As I've said somewhere lower in the comments, two things would have made a world of difference here.
1. GS should have had an e-mail notification system in place. They should notify any company, much less 37Signals, that there's been a question posted on their forums. Same can be said for UserVoice and any other third-party site who wants to get into this game. Had they notified the support people at 37Signals, none of this would have come to bear.
2. Jason, no matter how angry he is/was, should have NOT used a public forum for dealing with this issue immediately. Had he talked to GS's admins/support through e-mail privately, there'd be no need for this hubbub. If the e-mail route did not work, then I agree with denouncing GS publicly.
All I'm alluding to here is maturity. There are good ways of handling issues and then there are bad ones. Even if Jason has a good point about GS's business conduct, it's lost, not just on me, based solely on his approach to it.
I've never denied that what GS was at best misleading, however, I don't think that going public without trying to resolve matters privately is very mature. In this case, GS has responded positively, but things could have shaped differently had there been another Jason Fried on the other side.
37s: The Get Satisfaction business model is dangerously close to extortion.
GS: We didn't realize it, but you're right. We're doing X, Y, and Z to fix it right now. We're sorry.
37s: Also there's 10x more 37s branding on your pages than GS branding, which is misleading.
GS: You know what? You're right about that too. We thought the branding would help our users, but it's turning out to be misleading. We're doing X, Y, and Z to rebadge the pages, and we're sorry.
37s: ...
Peanut Gallery 1: GS misled the whole Internet?
Peanut Gallery 2: Yeah, and they apologized. That all you got?
Peanut Gallery 1: ...
Peanut Gallery 2: ...
Instead, because GS apparently doesn't know how to concede a point cleanly and end the discussion, they're going to remain the center of attention for awhile. And while all publicity is in a sense good publicity, the people they make money from are hearing nothing except "trademark infringement" and "customer service horror story".
The initial reply from GS that promised to change the phrasing on their site seemed, to me at least, disingenuous, like a kid caught with their hand in the cookie jar.
You know what this is just getting too complicated.
Everyone on the Internet has a soapbox. Jason Fried/37S has a much bigger soapbox than the average disgruntled blogger/user because of their huge reader base.
The irony in the "this could have been a lawsuit" is that their reply could have been too, since I suspect they'd have a pretty good case for a defamation suit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_defamation_law#De...
"Guys x, y and z need to change in the next week or we're going to rip you apart on our blog and possibly sue for trademark violation. -37s"
Plus a private email does nothing for the little guys that have no clout, who would be completely ignored if they made the same complaints. 37s helped far more people than themselves by doing this.
I'm a founder too, so I'm mostly imagining myself in their shoes and how angry I'd be if somebody took a very public swing at my company without giving me a chance to make it right. I'm sure the 37s guys are as protective of "their baby". ;-)
I wouldn't like GS's chances if they'd tried a slap-suit against 37S, even if they hadn't publicly admitted every factual point, apologized, and blamed every "misinterpretation" of their motives on their own poor communication skills.
(This is why I've been left wondering at people who saw the post as a tossed-off rant. It was a detailed, edited, and thoughtful complaint.)
How is that not claiming that they're engaging in extortion?
Amusingly, if you click on the wikipedia link above, and follow the reference to the bit on per se defamation, the example given is claiming that someone extorted money that did not.
GS certainly don't seem to think they would have a case.
That can be especially said for this follow-up post. If there was no need for the original one, there's absolutely no need for this one. If Jason thought that there are design considerations GS needed to think about, this whole post should have then gone privately.
However, opting to blog about it publicly so that one of GS's founders can go and say "Right, we got it. We will include it in our redesign" is, at best, pulling rank.
Sarah Hatter had said that she answers thousands of support e-mails every year. Saying it's not scalable to send an e-mail to a company you have a grievance with is childish.
So it seems like Jason is simply playing by their rules no?
The need was: their business was being hurt by the presence of the GS page that looked official but wasn't. If that doesn't count as a need, wtf does?
Your neighbour trespasses on your farm. Moreover, he builds a small store on it with no permits and when he gets tagged for it by the inspector, he points to you as it's your farm. Do you:
a) Find him, take him to the town square and publicly whip him in front of the whole town? b) Take him to court for trespassing?
You seem to have a bit of a fixation on criticism as some sort of injury.
Publicly whipping someone in a town square will cause more mental anguish than physical pain. It's intended to embarrass that person, as well as scare anyone else watching. Please point out where I have gone wrong with the drawing of these parallels.
This public criticism elicited awareness of the behavior for people who might have gone to GS unaware of their practices. It elicited GS to amend at least some of their practices. The only observers plausibly "scared" by this are people who want to build a business that involves impersonating other companies.
Including such words, however, is not "publicly criticizing" someone nor "outright denouncing them in stern but entirely truthful terms". They're meant to incite the other side. They're there to show righteous anger and having as many readers as 37Signals does, it's completely out of bounds.
Combine that with the complete and utter lack of professionalism displayed by Jason and that post can, and will be, taken as public shaming of GS.
Public shaming is not criticism nor denouncement. But yes, you're right. The only companies scared will be the ones who want to follow a similar model.
Of course, I'd have preferred to have the technical issues pointed out so that those up-and-coming companies can learn from this debacle, but I guess appealing to people's fears is much better. After all, that's what most of the world's governments have been doing to their people, so why expect more from our technical leaders.
The funny thing is, the same could be said for people using GS for airing their grievances. A company that hosts a public forum that solicits features/changes/complaints from people can't seriously expect someone to use a private channel to suggest features/changes/complaints, can they?
That's downright hypocritical in my book.
The only way GS makes sense is if you've tried to contact a company in order to register a complaint and were not successful:
1) You got a generic e-mail back, knowing that your issue will never be looked at.
2) The company does not have any sort of contact information available on their site.
If users of GS register complaints there, GS should forward those complaints to the company in question. That makes sense to me. If GS does not do that, then that's a problem.
However, that does not mean that you can air your grievance with them publicly until all other means have failed. It's logical, no?
I think that 37signals did the right thing. This issue doesn't just affect 37signals, it affects a lot of other companies.
In my opinion, 37signals were obliged to talk about this publicly. If they sent some private mails, a lot of people and companies would still be in the dark regarding the issue. They had a responsibility to call bullshit.