars in that price range to compare against directly). And emphasise the ability for you to get a premium car for your money.
In fact; this true cost of ownership thing could have worked if they hadn't stamped a big $500 on the front of it.
I understand why they have done it this way - fuel costs aren't a fixed cost for most people (by which I mean, you probably couldn't recall offhand exactly what you pay per month, or when you pay it) and so is a cost which people don't appreciate as much as their credit lines. But, still.
Similarly the buyback is only for a very short window of ownership. It'll be interesting to see how they remind owners of this window - will it be months in advance, or will it be "Hello, as of today..."?
Are you really saying that you'd replace the battery pack on that car? In three years, starting with a brand new one?
Or are you talking about keeping that car afterwards, ignoring the buyback option (and why would you do that)?
No, it's really not.
If I'm paying $1200/month for a BMW, and the cost of gas+maintenance is $400/month(ballpark), then my total cost per month is $1600.
If I'm paying $1200/month for a Tesla, and the cost of maintenance comes out to $200/month, then my total cost per month is $1400. The cost of gas should not be subtracted from the Tesla's cost, because that cost is $0. It can be used as a comparison point between the BMW and the Tesla, in which case the BMW does cost $200 more per month than the Tesla, but it absolutely cannot be subtracted from the Tesla's cost.
Every lease I've been a part on (none luxury) has the buyback price in the contract.
- the savings from fuel/maintenance/etc are very real, not wishful thinking. The math is true for total cost of ownership
- no downpayment due to the tax refunds
- guaranteed buyback, not something you'll find anywhere else
In the absolute worst case it's a standard lease + buyback guarantee, so how can it be "expensive"?