News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Richard Stallman on the Ogg Vorbis license (2001) by freehunter on Friday March 29, 2013 @02:41PM (#5462270)
It's easy to look back and say "see, it didn't do any harm!" Predicting the future is much more difficult, and it's perfectly reasonable to look at past trends in that prediction. If Frauenhofer had stopped giving out licenses, would you still be making that argument? If they started patent trolling, what would you be saying?

Calling someone out after the fact for warning about the potential for harm when the risk is very real based on what happened in the past just sounds like revisionism.

Re:Richard Stallman on the Ogg Vorbis license (2001) by aeturnum on Friday March 29, 2013 @03:32PM (#5462573)
This section of the discussion has entirely been about hindsight, specifically that RS has always been right.

On one hand, it's possible that mp3 could have become the defacto standard by being widely available, and then had the patent holders clamp down and raise prices. This didn't happen, and I don't think it was likely to happen.

RS' writings always have two parts. First, he predicts what could happen if things keep going in the current direction. He's quite good at this, because he's a smart guy, and all of his predictions I'm familiar with reflect a future that I think is technically possible. Second, however, is the tone and gravity he assigns to the consequences and likelihood of those possible futures. I find those parts of his writing to be unreasonably pessimistic and actively harmful in avoiding real problems.

Re:Richard Stallman on the Ogg Vorbis license (2001) by tome on Friday March 29, 2013 @03:13PM (#5462477)
It's very hard to say what Frauenhofer would have done if Vorbis didn't exist. Likely the situation would have been very different.