In case that you have not realized it, you are not paying any money. You are loaning with loan-shark rates. Have you ever heard of a loan-shark losing money?
Things are much more complicated than black or white.
Greece and Cyprus are not independent countries. Their very existence was built on loan. Loan with a purpose. And this purpose fulfills as we speak.
These countries' sovereignty is more than a joke, more than a century old.
You feel cheated. Greeks (people living in Cyprus are also Greeks) feel cheated. Every single person feels cheated.
Sadly, we live in the dystopian future where international mega-corporations (a.k.a banks) have more power than some countries.
You can however blame the rotten democratic system that we live by. You can blame human kind's greedy nature.
But you can't blame people of being stupid. The society can only be evaluated by the way it treats its weakest members. You can't blame stupid. You must protect them. This is what makes a society virtuous. Protecting its weakest links. Everything else is pure low-level greediness instinct that has driven us from living into caves to the modern world.
If thinking that poor nations had it coming helps you keep your conscious clean, so be it.
But it has always been about survival of the fittest and not survival of everybody and apparently it will keep being this way. Until human kind becomes one. Above races, religions, borders and whatever.
Amen :)
O yes I am. I'm paying taxes here to keep your economy afloat. I don't mind that, but I'm not going to respond all of the rest you posted.
Can you see how stupid this is?
Little guys fight each other. And the winner gets eaten by the big guy (= bank).
Do we need to rethink how our economy works? Yes. Do we need to help Cyprus, Italy, Spain? Yes. Partially because it is in out best (Dutch) interests, but also because they are European brethren. Is it okay to ask the locals for a sacrifice themselves? Yes.
I know I'm living in one of the richest countries in the world. I don't mind helping another country. I understand that losing 6.75% of your savings hurts.
This is the way it's supposed to be.
Also the problem is not losing 6.75 of ours savings. For most Greek people it's 0 * 6.75 anyway.
The problem is that I am poor. My country is poor. My country was born poor. My country was funded from the beginning of its existence because of being born poor. My country has always been and will always be poor.
But now somebody decided that we are not poor enough. And there is nothing that we can do about it.
And while at it, that same somebody is trying to make your life less comfortable and blame me for it.
This is a scheme over personal economics. It escalates at country level. Further above what some countries or even coalitions of countries can cope with.
And let's not get started with black market money in Swiss or wherever banks. Everything is plain pretense.
My country has always been and will always be poor.
You feel no connection to ancient Greece? Your ancestors created astonishing wealth - you don't think you can anymore?My ancient ancestors...
They were selfish imperialists that built their legacy with wars and slaves.
Even if we could do it again in the present day, personally I wouldn't want it. But there is no other way, is there?
And let's just think about it:
We could build today a monument that it would still be there in 3,000 years. But it would take the lives of 10,000 slaves. Should we do it? Shamelessly exploit people that will die anyway some day, so that we can show off in 3,000 years?
I vote for no.
And by "my country" I refer to the modern version created in the mid 19th century. There is no continuity with the ancient times (at least in political terms). And there was no country in the ancient times to begin with. Only city-states. A few rich and many poor :)
Therefore, I think that my country is definitely poor. Forever and ever.
The Cypriot people are not being asked if they want to sacrifice their savings - it is being taken from them by force!
The money isn't being taken by force. Money is a social construct, and the people in charge of taking care of that social construct are fiddling with the numbers. There are no jackbooted thugs going into people's homes and relieving them of physical property, which is what you're alluding to.
Whethere it's morally right or not (or somewhere in-between) is a wholly different question, which isn't helped by hyperbole like you're presenting here.
Which is exactly the same as jackbooted thugs going into people's homes and relieving them of physical property.
And it's morally wrong. Like putting tags on people to make fun of them.
I mean hard working bankers that deserve their 50,000% annual bonuses for destroying people's lives.
The local people are not bankrupt.
But they are soon-to-be.
What is a better option? Maybe don't buy a new car?
Let them rot. They're too far away. I can't smell the foul scent. I don't care.
2: It's a temporary measure that will only lead to a worse temporary measure.
3: GOTO 2;
That's the biggest problem of them all.
Earlier, in biblical period, god would flush the toilet and things would start from scratch.
Now, we can't afford to flush.
