News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by Irregardless on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:20PM (#5375896)
In the conclusion, you say:

> What’s next? Well you can extend your app by adding payment options, email notifications, user feedback. . .

Aren't those core features of AirBnB? That's like saying "Next, you build the entire application." So you really haven't built a clone at all, you've just built an empty shell with a tiny fraction of the functionality.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by jenius on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:40PM (#5376027)
This is absolutely true and I agree, but you also totally missed the point of the post, and this criticism is totally off-base.

OP wrote this post as a demonstration of how to get a native ios app prototype up and running quickly using tools like app design vault and stackmob, not in order to make any comments about airbnb or to actually try to make a full business out of this clone. The basic Airbnb interface/data structure was simply used as an example framework for the author to show off the tools and workflow.

I do think that an adjustment to the title would help to clear up the confusion around this -- this is not the only post in this thread making a similar criticism.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by Irregardless on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:39PM (#5376468)
Maybe the title should be modified to better fit the content of the post then? If I wrote an article called "How to build a Lamborghini clone for $2,500" but demonstrated how to put a look-alike body kit on an old Honda Civic, you would be justified in telling me that I didn't accomplish my stated intention.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by mbesto on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:29PM (#5376777)
It's not totally off-base. The OP wrote:

"Luckily, with the availability of backend services and tools like StackMob, you can fairly quickly come up with a very functional app in a matter of hours."

It's not a functional app unless it has all of the back-end structures that make the actual thing an 'application'.

The basic Airbnb interface/data structure was simply used as an example framework for the author to show off the tools and workflow.

That was implied, but not stated, hence the criticism. Hyperbole wins again!

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by snoman on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:00PM (#5376184)
This just in: when you have a proven example application, an existing design, pre-fab content, known behavior... writing software is easy.

I'm fighting the urge to say "no shit".

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by sergiotapia on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:58PM (#5376957)
Wow, seeing this at the top of this thread really makes me feel HN is jumping the proverbial shark.

The entire post is not a "Hey, fuck BnB, we can do it in 2 hours!". It's about how you can quickly iterate an application using StackMob.

It's a tech demo, showing off StackMob, not putting down BnB.

Christ. :/

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by Irregardless on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:23PM (#5377081)
> It's about how you can quickly iterate an application using StackMob

Then the title should say that.

If you dupe people into reading your article by using a misleading headline, you should be held accountable for it.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by 3am on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:06PM (#5376997)
Well, they used a link bait title to get click-throughs, and the article didn't live up to their hype. It's unsurprising that some people are calling them out on it.

EDIT - I'm glad this is off the front page. This etiquette kick that HN is on is really tiresome. None of you or me (except maybe pg) are the arbiters of what defines polite discourse here. And shame on me for getting dragged into it. The policy I strive towards is that if it's a bad comment (egregiously wrong, trolling, etc) I downvote, if it's a good comment I upvote, and if it's interesting and I have something interesting to add I upvote and reply. It's not the worst policy.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by chime on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:17PM (#5377052)
I'm sorry to add fuel to the fire but I've noticed this last few weeks. Almost every single top post to every new Show HN type submission is a brutal teardown or sometimes unfounded criticism. This kind of behavior does not encourage sharing of neat things we build. I've made many things and shared on HN in the past but I'm pretty sure if I were to submit similar things today I'd be called out for not supporting PlatformOfChoice in v0.1a or using improper font-size. I would be nice if people constructively criticized the core product being shared not the tertiary aspects.

If I write a blog post on how to find and fix leaks in single-page JS apps in various browsers, the top post shouldn't be the one complaining about how Chrome takes more memory than Firefox. Comments like that are certainly on topic because memory leaks end up using more memory by definition. The problem is that those kind of comments are too generic to improve anything for anyone but incite enough vitriol to get voted to the top. The top post should be the one finding faults with my leak handling practices and suggesting better methods of doing the same.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by PotatoEngineer on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:43PM (#5377215)
Almost every single non-reply post on this article is criticizing how much the app isn't AirBnB. Maybe the new measure of success on HN is finding the excellent discussions under those criticizing posts? Those criticizing top posts always have a huge amount of discussion under them.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by bromang on Thursday March 14, 2013 @04:08PM (#5377374)
why did you use the word "iterate"[1] in this context?

[1]http://www.thefreedictionary.com/iterate

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by sergiotapia on Thursday March 14, 2013 @07:55PM (#5378384)
Google it.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by rmoriz on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:35PM (#5375989)
Using Stripe, disquss etc it should be doable in a couple of hours/days.

Of course the main feature of AirBnB and the large copycats is the market penetration. Nobody cares if you have a fancy backend or e.g. a node.js based mobile app. It's about active users and transactions.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by barrynolan on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:51PM (#5376105)
It is what it is. A great demonstration of developer productivity. And the stack mob API is free.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by colbyh on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:46PM (#5377242)
It's still a more interesting article than "build a blog in two hours" or "chat apps in 3.14 lines of code!". There will always be functionality left for later but as an example of a quick prototyping framework I think the article is pretty great.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by seivan on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:33PM (#5376424)
Not to mention it's based on a third party vendor that not only has the API but also the schema.

Not to mention no time at all was spent (counted) on the app design and code regarding the logic for layouts.

Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by rhizome on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:56PM (#5376947)
"Now, draw the rest of the owl."
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by andrewljohnson on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:14PM (#5377029)
Classic top-ranked, snarky "missing the entire point" comment.
Re:Build an AirBnB Clone in a Day by jonursenbach on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:25PM (#5377091)
It's less of missing the entire point and more of the article being link bait.