News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by pg on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @05:46PM (#5410599)
This entire thesis is a red herring. I doubt we've ever had a conversation with a startup about what sort of benefits they should offer. Since the startups in a position to hire lots of people will presumably have raised money from later stage investors, if anyone is giving them advice about this, it would probably be them.

FWIW, if anyone did ask my advice about what benefits to offer, I'd tell them to err on the side of generosity. I certainly tell them to err on that side with equity grants.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by zallarak on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:05PM (#5410740)
Interesting you say this, because when I was an employee at a YC company, I was told that YC partners thought I was overpaid (while making "below market" and working lots of overtime and heavily contributing, and basically using my necessity as leverage to negotiate what partners thought was an 'overpaid' salary). NOTE: I am very grateful for my time there, but I wanted to point this out.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by michaelochurch on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:05PM (#5411223)
I have no idea who you are or what company you worked for, but a lot of things are blamed on "investors" that are actually management's own detested ideas. It's a somewhat dishonest negotiation tactic: It's Not Up To Me.

It's unfair that YC is being singled out here. These are genuine VC-istan issues, not limited to YC startups.

All of the YC founders I know are great, but sample size is small.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by vinceguidry on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:00PM (#5411174)
I would have assumed that a deep conversation on hiring would be part of the YC program, as it is indeed non-trivial yet essential, but from this post and re-reading the "What happens at Y Combinator" page, it appears that YC is mostly geared towards getting founders funding. There just isn't enough time in the day to convey everything.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by pg on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:37PM (#5411477)
It's not so much that we don't have time as that hiring is not the startups' focus at the early stage where we spend most time with them. We mostly talk about what to build and how to get users.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by dools on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:07PM (#5412309)
You do skew quite young in your choice of founder, though don't you?

I didn't see anything in the article state that you guys were explicitly advising founders to do these things. One of the first things the OP says is:

"YC seems to be a cult which is quite adept at turning college students into millionaires while creating billions of dollars of wealth for Venture Capitalists."

So the outcomes he's referring to may just be a direct result of the level of prior business experience amongst people you accept into the program.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by pg on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @10:15PM (#5412336)
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by guptaneil on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:14PM (#5410796)
I'd argue that being less generous with benefits is a good filter for hiring candidates that are genuinely interested in what the startup's doing (which is crucial in early employees) rather than somebody who's just looking for another job, like the author.

Edit: To clarify, there is huge difference between offering no benefits and offering fewer benefits than a large company. I'm not advocating treating employees like crap. I'm saying that there is a potential benefit to startups who don't try to compete on monetary benefits. Startups should provide as many benefits as possible, but not worry about competing with the financial packages that a large company can provide.

Also, if you disagree, please give your reasoning below. Downvoting to show disagreement just seems lazy.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by avenger123 on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:24PM (#5410873)
This is a good point, so why not just come out and say it!

I see a lot about how these start-ups state "competitive salary, great compensation, etc."

Instead, just say, "hey, we will pay you crap but come work for us anyway because you believe in our idea."

Somehow, I don't think that would get traction, when its put that way.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by dinkumthinkum on Thursday March 21, 2013 @03:32AM (#5413550)
You might want to add "... and you think we are cool personalities and you want us to get rich of the back of your labor." :)
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by argonaut on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:45PM (#5411057)
I call BS. Sure, you could spin it that way. You could also spin it the other way: a startup that doesn't offer benefits doesn't care about making their employees' lives easier, and thus not offering benefits is a negative signal to potential employees.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by guptaneil on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:51PM (#5411096)
Just because a startup doesn't offer lots of monetary benefits doesn't mean it doesn't respect its employees. Generally, the advantage of a startup is that you get far greater independence and autonomy than in a large corporation. You have to personally weigh what matters to you more: money or independence. My point was that startups should favor employees who want independence more than money because as it has been said above, being an employee at a startup is a losing proposition. At least the startup will have optimized for hiring people that are ok with that.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by aplusbi on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:15PM (#5411291)
You just pointed out why your argument fails - it's a poor indicator. A company that doesn't offer lots of benefits may or may not respect its employees. Likewise an employee willing to accept a below-market offer may or may not be committed to the vision.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2013 @05:41AM (#5413933)
>Likewise an employee willing to accept a below-market offer may or may not be committed to the vision.

