That isn't true but why it isn't true is not immediately obvious. Google reader drives a ton of traffic, what that means in real terms is that there are a huge body of people who don't have time to regularly visit a blog, but they do have time to look quickly at what 10 or 15 blogs have recently posted. Thus they discover where there is an interesting article on "your" blog and visit. That is how it drives traffics to otherwise poorly visited blogs. It is more effective than G+, Organic Search, and Facebook in that regard.
Those bloggers that benefit from this feed do feed themselves and possibly their family on income they get from their writing either in ad-clicks or affiliate links.
When Reader goes away, a number of those blogs will be hurt, and those people will be scrambling to find other ways to drive traffic to their sites.
Now this will also hurt Google because there is a crap ton of AdSense for Content advertising on those blogs, and I expect that what use there had been of Blogger will drop below the 'minimum sustainable point' and so Blogger too will get tossed into the spring cleaning trash bin. Now its probably not noticeable (much) the last time we (Blekko search engined) looked through the blog crawls in depth Google was the dominant ad network provider on those blogs, but they do something like 3.7B$ of revenue in 'Partner sites' [1] per quarter and 1% of that being tossed out the window is only 37M$ per quarter (or about 150M$ for the year) isn't a huge loss for them but its going to hit a number of their "partners" quite sharply.
Unlike sites which are bogus flick-n-click ad reapers these folks are actually trying to use the system in the way it is supposed to work, they write quality content and Google helps them monetize it.
The thing that few people "get" about Google isn't that they are a search monopoly (they aren't) it is that they are an advertising monopoly (which they are). They are synonymous with "internet advertising" and having dealt with a lot of advertising partners, they all seem to end up re-selling Google's ads in one way or another. Its like having three different pizza restaurants but only one kitchen.
I'm hopeful that this will create opportunities for actually new advertising networks to appear> We'll have to wait and see though.
[1] http://investor.google.com/earnings/2012/Q4_google_earnings....
I don't think anyone uses that as the criteria of what should be made public. People rely on car companies and grocery stores to get home and feed their children, but economists aren't fighting to make those public. And federal parks are hardly critical infrastructure but I don't know many people who complain that they are public.
The article is written from a purely theoretical economic perspective, it's not a real proposal, so it's worth addressing it from that perspective. Krugman's argument is basically that there are certain products that add global value but cannot exist without people being forced to pay for it. Many economists - not all - agree this is a good criteria of what should be made public (infrastructure and research would fall in this category). It's hard to imagine that web services could fall under this, but I suspect a lot of people forget that the internet is still in its infancy and companies like google have been able to subsidize loss-creators through insanely high profits. That won't last, google is already scaling back, and the result may be a global destruction in value.
(To be clear I don't want to see things like google reader made public for idealogical reasons, and I think you and most people are the same way, but I think that's out of the scope of addressing Krugman's point)
Basically it says following: * some people I know are upset * we know from economics, but often forget, that some products can be not viable even if people are willing to pay for them * historical solution is to make them public service which also to Krugman seems hard to envison
Nowhere does he say anything about importance of Reader.
Most clients point to Reader as the central feed aggregator. Most publishers point to Feedburner as the central publisher.
Google seized the commanding heights with Feedburner and Google Reader and captured all the publishers and the clients, and now they're killing the ecosystem.
http://www.zdnet.com/embrace-extend-extinguish-how-google-cr...
I don't see why they couldn't have integrated Reader into Plus without killing the ecosystem. Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn are moving into news aggregation, and Google is killing a successful news aggregation system.
I don't understand their strategy, but it's seems sort of like, we want everyone on G+ and we don't care how heavy-handed we look or how early adopters feel, and we don't want an open ecosystem that people can use to pipe content into Twitter and Facebook.
It's about economics, particularly as they apply to something with fixed-to-increasing costs but with users for whom the value has a fixed upper limit and is declining based on the intensity of their usage. There's a lot more here than complaining and pseudo-analysis. It's a Nobel Prize winning economist talking about pricing models as they apply to usage/cost/scale!
He does describe interesting models/theories, but I don't actually think they're relevant. It seems cheap and link-baity.
Right, that's the point. This is a common style in economic blogs. They often follow the form: assuming some set of data, what are the economic implications?
> He does describe interesting models/theories, but I don't actually think they're relevant.
Right, they may or may not be relevant to this specific case (Reader), but I still found it interesting to learn about.
> It seems cheap and link-baity.
Hmmm, here we have a distinguished economist, who could no doubt live easily from his university job, instead spends time trying to bring scientific economic analysis to popular topics. Not sure how that is cheap and link-baity.