Also, there is nothing useful about realizing it.
We simply have to accept it.
The problem is that the elected officials promised the exact opposite, in order to get elected.
The only European country still standing on its feet without any outside help is Germany, but that could end very quickly end once every other country around her begins the slide into depression. For better or worse, we're all in this together.
During the boom so much credit aka money was created from what is now nothing but people assume they will get to keep this "wealth".
Of course, we had it coming.
Let's see your economy strive without the southern suckers.
Oh no, wait.
We have the chinese market now. Screw the southern suckers.
I don't think it's hyperbole to suggest that this sort of action could lead to pan-european war in the next decade.
It radically undermines trust in the banking system, in the social contract, and in democratic government. If you undermine the social contract and rule by fiat, as the EU has in Greece and Cyprus, it leads to extremism, break down of social order, an ever more polarised political situation, and ultimately revolution and/or dictatorship (see France late 1780s, Russia 1900-1917, Germany 1920-30s). That's not a Europe I want to see and this can happen quite quickly even in an apparently stable society when the foundations are weakened progressively.
The EU was founded to avoid precisely this sort of escalation of conflict and blaming of others by sharing the wealth of nations and promoting ever closer union. They could easily afford to support Cyprus through these hard times against the banks, in fact they're a big enough trading block to simply default wholesale against their creditors and start again, but they have chosen instead the road of muddy compromise, where they end up defaulting piecemeal (as in Greece, which effectively defaulted), but by stealth and in secret and with draconian conditions attached, and which hurts the poorer people of the EU disproportionately by forcing through massive cuts which don't actually solve the problem. Is Greece doing better than Iceland at the moment, is the austerity working? How will paying this bill help Cyprus?
They're undermining trust in the entire EU and EUR project, and there may come a time when governments are overthrown and countries leave the union because of it, and even (and I sincerely hope not) where countries go to war over it. It's fascinating and a little sad to see the same mistakes being made all over again.
Mostly unrelated and that kid was really stupid, but just the other day a 20-year old Greek footballer used the Nazi salute after scoring a goal for his team (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-21822165). Like I said, that kid is beyond stupid, but I think it shows that some sort of extremism (right-wing, left-wing) is slowly making its way onto the front scene.
Hopefully irrelevant factoid: Cyprus is the 6th country in the world in number of guns per capita [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Number_of_guns_per_capita_by_c...
In essence, The Irish have bailed out Germany and the rest of Europe. In the case of Ireland, they are now sitting on 80+ billions of Euros of debt that they have to pay back.
And remember: There was no haircut for the bondholders.
The blaming and hating is growing. The EU received the Nobel peace prize just in time, could be too late some years later.
[edit] And yeah, this is a very crude way to raise the money. Given more time, a better way is probably possible. But I think time is at a premium now.
If you lose sight of the individual in all this, then I suppose it isn't a punishment. But I don't think it's appropriate to do that.
It's just an excuse to take your money too and blame someone else for doing so.
How can you think getting a bigger loan to pay current loan is a good strategy. It will work only if the economy improves. If the economy tanks, it is not going to work. It is only going to increase the losses for the lenders ultimately.
People much greater than my humble me couldn't provide a non-temporary solution.
And I must admit that I don't carry the most temperate mind around.
At theoretical level, the only solution that is intriguing me for many years now is a society's hard reset via global bank run.
Rebuild everything from the ashes and maybe learn from the past mistakes this time.
Replace money with something else. Maybe something of non-long-term-accumulative nature.
But also, on the same time, find a fair way to compensate for the fruits of one's excessive labor.
Not the smoothest thing to do.
The inconvenience of millions will be the salvation of billions. Fair or not?
The real problem is that human's greed-driven ingenuity will abuse, overcome and nullify every kind of systemic fairness.
We live in an infinite loop of imbalance.
Unless the next asteroid is big enough and hits the target before we set our GPS navigators to the deep space :)
Instead, "they" lied and cheated, and effectively nullified any mutual agreement. The only reason why they're still getting the help is because the alternative would be much worse.
I don't see the problem to be honest. We (I live in the Netherlands) are paying a lot of money to help them out, which is okay. But yeah we're asking the inhabitants of Cyprus for a sacrifice too. The 10% tax is a very crude way to implement this, but dire times need dire actions.