I'm a little confused by what you mean. Do you mean what he's afraid about doesn't matter that much? Considering the massive patent lawsuits flying around I think that's pretty blatantly false. I mean, some of this has been ameliorated by industry's unexpected generosity towards the open source world (Google via a ton of shit, Apple via LLVM), but certainly not all of it.
Personally, I've stopped ignoring what Stallman is saying. I'm not saying he doesn't have a side of him that worries about completely irrelevant shit, but I think he's been proven well enough on important topics that he deserves our (as hackers, consumers, and business owners) respect, even if you decide you disagree with him.
Put another way. RMS has warned about the dangers of hot water and has spent a lifetime taking cold showers. He's right of course, hot water can be dangerous, but warm water is just fine and gets things done.
He's presenting a binary choice when its not the choice that matters. It's about how hot the water can get for your needs and not be dangerous is where all the important things are happening.
I don't really care about what RMS says because it locks you into thinking binary extremes. Free or evil, the past or some hypothetical future, when it's the now that matters.
You don't think massive adoption of open source software would not at all imply that all the R&D effort spent on everything else over the last decades would have shifted to that instead?
And, please, could you be more of a contributor and less like an aggressive drunk starting a bar fight?
I guess you could say Stallman wasn't wrong exactly, just unnecessarily alarmist over this particular issue. I'm not saying software patents are benign, by the way - I'm only addressing mp3 here.
Who knows what knock on effects that might have had? Chrome and Mozilla could have had WebRTC happening years ago with a patent royalty free H.264, or a family of codecs that evolved from it, rather than waste their time (and a quarter of a billion dollars) on trying to break the codec monopolies. Less Flash, less IE, less Windows, more competition. What's not to like?
edit: or flip it the other way. If browsers or the web were patented, how many consumers would celebrate the day those patents expired? None, because all the good things that flowed from them not being patented would never have happened. "So Microsoft made a few more millions" they'd say, I mean its not like browsing the web ever became a big deal.
Calling someone out after the fact for warning about the potential for harm when the risk is very real based on what happened in the past just sounds like revisionism.
On one hand, it's possible that mp3 could have become the defacto standard by being widely available, and then had the patent holders clamp down and raise prices. This didn't happen, and I don't think it was likely to happen.
RS' writings always have two parts. First, he predicts what could happen if things keep going in the current direction. He's quite good at this, because he's a smart guy, and all of his predictions I'm familiar with reflect a future that I think is technically possible. Second, however, is the tone and gravity he assigns to the consequences and likelihood of those possible futures. I find those parts of his writing to be unreasonably pessimistic and actively harmful in avoiding real problems.
He's unnecessarily alarmist on all the issues he cares about. And because of that, he's bound to be right once in a while, but since it's impossible to determine when to listen to him, he's as accurate as a coin toss.
But that's just an opinion - I guess it's possible a lot of people were put off by the hoops necessary to install an mp3 player, although to be honest I don't recall it being a problem for a good decade or so now.
You say the MP3 patent really did no harm; what harm did it not do? And of the harm that it did not do, what harm do other software patents do?
1. He is a grating and uncompromising lunatic, and does not make any attempts to present himself as agreeable to other people.
2. He's been proven completely correct on everything he's warned us of in this industry to date.