Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by hucker on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:07PM
(#5375818)
Some of the evaluation criteria [1]:
* Submission provides evidence that code is in use by other projects, or is running in production at Netflix or elsewhere
* Submission has a large number of watchers, stars and forks on github.com
So the entrant has to prove that it is used in production at Netflix? And why would they care about the number of watchers/stars/forks? If I made a great contribution to something very specific (let's say aiming for the "Best contribution to performance improvements" or "Best contribution to code quality" awards), why would anyone watch/star/fork my repo? This seems more like a popularity contest to be honest...
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by hucker on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:52PM
(#5376115)
Good point.
I guess I'm partly missing the point of the competition, and missed the fact that the entry could be anything(?) and does not have to do with something directly Netflix-related (either customer facing or operations).
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by photorized on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:44PM
(#5377224)
I am not going to debate that. As a long time Netflix customer, the recommendation engine does not impress me. This is what I was recently recommended (thriller? Okay), see anything wrong with this picture:
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by millerm on Thursday March 14, 2013 @06:43PM
(#5378110)
Hah. If you look for the animated Pixar movie "Brave" and look at the "More like Brave" section it suggests "Magic Mike" (Yeah the stripper dude movie). That algorithm needs work.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by run4yourlives on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:45PM
(#5376880)
I'm sure this will be massively popular, but the cynic in me can't help but think this is a great way for a company to do very cheap R&D.
It's similar to their algorithm contest - where they basically had a fixed potential investment but reaped rewards thousands of times greater than what they could have afforded by tapping into people willing to work for free as a hobby.
On one hand I think it's a great idea, but on the other I'm concerned about how this can be exploited; industries built on passions tend to massively undervalue employees. See: Aviation, Sports, Publishing.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by photorized on Thursday March 14, 2013 @02:50PM
(#5376908)
... cheap R&D and cheap publicity.
Much like the infamous recommendation data challenge, that was never put in production.
I am, too, a cynic - and I think their data model is flawed from the beginning (user account vs. household, among other things), causing schizophrenic recommendations.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by cscheid on Thursday March 14, 2013 @03:17PM
(#5377049)
The important aspects of the recommendation data challenge was put in production. Of course, it wasn't the precise weights and models, but the important ideas, namely ensembling and RBMs (which didn't exist before the challenge) were put in place. What you're describing is a misunderstanding of the statement from Netflix.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by jedberg on Friday March 15, 2013 @10:53AM
(#5380881)
I don't think you can reset a profile, but the workaround is to just make a new profile, which will have a clean slate. Then you can go through and rate a couple things to help it learn.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by jedberg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:18PM
(#5375883)
Netflix didn't really pull the plug on the API -- everyone who was using it (which were only a few people) are still getting the same experience as they had before. There will just be no new growth in the use of the API.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by Maro on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:59AM
(#5375766)
I was at their meetup yesterday. What you're implying is definitely _not_ the vibe.
I thought Netflix OSS is great. They're opensourcing something like 30 projects, putting on super well organized meetups with expo like rooms where you can pick Netflixers brain about the software and their internal systems in general, free food&beers, free Ts, etc. It was great.
They do it go give back to the community, to get patches and ports from the community, and hiring of course, there's nothing wrong with that!
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by phamilton on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:08PM
(#5375823)
I was there too. I went with a coworker who is a former Netflix employee. He was almost celebrating with each announcement. His biggest complaint about working at a startup is not having access to the tools they have built up. Netflix has built up an amazing platform that is tightly integrated with AWS. By making these tools open source our little startup has a quicker route to a robust and scalable platform. In my opinion that is awesome.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by nicholassmith on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:45AM
(#5375665)
Or, they're encouraging developers to have fun with their open source projects and putting a prize at the end of it. It's not like there's someone twisting the ends of his moustache contemplating turning them closed source once they've got some good code on there.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by ryanfitz on Thursday March 14, 2013 @01:36PM
(#5376444)
Thats great to hear the ami bakery is finally getting open sourced. I wrote my own ami bakery and it has completely changed the way we do releases at my startup. I'm Looking forward to hacking on this for the contest.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by ksowocki on Thursday March 14, 2013 @11:55AM
(#5375743)
Is it just me or does the repo that we're supposed to be forking only contain the readme and the contest rules? Is there a baseline app to be extended?
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by jedberg on Thursday March 14, 2013 @12:20PM
(#5375897)
The repo you fork is just a readme. Then you add in your submission, which you derive from all of the other open source software in the Netflix Github account.
Does anyone have any suggestions on how to make this clearer? I've seen this question a few times.
Edit: Thanks for the feedback everyone. I've incorporated it into the page.
Re:Announcing the Netflix Cloud Prize
by dpritchett on Thursday March 14, 2013 @05:30PM
(#5377791)
A quick read of this thread suggests that you could really get out in front of things with a well-placed FAQ, whether on a Netflix site, github, or your personal site.
Assuming your job description is something like relations.
* Submission provides evidence that code is in use by other projects, or is running in production at Netflix or elsewhere
* Submission has a large number of watchers, stars and forks on github.com
So the entrant has to prove that it is used in production at Netflix? And why would they care about the number of watchers/stars/forks? If I made a great contribution to something very specific (let's say aiming for the "Best contribution to performance improvements" or "Best contribution to code quality" awards), why would anyone watch/star/fork my repo? This seems more like a popularity contest to be honest...
[1] https://github.com/Netflix/Cloud-Prize/wiki
Or are you complaining about netflix wanting projects "that contain a substantive contribution, working code and which have high community adoption"?
If that's what they want, then that's what they want and should award prizes accordingly.
I guess I'm partly missing the point of the competition, and missed the fact that the entry could be anything(?) and does not have to do with something directly Netflix-related (either customer facing or operations).
http://imgur.com/Lu0xfRV
The contest is exactly a popularity in most of those categories. Make something people find useful and share it. That's the entire idea behind OSS.
I imagine the performance categories are going to be judged a little bit differently, but for most categories the criteria look reasonable to me.
It's similar to their algorithm contest - where they basically had a fixed potential investment but reaped rewards thousands of times greater than what they could have afforded by tapping into people willing to work for free as a hobby.
On one hand I think it's a great idea, but on the other I'm concerned about how this can be exploited; industries built on passions tend to massively undervalue employees. See: Aviation, Sports, Publishing.
Much like the infamous recommendation data challenge, that was never put in production.
I am, too, a cynic - and I think their data model is flawed from the beginning (user account vs. household, among other things), causing schizophrenic recommendations.
Profiles are being tested now and will soon be deployed to all customers.
Disclaimer: I work for Netflix.
I thought Netflix OSS is great. They're opensourcing something like 30 projects, putting on super well organized meetups with expo like rooms where you can pick Netflixers brain about the software and their internal systems in general, free food&beers, free Ts, etc. It was great.
They do it go give back to the community, to get patches and ports from the community, and hiring of course, there's nothing wrong with that!
More Python should follow shortly. Python is much newer here, so we aren't as far along the open source path.
https://github.com/Netflix/netflix-commons/tree/master/netfl...
Does anyone have any suggestions on how to make this clearer? I've seen this question a few times.
Edit: Thanks for the feedback everyone. I've incorporated it into the page.
Also maybe spitball some examples of what you expect people will do with this. Lots of cool repos there but it is a bit overwhelming.
https://github.com/Netflix
You can also write a new monkey in any language you want.
http://www.wired.com/business/2012/04/netflix-prize-costs/
Assuming your job description is something like relations.
However, they are a fun way to recruit.