What vision? I thought we are all professionals working for the money.

It seems bleeding edge capitalism forgets the "free market" and "egoism turns out for the best" and resorts to idealism and religious-like "visions" for the company -- in order to have fools work for less than they could.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by coldtea on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:18AM (#5415603)
>Uh, I'm not sure why you're responding to me as my point was that offering below market salaries to try and get "good" employees is a stupid idea.

Hi, I wasn't answering to your comment as it is, just got inspiration from your "vision" quote (something that one hears often repeated from startup guys).

>That said, most people don't work solely for money and I'm sure you don't either. If they did, then everyone would want to work on Wall Street.

Sure (I also care for the work environment, tech involved etc), but that doesn't mean I work for some "vision" or that I even believe that 99% of startups even have a vision worthy of mention.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by aplusbi on Thursday March 21, 2013 @11:10AM (#5415544)
Uh, I'm not sure why you're responding to me as my point was that offering below market salaries to try and get "good" employees is a stupid idea.

That said, most people don't work solely for money and I'm sure you don't either. If they did, then everyone would want to work on Wall Street.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by argonaut on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:53PM (#5411594)
What does money have to do with independence? Can't you richly reward autonomous engineers? Are you suggesting there is an inverse correlation between independence and benefits? Are you suggesting there is a mutually exclusive zero-sum relationship between attention paid to benefits and attention paid to independence? All of these are unfounded assumptions.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by guptaneil on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:28PM (#5412129)
I didn't claim that money and independence are mutually exclusive (though I can see how that may have been interpreted). Instead, I made 2 assumptions.

1. Startups don't have as much money as a large corporation.

2. You, as an engineer, have more autonomy at a startup than a large corporation.

The reason I would choose to work at a startup over a corporation is because I value my autonomy, even if it means making less money than I would if I took a job at a large company. When I am a 45 year old father, my priorities will probably change. There's nothing wrong with that.

The question at hand is, should startups try to compete with large corporations on benefit packages? Benefits are important to feeling welcome and appreciated at work. At no point have I claimed otherwise.

My sole claim has been that if I had to make a tradeoff between certain benefits (that don't necessarily impact me as a young recent college graduate) and increased autonomy, I will pick autonomy. This is why startups optimize for recruiting younger developers. If a young developer thinks an idea is cool and believes in it, she will work her ass off. A 45 year old father, on the other hand, has other priorities. To reiterate, there is nothing wrong with that! But if a startup cannot afford to support such an experienced programmer (startups can't offer competitive salary, job safety, 401k, etc), it's better for the 45yo father to consider that before hand, rather than get burned later.

If the startup had offered him the same benefits and salary as the large company, he may have accepted the startup's offer. The startup could then go out of business in 2 months, and he'd be screwed. A young college graduate would have far more flexibility to bounce back and find another job, simply because the younger developer has fewer responsibilities.

A startup should offer as many benefits as it can. But the reality is that most startups simply cannot provide the same benefits as a large company, and I think that's ok. It's really not as evil as the author makes it seem because startups are targeting a different demographic than him.

If a startup's lack of benefits aren't acceptable to you, then you probably also shouldn't be taking the many other risks involved with doing a startup.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by kevingibbon on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:19PM (#5410830)
If your startup is well funded you should offer these benefits. You should want to reward the people who work so hard for you.

These benefits also make an employees life easier, giving them more time to spend on your precious startup.

There are other ways to weed out the "another job" candidates.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by Mamady on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:43PM (#5411037)
These are not "another job" candidates. These are A grade candidates who are not desparate enough to take any lame offer they get (unlike recent grads with little experience).

When someone in the valley says "there is a shortage of talent", what they really mean is... there is a shortage of "talent willing to work for a pathetic salary".

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by granitepail on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @06:53PM (#5411113)
Taking away benefits to see which candidates are the "hungriest" seems lazy - and unethical - to me. It's not easy to source good candidates, but it seems completely backwards to find the best, most driven candidates possible through a method that, in the end, deprives them of something you could easily deliver.

