A few things. Some of these things can be mitigated, but I think then we've moved beyond simple sharing.
1. Your neighbor could use too much bandwidth, thereby impacting your usage negatively.
2. Your neighbor could do naughty things on your Internet connection, and you'll be held liable. Practically, this might mean getting a bunch of DMCA notices. For some ISPs, this has a real impact on your account.
3. Many applications by default share their data with whoever is on your network. Maybe this is OK, but maybe it has stuff that you'd rather your neighbors did not see.
To clarify, I think sharing is great if you decide to do it. But I also think that the uninformed should be advised to not share by default because of the issues I mentioned above.
2. Why is only the penultimate hop responsible for the last hop? Why should he be responsible in the first place? And why shouldn't all the network hops in-between be responsible as well???
3.Yes, it is OK
"Link sharing" is OK regardless of your decision whether to share or not. Don't blame the technology man.
> To clarify, I think sharing is great if you decide to do it. But I also think that the uninformed should be advised to not share by default because of the issues I mentioned above.
...
> This is not necessarily wrong. Maybe I set it up so he can use all the bandwidth that he can get
Maybe you did. So?
> Why is only the penultimate hop responsible for the last hop? Why should he be responsible in the first place. And why shouldn't all the network hops in-between be responsible as well???
Red herring. We're not talking about the appropriate legal perspective of network responsibility, but rather, what is the legal perspective of network responsibility.
> Yes, it is OK
For you? Great! Not for everyone. Which was my point.
And what _is_ the legal perspective for this issue, anyway? Do you equate it with illegal activities in a house? So the owner is responsible for what's going on there? It's not the same thing.
If you could be 100% sure that the originator is the true owner maybe you could have a stand in your argument. But you can't be 100% sure that the network is uncrackable.
This has two interpretations. Either you're claiming that:
1) Just because person A doesn't want to share their data doesn't mean that it's bad for person B to share their data.
or
2) Person A doesn't want to share their data, but person A having their data shared unwittingly isn't bad.
I agree with (1). I don't see how (2) can be true. If I don't want my data shared, then having it shared is bad.
Moreover, this isn't even just about sharing data. It's also about sharing bandwidth and legal/ISP ramifications.
> And what _is_ the legal perspective for this issue, anyway? Do you equate it with illegal activities in a house? So the owner is responsible for what's going on there? It's not the same thing.
I don't equate it with anything. My initial post was very clear about potential ramifications. Perhaps you should re-read it.
> If you could be 100% sure that the originator is the true owner maybe you could have a stand in your argument. But you can't be 100% sure that the network is uncrackable.
You're still very clearly missing the point. I don't care who the "true" owner is. I don't care about the workings of the network. In this instance, I care about what my ISP will do to me and what the government will do to me. I was very clear about this in my initial post.
Please revisit the context of this discussion. The top post in this thread asked, "What is wrong with sharing?" I answered with what I could see as the potential pitfalls of sharing. What argument are you trying to make exactly? That sharing has no pitfalls?
To me the issue isn't people sharing their network, it is having the ability to trace an action back to a group of people who have access to a specific network.
I am all for a free and open web and actually have had several arguments with people why I think that access to the internet is starting to become a human right and should be socialized. But there needs to be accountability for your actions online, and for there to be accountability you need to be able to map an action made over a network to the person or people who did it.
This opens the door to all sorts of abuse.
And while we're at it, we should put FBI warning messages on all legally purchased DVDs, because, yes, they do a lot to catch the bad guys who rip them off.
I'm not suggesting that we have a system where someone can look up what anyone is doing on the Internet at any point in time. I'm simply saying that if there is no way to connect an action made online to the real world such that it cannot be used as evidence against someone then anything a person does on the internet has no possible repercussions. Which I think would have some horrific consequences. Yes there is room for some abuse, and an actual implementation of any system would have to work out how to minimize this abuse, but at a certain point you need to trust your government. They have the ability to do a lot worse to a person then find out what they are browsing online.
Trust is something that is earned.
I am a firm believer in this as well. My post way probably a little too aggressive on the side of overwatch, but I tend to go a little to extremes in these kinds of conversations to push the discussion. You're obviously correct, my point was just that there needs to be some kind of accountability for someones action online. Total anonymity and lack of accountability can be just as dangerous in my opinion. Obviously any real life implementation like this would need to find a balance between perserving the rights of the individual and aiding in identifying and prosecuting criminals.
I'm curious as to why you believe it would hinder the legal user experience? I feel like having some sort of accountability to actions made online in the case of illegal activity would have little to no effect on the legal users. Also I think saying that it would do nothing to stop the bad guys is blatantly false. Yes any computer system is able to be compromised by people of high skill but making it require high skill to get around would weed out a lot of people.
Even though people move around with their phones and laptops all the time, network protocols still want to trust the LAN. Things like rogue DHCP servers, unencrypted HTTP traffic and unsecured devices (like printers) are real problems.
Bandwith caps and accountability are also of concern.
Does IP adress = the person who pays the ISP bill?
I suppose legislation could help to clarify things in that regard but that has little to do with understanding the technology.
What I'm saying though, is that (like marssaxman) I'd like more people to share their connection but I understand why many don't given the technical issues, bandwidth bill, and legal uncertainties.
No - because "absence of bug reports does not mean there are no bugs"
Feel free to replace "bug" with "security breach"
Or, are you going to turn off the public WiFi and pretend there was a breach should you get into trouble?
The whole thing is "it's your network you go to jail". That's all they got. And it is not correct, because they can't prove that it was me or someone else, the same way I can't. But if the argument is only on network ownership, then I loose because now the burden of proof is on me and I can't prove anything.
In other words, you're the one with the problem. It is open by design, and there isn't a problem with the design.
This is such a weirdly negative framing. What's wrong with sharing? I've always left my wifi routers open and unsecured so my neighbors can use the bandwidth if they want.