source: I distinctly recalled using this as an argument against my dad when he told me to focus :P
Yeah, "fall in love" isn't that concrete, I know. But again, it works for me if I manage to rotate the types of content I consume.
About the last topic, I give you that. But I'll choose reading a good article to watching trash TV or gossip news any time of the day.
Anyway thanks for taking to time to deconstruct some of the ideas I wrote. I think this topic has too few people writing and thinking about it.
Thanks – the first point is the important one, the latter ideally should be a no-brainer. :)[0]
> But I'll choose reading a good article to watching trash TV or gossip news any time of the day.
Of course, the heuristics that icebraining mentioned come into play here, in a validity to the extent that it is generally safe to assume little to no information on trash TV.
However, heuristics are still heuristics and there are – in my experience – always sufficiently many borderline cases where heuristics will fail and the love-it-or-leave-it attitude makes you stick to one particular newspaper[1], leading you to become uninformed about the arguments of the ‘other side’.
[0] If someone could make a rule please about the relative position of emoticons and punctuation…
[1] Granted, the internet alleviated that issue somewhat, but just the choosing of news Google delivers to you based on your past reading might act somewhat like that, recreating the bubble that was formerly built by newspapers.
About emoticons and punctuation, I deal with that on a daily basis too. Ugh.
On the face of it yes, on the other hand, there's a ton of crap out there, and the fact that someone wrote a book about something is on it's own a poor indicator for wether it's going to teach you something meaningful. Reading some of it seems to be a better indicator.
Also, abandoning a book doesn't mean abandoning the subject. Sometimes you need a different author and angle and sometimes a more basic primer on the subject before tackling the main work.
That applies to any decision; you rarely or never have complete information. The solution is to apply heuristics to make a preliminary judgment. For example, by coming to HN instead of any other source of articles you're implicitly deciding that being linked from here means there's a greater probability of the article being good (for any definition of good you prefer).
Actually, I spent most of the time I spent here on /newest, where this is guaranteed to a smaller degree[0], offering a relatively diverse random subset of whatever someone wrote on the internet.
[0] Maybe apart from ‘X married Y but held hands with Z!!!!’.
We're all heavily filtering what we consume, it's effectively impossible to do otherwise.
But can you give me an example of the opposite? Say, an article or book which did not grab you at first but you found quite interesting. (being the keyword "interesting", a subjective concept to each and everyone of us, of course - myself included)
Faust II, though you might not want to learn German just to read it – written 20 years after Faust I, with the knowledge accumulated during the lifetime of one of the world’s greatest authors poured into it; while definitely not attention-grabbing in any way and taking some time to get into, the hours I spent reading it were certainly one of the best spent hours so far.
I always found this about the single most obvious faux-pas of Sherlock Holmes – if you give your brain enough time to properly organise the data, it does have (nearly) infinite storage. Choosing carefully what to read and what to ignore only leads to less information, in turn making it more difficult to build links between different ‘information islands’ and hence retaining said information more easily.
> Basically, if I don’t instantly fall in love with an article/book/blog, I stop reading and move on.
I don’t know the definition of ‘fall in love’ here, but this sounds rather dangerous as well, as it makes it more difficult to learn actually new things and supports living in one’s own little bubble of information.
> Getting informed is a means to an end, not an end in itself. And life’s too short for bad information.
But how to decide whether a given datum is ‘bad’ or ‘good’ information before consuming said datum and linking it up with the rest of your memory? Maybe it looks utterly senseless at the time you first read it, but it might well be missing piece linking two large and so far separate areas together.