I've worked with companies who have a 1-month "escape hatch" on-boarding plan, wherein either the employer or employee can terminate the agreement no-harm-no-foul if expectations are not aligned. This is obviously more of a social agreement, as most companies use at-will employment contracts. This way, you can still treat your employees right.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by vacri on Thursday March 21, 2013 @06:59AM (#5414196)
It's funny, really. Coming from an OH&S perspective, you want good OH&S not just because it's nice, but because losing a worker is expensive - rehiring, retraining, refamiliarising (it always takes a new employee time to learn the ropes). Scrooging people on basic benefits seems to be in the same bucket as scrooging them on OH&S - saves money in the short term but is overall more costly.
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by mikeash on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:30PM (#5411843)
Why concentrate on benefits. Being less generous with everything is a good filter for hiring candidates that are genuinely interested in what the startup's doing! Pay your employees poorly, and you're guaranteed to only get the ones who really believe in your company. You're virtually guaranteed success, right?
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by guptaneil on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:53PM (#5412259)
If you take any comment to its absolute extreme, it will stop making sense. If you consider my comment from the more reasonable stance that startups have limited resources compared to large companies and come with extra risks for employees, the fewer benefits can be valuable for dissuading people who might not otherwise be good culture fits.

For example, a 45 year old father who might be screwed if the startup shuts down 2 months later probably should not be applying to startups. However, a young recent college grad will have a much easier time bouncing back if the startup shuts down, simply because she has fewer responsibilities than the father. As a result, a lot of those benefits that the father is looking for are also less important to the recent college grad.

Of course, the startup should give the best possible benefits it can afford. But I don't see anything wrong with the startup focusing its limited resources on finding the employees that are better fits.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by mikeash on Thursday March 21, 2013 @08:51AM (#5414651)
Funny, I didn't think that was even remotely an extreme. An extreme here would be something like, "Charge people money to work at your company, that way you only get the most extremely dedicated." Simply paying less salary in addition to giving fewer benefits seems like an extremely minor extension.

There's nothing wrong with paying less because your resources are better placed elsewhere. I just don't buy the idea that paying less gets you better candidates. Sure, it might filter, a little bit, for people who really care about your business. But it's also going to filter, a lot, for people who can't get better jobs elsewhere.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by dinkumthinkum on Thursday March 21, 2013 @03:30AM (#5413542)
This is exactly what's wrong with many tech startups and what makes caricatures of them. You're view is to be a stingy miser and just believe that you will be filtering out those that want to exchange work for money (what a horrible idea in a capitalist economy). So you get the kids that do understand what equity means or what "vesting" means or "at will" employment means that are excited, they burn off a couple years of their 20s not realizing that even if this supposed great idea was successful that they basically get nothing anyway, and you're arguing that is the proper way to be? It's hard to argue the economics of that for your favor .. but you can see how unsustainable that would be if all the founders felt the way you did and the works ... gasp .. actually figured this out. I think there have been a few events in history that have occurred during such realizations ... something about October? ... :)
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by michaelochurch on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @07:16PM (#5411307)
Health insurance is non-negotiable and shouldn't have an employee contribution. The rest of the benefits are more negotiable. 401k becomes important in your 30s when you start realizing that you're not going to be young forever. Conference budget is a nice-to-have but conferences shouldn't come out of your vacation-- that's a fuck-you if they do.

Regarding compensation: the total package should be enough that people don't worry about money. Ever. If you're doing your job, you may not make them rich but you pay enough that people aren't worried about daily living expenses.

The issue here-- why benefits are so important-- is that VC-istan startups are in such a state where the concerns of a 45-year-old with kids are seen as freaky and unusual. There's a very large talent pool that's being overlooked.

Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by wyclif on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @09:03PM (#5412029)
"There's no shortage of smart, hardworking engineers. There's a shortage of smart, hardworking engineers willing to work for very little money." ~ David "Pardo" Keppel
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by danielweber on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:03PM (#5411672)
God, you reminded me of a start-up where the independently wealthy CEO kept on bitching out loud in the office, three years after the fact, about early-round employees that demanded health insurance (but were willing to work for peanuts).
Re:Benefits matter, or why I won't work for your Y Combinato... by bearmf on Wednesday March 20, 2013 @08:43PM (#5411913)
Lost of large companies have employee contributions. No-premium health insurance is not a standard benefit outside of a few technology companies.