He does have a knack for catchy titles, though. If you aren't familiar with his blog style, "evil google" probably sounds bad (and emotionally charged), but I really doubt it was meant to be taken literally.
Meh... you could make a pretty compelling argument that economics isn't a science, and a pretty compelling argument that Krugman is a radical ideologue who is good at marketing himself. In any case, whether he's distinguished or not, whether or not he has a Nobel Prize, how else he could theoretically support himself, don't really enter into it... evaluating this piece of content (as well as any other) should be done on it's merits (or lack thereof).
It's kinda disappointing in this case, because that actually is a really interesting article from an economic perspective. But when he mixes it in with his psuedo-socialist, big government, leftist ideology, it immediately turns a lot of people off. I almost didn't click through just because it was Krugman. But he sucked me in with the catchy title. :-)
What are you talking about? What part of the article made that impression on you and why?
So what’s the answer? As Avent says, historical examples with these characteristics — like urban transport networks — have been resolved through public provision. It seems hard at this point to envision search and related functions as public utilities, but that’s arguably where the logic will eventually lead us.
alludes to his ideology. But to be fair to Krugman, he is quoting somebody else, or referring to the works of others, for big chunks of this article, so I can't be too harsh on him.
I have to agree. Google is very efficient at profiting from casual users unwilling to pay, but clearly they just didn't exist.
Don't get riled up, this was a piece by Paul Krugman. He thinks government should own /control / regulate everything.
[0] http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/mediawire/130485/claim-kr...
I like to use free services from Google, Twitter, and Facebook, but I certainly don't want to rely on them for business.
An analogy: my family likes to support small local businesses. For web services, hosting, etc., I prefer using companies that I pay fairly for services and who support me.
On March 13, Google announced it's killing Reader; that's 10 days a go. http://googleblog.blogspot.nl/2013/03/a-second-spring-of-cle...
I know I'll be complaining about this for quite some time to come.
Google isn't a monopolist in this situation either, but it is useful to understand pricing dynamics where there is no competitor. It sheds light on price discrimination with coupons, for example.
Krugman mischaracterizes the article[1], since it does not claim that Reader was crucial infrastructure, but he doesn't argue that it is crucial infrastructure himself either. They both talk about the dynamics of a product that has network effects and becomes a public good.
We generally know from cognitive sciences how we economize in situations like having a reliably knowledgeable colleague. This has served as a counterpoint to the silly arguments about how Google is making us stupid, but nevertheless says that the specialization in our expertise that it facilitates has Google search's continued availability as a vital component.
The original article talks about whether discontinuations will cause users to be more cautious about adopting services that create dependencies, and whether it will inhibit the success of new ones that involve network effects.
>Google wants us to use its services in ways that provide it with interesting and valuable information, and eyeballs. If a particular Google experiment isn't cutting it in that category, then Google may feel justified in axing it.
>But that makes it increasingly difficult for Google to have success with new services. Why commit to using and coming to rely on something new if it might be yanked away at some future date? This is especially problematic for "social" apps that rely on network effects. Even a crummy social service may thrive if it obtains a critical mass.
Anyway, the important issues aren't perfectly typified by Reader, but it is a situation people are familiar with at this moment. Personally, I think it is worth thinking about why more of the shuttered projects haven't been sold off or at least open sourced like Wave. Combine that with profitable businesses that are acquired for the talent, then neglected to death, and it sounds like a lot of effort is being needlessly trashed.
It is not difficult to imagine that if books.google.com were able to give even more liberal access to its library, that struggling municipalities would be even less willing to fund their libraries. This hypothetical would be unambiguously good for the world if it lead to more access to information, but one can also imagine that this hypothetical could also lead to a dependency that was itself vulnerable.
There are a lot of things that won't lead to the end of civilization, but they can still be nevertheless worse than an alternate outcome.
[1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2013/03/utilitie...
This perspective just boggles my mind. If anyone decides not to use a Google product because it could "disappear just like Reader" or something, they are shooting themselves in the foot.
First, any product (especially web sites), made by Google or otherwise, can disappear. If it's not a profitable product/market, it will go away, whether it's run by Google or some guy in a basement.
Secondly, even if you suspect a product will eventually disappear, why not chose to use a superior product while it's around? This is especially true for something as inconsequential and fungible as an RSS reader. I mean, in retrospect, do hard-core Reader users wish they could go back in time and chose a different product instead of Reader for all these years? What would be the benefit of that? Whatever choice you made could have also disappeared. And if your answer is that you would have still used Reader, than that's all the evidence you need to know you shouldn't hesitate to use a new Google product, if it's the best option.
