"Guys x, y and z need to change in the next week or we're going to rip you apart on our blog and possibly sue for trademark violation. -37s"
Plus a private email does nothing for the little guys that have no clout, who would be completely ignored if they made the same complaints. 37s helped far more people than themselves by doing this.
I'm a founder too, so I'm mostly imagining myself in their shoes and how angry I'd be if somebody took a very public swing at my company without giving me a chance to make it right. I'm sure the 37s guys are as protective of "their baby". ;-)
I wouldn't like GS's chances if they'd tried a slap-suit against 37S, even if they hadn't publicly admitted every factual point, apologized, and blamed every "misinterpretation" of their motives on their own poor communication skills.
(This is why I've been left wondering at people who saw the post as a tossed-off rant. It was a detailed, edited, and thoughtful complaint.)
How is that not claiming that they're engaging in extortion?
Amusingly, if you click on the wikipedia link above, and follow the reference to the bit on per se defamation, the example given is claiming that someone extorted money that did not.
GS certainly don't seem to think they would have a case.
The irony in the "this could have been a lawsuit" is that their reply could have been too, since I suspect they'd have a pretty good case for a defamation suit.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_defamation_law#De...