Maybe you recall a chapter in Cannery Row where a gopher sets up in a perfect vacant lot full of everything it needs and without predators. (Or not, and I suppose the value of allusions rest on the network effects of a common canon) The gopher flourishes, but ultimately gives up because no female gophers ever appear, and it returns to a garden with gopher traps set out. The allegory is an accessible way to explain network effects, something that is often lost in the entrepreneurial rhetoric, where companies succeed or not regardless of the market environment or context of the community they foster or don't.
When choosing a large development platform, anyone reasonable doesn't only look at the tools and languages, but also considers the community and the market. Take for example Blackberry or the Windows Phone. I don't think developers believe that anyone owes them certain tools, or even a guarantee of a certain number of sales. However, these platforms will only get good talent if there is a credible marketability of anything they develop.
Hypothetically, lets assume that Visual Studio works really well for developing on Windows Phone and is better than any other set of tools for mobile development. Then let's assume that in 2015, Microsoft stops creating phone operating systems because the phones remain unpopular. A lot of developers have spent a couple years learning skills, much of which they can use elsewhere. If they'd been developing for Android or iOS, they would have even more skills that would be useful elsewhere. Now, someone shouts at you, "So you're saying that Microsoft shouldn't have released such a good set of tools?!" The question itself is silly.
The problem is not reducible to a set of tools, or evangelizing to developers, or confidence in the platform, or advertising to consumers. Assumptions about all of these together go into developers' decision making today, and it isn't even that deterministic, since there's an error component to how these perceptions that aren't based on accurate future-prediction, that will itself decide the future success of the platform.
The original Economist post didn't so much talk about Google owing anyone anything, but addressed the confidence problem. If people believe that a product won't be around very long, it won't get talented developers which won't attract users, which will lead to the product being canceled, or vice versa.
Let's say you want to put a small module on your webpage, and you are considering Google Gadgets. It might be more difficult to replicate the same functionality using HTML5. Are you worse off, because Google Gadgets is available? Google doesn't owe you any guarantee about the longevity of the system, but it would be more valuable right now if you could believe that Google Gadgets will still be around in a couple years, and your payoff matrix says that you would be worse off if you choose Google Gadgets over something else and it is later canceled.
Google Reader is being shutdown but I doubt that when they launched they said to themselves "We will run this service until 2013 and then shut it down". Without that plan I don't think it can be planned obsolescence.
No, both Krugman and Avent are talking about private goods with fixed costs to the producer.
Network effects might increase the consumer surplus, but that's all. They aren't that important to the analysis. The important part here is the inability of the producer to engage in price discrimination.
Both focus on the value of the community itself, the public good that emerges from the physical infrastructure that is privately built, that its value increases with size, that growth is influenced by size, and that early adopters are likely influenced by guesses about longevity.
The analysis could be wrong over the long term, but there is a growing consensus summed up in another front page post[1] right now, that describes how Google has caused some damage to its brand. Some of which is likely being felt right now in the chilled enthusiasm around the release of Google Keep—a product that relies on network effects more than Google Reader does.
[1]http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/03/finale...
Google Reader had a massive user base when compared to other RSS readers, but it's hardly a monopoly. I'd understand the uproar if it was the ONLY RSS reader to ever exist, and ever to be possible. There are alternatives. The very definition of monopoly is that you do not have a choice. Remember the old Bell system? Now that was a monopoly. (It used to be illegal to plug in phones not bought from the phone company.)
Google was operating in a space with lots of players, they just happened to have large market share. They weren't doing anything anticompetitive, and there wasn't any barrier to entry beyond 'You have to do it better than Google, and get your name out there'.
Krugman should really do some research on what monopolists do, starting off with Standard Oil. The internet is a highly competitive environment.
"seems hard at this point to envision search and related functions as public utilities, but that’s arguably where the logic will eventually lead us."
That is the "logical conclusion" for people of his ilk.
And I'm not surprised by the first comment that I found on the article:
It is the height of capitalist folly to insist that a profit-seeking corporation is the right form of organization for operating facitilites that become essential global public utilities.
Why of course. This guy is just random article commenter, but you know your average, hardcore leftist thinks the same way. Facebook must come under UN or some other quasi-governmental control. It needs to be controlled. Well, duh...
Can we have a reality check? It's an RSS reader. It was really good. Now it's shutting down. Nobody relies on it to get to work so they can feed their children. Building a replacement doesn't require digging tunnels, buying trains, hiring drivers. The economic argument is interesting, but I'm wondering if this wins for 'Most Hyperbolic Google Reader Shutdown Article'.